What's new

‘Extorted’ donations: Karachi’s multi-million dollar Bhatta/"charity" business

FaujHistorian

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 20, 2011
Messages
12,272
Reaction score
43
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
MQM tells a huge lie when it says, MQM is the only one targeted by rangers. Not true.
There are others too.
These are not "charities", there are mafias.

Pathetic to see how low our leaders have gone.




‘Extorted’ donations: Karachi’s multi-million dollar charity business
By Rabia Ali / Photo : Athar Khan
Published: July 7, 2015
55SHARES
Share Tweet Email
As the Rangers have started a crackdown against political parties collecting Fitra and Zakat, alKhidmat Foundation, like many other welfare organisations, puts up a billboard calling for people to donate for the poor. PHOTO: ATHAR KHAN/EXPRESS

As the Rangers have started a crackdown against political parties collecting Fitra and Zakat, alKhidmat Foundation, like many other welfare organisations, puts up a billboard calling for people to donate for the poor. PHOTO: ATHAR KHAN/EXPRESS
KARACHI:

Karachi is well known for its lawlessness and violence. But then again, it has a softer side. Of philanthropy and volunteerism and cub scouts. Unfortunately, this softer side too has become victim to the unrelenting violence – when organisations start fighting to collect more donations and the competition ultimately leads to violence. This was the way things were done in Karachi. Until the Rangers decided to act.

The Sindh Rangers have come down hard on political parties and their welfare wings, accusing them of forcefully collecting donations. Workers are being arrested, cash and Fitra slips are being confiscated and a helpline has been set up where people can register complaints against forceful collection.

Read: ‘Uncharitable’ affairs: Save the Children office sealed in Islamabad

The crackdown by the Rangers is now forcing political parties to change their method of Fitra collection, a compulsory charity with a minimum amount of Rs100 per head, to be paid before Eidul Fitr.

The other round

Since the start of the holy month, more than two dozen volunteers of the Khidmat-e-Khalq Foundation (KKF), a welfare organisation of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), have been arrested by law enforcement agencies – a move that has slowed down its donation drive, said a party leader.

Fearing raids and arrests, the KKF has slightly moved away from its traditional method of Fitra collection by sending out volunteers with receipt books in different neighborhoods.

Party spokesperson Aminul Haque claims that instead, people are coming to their offices to donate money. “People are coming themselves to the KKF office in Dastageer or our headquarters, Nine-Zero.”

The party, which would usually set up collection camps from the advent of Ramazan, only recently set them up. Leaders claim that the KKF banners are being removed from the streets. “We are continuously motivating our volunteers and encouraging them to remain strong in these difficult times.”

The KKF was established in 1979, with the name of Khidmat-e-Khalq Committee. After the formation of the MQM, its name was changed to Khidmat-e-Khalq Foundation.

While the Rangers claim that the arrested men were involved in extortion and forceful collection of donations, the party has denied this and said that innocent people are being arrested. “An audit is also held of the KKF and all legalities are completed. There is complete transparency in the operations.”

The MQM, which claims to collect millions of rupees as fitra and Zakaat, predicts a 19 to 20 per cent decrease from last year, owing to the crackdown of the law enforcement agencies.

Read: Charitable gains: Save the Children allowed to resume work

No shops this time

Another party affected by the Rangers’ crackdown is the Pakistan Sunni Tehreek, whose headquarters were raided and several workers arrested. The party runs a welfare organisation with the name of Ahle Sunnat Khidmat Foundation Trust. This time, it has decided not to collect fitra from shopkeepers. “When we go to shops to collect donations which are not forced, it is labeled as extortion. A donation is a donation. It is wrong to call it otherwise,” said the party’s spokesperson Fahim Sheikh.

The party, however, lauds the crackdown by the Rangers, and says that because of them, extortion has gone down. “Good and bad people are everywhere, even in our party. At the lower level, there may be workers who force others to give donations. We have told people that in case this happens, they should inform our leadership.”

According to the party, 11 workers have been arrested. “Those who love us are still giving us donations.”

The unaffected ones

Jamaat-e-Islami, which collects huge amount of fitra and Zakaat for its welfare organisation, Al Khidmat Foundation, has remained largely immune to the Rangers’ crackdown.

“Most of the fitra and Zakaat comes from our activists. People trust us and unlike other political parties, we don’t force anyone for donations. We don’t tell them to pay us the entire fitra receipt book,” said Zahid Askari, the party’s information secretary.

Hence the party never goes to shopkeepers and traders for collection of fitra. While they do go into neighbourhoods and put up stalls outside mosques, the JI says that they don’t force anyone. “Because of some political parties, this holy work is now being regarded a commercial enterprise.”

Published in The Express Tribune, July 8th, 2015.

