I understood ur post.
Islam is one , there can not be place for sects in it. Country class culture and creed are acceptable, but sect or castism is not (According to Islam).
Its your understanding that the Talibans are considering Shina non-Muslim. You see them as Taliban, I see them as Muslims. I don't see any difference between there Islam and your Islam (If there is only one Islam)
Thank u for yr understanding.
Dude i live in a Country where taliban exist so by even common knowledge one can differentiate their understanding of Islamic teachings which is mostly Jazbati as most of people in my country right now r uneducated n we all know that we can brainwash them easily by using Religion as soft target.
So they killing Shias n declaire them non muslim individually is obviously not important. What we need to do n r doing is to invest highly in infrastructure n education in those areas.So this Bemari gets cured.
Ahmedis are not banned in India. They are as Muslim as others, "Jamiyat e Ulma e Hind" is not Indian constitution, they are some one in huge country. Country don't give them importance.
Ahmedis not banned in india= obviously yes they arnt.
But thats because its not a Muslim country, it doesnt represent Muslims through its law.
But yr constitution makes clear that every person is allowed to follow, preach their faiths.
And in that very faith they come into cross roads with Islamic Basic Teachings.by not accepting the basic principals of Islam, so now designating them among Muslim is technically Wrong and on the other hand Muslims themselves dont consider them same in the same country.
We dont expect u to kill them, or become unjust here. All we want is to not designate them with Muslims n declare them as another minority like Jews, Sikhs etc.
The should be allowed to follow their faiths like they r allowed in Pak too n they dont have any other discrimination problems in general but they r only designated with non muslims in our Country. This same is accepted world wide in muslim world but the reason why they dont have a law to say that is because they dont exist in their countries they only exist in SA only.
In the end u say that ''"Jamiyat e Ulma e Hind" is not Indian constitution, they are some one in huge country. Country don't give them importance''.
My dear friend, we r talking about people who r just 21% of yr population n in that 21%'s maybe 1%,2% people.So we r not talking about Huge Country's huge population combined here. This is the matter of the Muslims only who r 21% in yr country not others so its not a matter n their agreement in this case.
It is solely about Islamic Beliefs of Muslims only.
And for yr info Jamiyat e Ulema e Hind is the biggest Gathering of Clerics of Highest regard of Muslims in India.
Molanna Abdul Kalam Azad, Molana Mehmood Madni(who is the member of yr Lok sabha is head of this jammat) Its not a taken for granted thing when Muslims r concerned.
I say u again read my posts in reply to hindu Guy...we had talked about this in detail there. U n him have same concerns.