India lost war with China but won Arunachal’s heart

[帅的一匹]

If you such high confidence, what is the reason, China isn't taking over the territory claimed. Also what would be the reason China assisted Pakistan in strategic weapons program

We retreated from AP due to inability of logistic in 1962. Can't help but it was true. We assist Pakistan to protect them, even if India is not considered.

 

[Awesome]

And Indian state likes India... Is that something really this weird?

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

We retreated from AP due to inability of logistic in 1962. Can't help but it was true. We assist Pakistan to protect them, even if India is not considered.

You could have provided Pakistan a nuclear umbrella , rather China assisted Pakistan in its development of nuclear weapons and delivery system

If China's intention was to assist Pakistan to protect them how come Chinese never showed up in 1971 when Pakistan was broken up, depite diplomatic assurances?

 

[INDIC]

We didn't nuke india in 1962, so don't need to gild a lily.

But you didn't have nukes in 62.

 

[帅的一匹]

You could have provided Pakistan a nuclear umbrella , rather China assisted Pakistan in its development of nuclear weapons and delivery system

If China's intention was to assist Pakistan to protect them how come Chinese never showed up in 1971 when Pakistan was broken up, depite diplomatic assurances?

If we showed up in 1971, there would be similar thread of finding pretext for 1971 defeat. Not to bother you sir.....

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Nothing that we don't already know , but still a nice read .

China must accept status quo on the international border issue .

India should compromise on Aksai Chin and China must compromise on Tawang .That is the only and fair solution .

Can we please have some pictures of the Arunachal Scouts Battalion ? Tried looking but couldn't find it .

 

[KRAIT]

it seem Indian members are trying to talk about the possibility of a rematch. Do you think it's tolerable?

You can always ignore it. There won't be a rematch. Both Asian nations have different sets of worries, more challenging one and both nations are trying to settle the dispute and keeping the talks at low level.

The interests of China and India are converging in various regions whether its Africa or Afghanistan, so there will be competition but in a healthy way, in a way which is beneficial for both. This is what people are ignoring for no apparent reasons.

So let it go by, I know you will see what I am trying to say.

Cheers.

 

[帅的一匹]

And Indian state likes India... Is that something really this weird?

South Tibet is a part of China. I know Indian hates listen to this one, but just take it. India doesn't admit it's disputed territory, which makes the negotiation impossible.

 

[KRAIT]

You could have provided Pakistan a nuclear umbrella , rather China assisted Pakistan in its development of nuclear weapons and delivery system

If China's intention was to assist Pakistan to protect them how come Chinese never showed up in 1971 when Pakistan was broken up, depite diplomatic assurances?

US asked China to assist in 1971, but Indira Gandhi listened to the generals and launch the attack at the time when Chinese weren't able to provide support due to time of the year when all the passes were blocked.

Another reason was strong Soviet Union stance to safeguard India's interest. It kept China away and made USS Enterprise to back off by sending its nuke sub. This was the reason why China and US didn't openly supported Pakistan in 1971.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

South Tibet is a part of China. I know Indian hates listen to this one, but just take it. India doesn't admit it's disputed territory, which makes the negotiation impossible.

South Tibet ?

What kind of a Tibet is Arunachal ? Where no Tibetans have ever lived ?

Come on , i know you are not this dumb , you are just acting like one for the sake of this argument .

 

[帅的一匹]

South Tibet ?

What kind of a Tibet is Arunachal ? Where no Tibetans have ever lived ?

Come on , i know you are not this dumb , you are just acting like one for the sake of this argument .

Blame Mr. McMahon, not me.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Blame Mr. McMahon, not me.

Why should i blame him ? The border he drew is just fine . That is where Tibet ends and Arunachal begins . Tibetans have never lived in Arunachal or NEFA as it was previously called .

 

[timetravel]

it seem Indian members are trying to talk about the possibility of a rematch. Do you think it's tolerable?

r u nuts.. chinese have so poor reading skills.

but even if there is a rematch the result will be like it was during Sikkim annexation with India... Chinese cant do anything there now. you can open another thread to discuss the results of a rematch if it happens.

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

it seem Indian members are trying to talk about the possibility of a rematch. Do you think it's tolerable?

Nobody said anything about a rematch, we are merely discussing the possibility of defence.

 

[INDIC]

South Tibet is a part of China. I know Indian hates listen to this one, but just take it. India doesn't admit it's disputed territory, which makes the negotiation impossible.

South Tibet, what a funny name when the tribes of Arunachal Pradesh never call themselves Tibetan.