‘Extorted’ donations: Karachi’s multi-million dollar charity business - The Express Tribune
 
Now we need permission from rangers to whom we give Fitrana Zakat etc?:hitwall: MQM running it's KK foundation and I guess it's second big after Eidhi Sahib trust. Crack down my axx tell them to crack down kidnappers bank robbers. Pathetic think.
Fauji Bhai ziyada Matt jallen keep some power left for Rozajat:D
 
Now we need permission from rangers to whom we give Fitrana Zakat etc?:hitwall: MQM running it's KK foundation and I guess it's second big after Eidhi Sahib trust. Crack down my axx tell them to crack down kidnappers bank robbers. Pathetic think.
Fauji Bhai ziyada Matt jallen keep some power left for Rozajat:D

collecting fitrah by force has become a norm by mqm in areas which it controls.... it is the same every eid ul fitr and eid ul adha, when the local unit rep comes to the house and says "apka to hum nay register main likh dia ab to daina paray ga". how do you justify this attitude?
 
collecting fitrah by force has become a norm by mqm in areas which it controls.... it is the same every eid ul fitr and eid ul adha, when the local unit rep comes to the house and says "apka to hum nay register main likh dia ab to daina paray ga". how do you justify this attitude?

Ye ilzam jhoot per mabni hai, ye MQM k khilaf Sazish hai ... !
.
.
.
.
.
P.S. Is banday ke borri tayar karo
 
Crack down my axx tell them to crack down kidnappers bank robbers. Pathetic think.
So you are not in favor of Ranger's catching anyone who is collecting Fund's illegally. Enough said, you people have no shame.
Good to see Ranger's cracking down against any one who is involved in illegal activities.
 
Have you seen how MQM collects hides of sacrificial animals? You have to live in Karachi to understand MQM sophisticated extortion tactics.

KKF is part of that extortion ring. KKF ambulances have been used to transport MQM weapons in the past. This when Edhi ambulances have been prohibited from entering some areas while KKF ambulances freely plied the roads.
 
Now we need permission from rangers to whom we give Fitrana Zakat etc?:hitwall: MQM running it's KK foundation and I guess it's second big after Eidhi Sahib trust. Crack down my axx tell them to crack down kidnappers bank robbers. Pathetic think.
Fauji Bhai ziyada Matt jallen keep some power left for Rozajat:D

Second big after Edhi trust???? do you have anything to back your words ? any source any news release?
 
collecting fitrah by force has become a norm by mqm in areas which it controls.... it is the same every eid ul fitr and eid ul adha, when the local unit rep comes to the house and says "apka to hum nay register main likh dia ab to daina paray ga". how do you justify this attitude?
There are thousands and thousands people giving funds to Edhi Sahib no matter which area and parties like JI, in neighbor hood every one knows who giving which one. No one care and it's like a race which one get a lot,I don't think MQM or other political parties could harsh on someone as operation is under way by strict hands of rangers.

So you are not in favor of Ranger's catching anyone who is collecting Fund's illegally. Enough said, you people have no shame.
Good to see Ranger's cracking down against any one who is involved in illegal activities.
It's not about giving favor or not it's their duty to took action if there is some complaint regarding taking forcefully funds, MQM is a party which running by it's supporter donations and not like PTI who sucking blood of foreign residents in the name of charity. I donate SKH without thinking it's run by who I also donate Edhi Trust.
 
Fitrah MQM Style
273fc45b83f66d90bcc08a8be534165d6393c241cc9a3ee9205be1122b596326.jpg
 
like PTI who sucking blood of foreign residents in the name of charity
Had to bring PTI in. Note i don't care what PTI does. How can PTI suck blood of foreign residents? if anyone is willingly giving a party some funds, nothing wrong in it. What's wrong is collecting funds illegally. If MQM is involved in this, there should be an action against it.
if there is some complaint regarding taking forcefully funds,
How else do you suppose they caught these people. Someone must have given them intel on them.
 
Now we need permission from rangers to whom we give Fitrana Zakat etc?:hitwall: MQM running it's KK foundation and I guess it's second big after Eidhi Sahib trust. Crack down my axx tell them to crack down kidnappers bank robbers. Pathetic think.
Fauji Bhai ziyada Matt jallen keep some power left for Rozajat:D
If donations are used in threatening this country then its rangers responsibility to stop them , what is wrong in it? They are doing what needs to be done, This city is financial back bone for both Pro-Pakistani and Anti-Pakistani movements, You want army and security agencies to sit and watch how all income of their Tax payers have been used against them and their country?
 
Had to bring PTI in. Note i don't care what PTI does. How can PTI suck blood of foreign residents? if anyone is willingly giving a party some funds, nothing wrong in it. What's wrong is collecting funds illegally. If MQM is involved in this, there should be an action against it.

How else do you suppose they caught these people. Someone must have given them intel on them.
That's what I'm saying supporters of MQM giving it willingly, there are hot lines for complaints by MQM and rangers if some one forcefully collecting it, and this your belief that MQM have support in Urban Sind or not! In recent by election MQM get 90 thousands votes if they can vote it's mean they willingly donate also.
 
I dont understand why party needs to "collect" fitr OR charity.....Charity is willing of a person to give....While fitrah is compulsory to cleanse your wealth ......No one needs to collect it people, GIVE IT...

2ndly, why dont MQM do this to the elite? Those who need the push? - Just curious

3rdly, Edhi is the best option you actually know and see where your money is going....While MQM has alot of illegal land grabs/ public property made into marriage hall and shit like that....

4thly, there SHOULD NOT be a competition to begin with...POLITICAL parties SHOULD be banned from collecting or accepting anything....Religion ko politicize kero gay then only shit can come out of it!
 
Back
Top Bottom