I dont understand why you keep repeating the same thing... theology is a banned topic..so you using theology to debate whether they are muslim or not is a dangerous thing to do..
Constitutionally, in India (as we are talking about Indian muslims) are muslims, and hence your assertion that they are non-muslim 'constitutionally' is wrong, as you are applying wrong constitution.
In your reply please provide the reason using 'Indian' constitution, why they should be considered non-muslim.
Its not theology is just yr personal understanding of my posts n Islam.
The reason why i tell u the same is because u dont have any answer n yr just debating on yr personal analysis or understandings.
We r First Muslims then we r Saudi, Kazak, Malay, Pakistani, Indian etc.
we have to first follow the teachings of All Mighty then of any other state's man made laws.
All Mighty has defined the a Muslim, ie a person who submits his/her will to All Mighty completely!!!.
Now All Mighty says through his book Quran that how n what a Muslim should be.When ever a Child is born we teach him the first Kalima Which is La Ilaha Illallah Muhammadur Rasool Allah.
Meaning There is no God But Allah and Prophet Muhammad is the last n final Prophet of All Mighty!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The Ahmedis dont consider Prophet Muhammad as the last n final Prophet of All Mighty rather they say that 'Mirzai'(an individual who claimed prophet hood in united India is the Prophet. They reject the teachings of Prophet Muhammad n Quran as it was the book revealed on Prophet Muhammad.)
So that is why none of the People not just in my Country but Muslims in Whole World including India dont consider them Muslims.
I believe yr constitution clearly states that every religion has its rights to practice their religion as well as preach it.
this is enough reason for yr Gov to dont designated them with Muslims.
Rather give them their own identity like we did ie Ahmedi. They r still free to practice their faith in here n that is what we expect u also. We dont say u to kill them so do something silly but just dont designate them as Muslims nor with Muslims.