Pakistani patients facing heavy odds in India

[Roybot]

some of us burn ourselves to get into govt colleges unlike the folks that pay their way through private institutions.

Well fair enough, but some people have more money than others. You can't make generalizing comments like government hospitals have better doctors than private hospitals.

Besides how'd you know she goes to private college?

 

[Mech]

Well fair enough, but some people are more money than others. You can't make generalizing comments like government hospitals have better doctors than private hospitals.

Besides how'd you know she goes to private college?

What i didnt like was how she seemed to imply private institutions are somehow better. Only the hard working gets into govt institutions. And some of the best teachers are in govt institutions.

 

[Mech]

Funny thing is, even if you work to the point of death...the chances of getting into colleges similiar to mine are slim.

I spent a whole darn year preparing......engineering though,...but same principle!

 

[keeninterest]

the debate between government and privately employed docs is like this:

government docs: exposure to extreme cases, cases that would never end up in a private setup will end up in a government set up so the practical experience is tremendous. my father is an orthopedic surgeon, and back in days when he was in a govt setup these chaps would get certain absolutely smashed up cases, very complex but tremendous experience to be gained.

private docs: international exposure is phenomenal, almost every two months a doc in a good private hospital is outside the country attending conferences/delivering lectures/attending various courses/trainings etc and then within the country these chaps are out every fortnight/month getting trained or imparting trainings depending on how well a doc is networked.

dad's worked in both the setups , though i have never asked him to evaluate the two but both seem to have their own advantages, one gives you hands on experience on cases that one would rarely come across of complex nature, the other gives you an opportunity to get trained in techniques which are by far the best the world uses, who are better, take your call, but either way both are working for one cause!

 

[Zeeshan360]

Well fair enough, but some people are more money than others. You can't make generalizing comments like government hospitals have better doctors than private hospitals.

Besides how'd you know she goes to private college?

Get a life .
R u a medical student in India ?
AFAIK u stay in US .

We knw the ground reality abt private medical colleges .
U might not be knowing how the a$$ burns when getting 170 of 200 isnt enough but the ones getting 50 , 60 marks make the way through .

 

[Roybot]

What i didnt like was how she seemed to imply private institutions are somehow better. Only the hard working gets into govt institutions. And some of the best teachers are in govt institutions.

Hardworking and not so hardworking SC/ST/OBC. Are you in IIT btw?

 

[Zeeshan360]

the debate between government and privately employed docs is like this:

government docs: exposure to extreme cases, cases that would never end up in a private setup will end up in a government set up so the practical experience is tremendous. my father is an orthopedic surgeon, and back in days when he was in a govt setup these chaps would get certain absolutely smashed up cases, very complex but tremendous experience to be gained.

private docs: international exposure is phenomenal, almost every two months a doc in a good private hospital is outside the country attending conferences/delivering lectures/attending various courses/trainings etc and then within the country these chaps are out every fortnight/month getting trained or imparting trainings depending on how well a doc is networked.

dad's worked in both the setups , though i have never asked him to evaluate the two but both seem to have their own advantages, one gives you hands on experience on cases that one would rarely come across of complex nature, the other gives you an opportunity to get trained in techniques which are by far the best the world uses, who are better, take your call, but either way both are working for one cause!

Wtfisdissheet .

We were talking abt students frm gov and private colleges not the docs .

 

[Roybot]

Get a life .
R u a medical student in India ?
AFAIK u stay in US .

We knw the ground reality abt private medical colleges .
U might not be knowing how the a$$ burns when getting 170 of 200 isnt enough but the ones getting 50 , 60 marks make the way through .

My dad was a professor at BHU before we moved here, sister did her medical from BHU, so I understand what you are talking about and all the rigours of the entrance tests. But why blame that individual, blame the system if you want to. Besides there are so many run of the mill "Government" medical colleges which are no where as good as private institutions like say CMC Vellore?

 

[riCoh]

how much is the difference in pay of a pvt Doctor and govt doctor??
And why doctors dont want to work in rural areas??

 

[AvidSpice]

Reservations have made matters worse!

 

[Zeeshan360]

My dad was a professor at BHU before we moved here, sister did her medical from BHU, so I understand what you are talking about and all the rigours of the entrance tests. But why blame that individual, blame the system if you want to. Besides there are so many run of the mill "Government" medical colleges which are no where as good as private institutions like say CMC Vellore?

There are just handful of them.

Even if a gov college is placed in a town still it gets better patients and has better infra compared it with private college in the same locality .

I am no way blaming the individual but I am against the twisting of facts done .

 

[Zeeshan360]

Reservations have made matters worse!

This reservations .

It's only in India where a student scoring 80% doesnt get admission but the one with 40% does

 

[Swati Shukla]

Clearely, you have some quality weed in your posession. Do you know how hard it is to get in a government medical college? Do you know the amount of exposure the kids at govt medical colleges get?! You dont get a quarter of that in private institutions. Just because you probably paid your way through it 'does NOT mean the brightest are in pvt institutions. How much do they charge these days? 1 crore?

Do you know the name of my College..? It's name is "Shri Ram Murti Smarak Institute of Medical Sciences" (SRMSIMS), it is one of the only few Colleges affiliated to"ROHILKHAND UNIVERSITY", which itself makes it one of the Best. Do you Know it's standards?? huh..! It has a 650+650 bed hospital. bigger than AIIMS..

Did you even bother to know what we were talking about before Coming up with CRAP?? We were talking about govt. hospitals have best "DOCTORS", not that govt. medical colleges have best students or not. What makes you think that those students who are studying in Govt. medical colleges become doctors in Govt. Hospitals?? What makes you think they choose Rs.60,000/month over Lacks of rupees in Private hospitals?? Please Please Please Try to read what others are saying before trying to be over smart. Please..

 

[AvidSpice]

This reservations .

It's only in India where a student scoring 80% doesnt get admission but the one with 40% does

I was myself a medical aspirant. I scored 152/300 but coudn't even get a seat in BHMS. SC/OBC/ST score 102 and get a seat in MBBS. High time to remove this system and implement a 'reservation based on economic status' system.

 

[Mech]

Do you know the name of my College..? It's name is "Shri Ram Murti Smarak Institute of Medical Sciences" (SRMSIMS), it is one of the only few Colleges affiliated to"ROHILKHAND UNIVERSITY", which itself makes it one of the Best. Do you Know it's standards?? huh..! It has a 650+650 bed hospital. bigger than AIIMS..

Did you even bother to know what we were talking about before Coming up with CRAP?? We were talking about govt. hospitals have best "DOCTORS", not that govt. medical colleges have best students or not. What makes you think that those students who are studying in Govt. medical colleges become doctors in Govt. Hospitals?? What makes you think they choose Rs.60,000/month over Lacks of rupees in Private hospitals?? Please Please Please Try to read what others are saying before trying to be over smart. Please..

oh wow....having more beds mean its better?! I know for a fact that some of our nations best are in govt institutions. So as i was saying...how much did you end up paying?...if its some fancy smooshy place i bet its more than 1 crore