Who was responsible for 1971?

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

nothing, i was tellin him that Bengal was not part of "Pakistan" Plan, its just we have mutual interest (independence from British and wanna be colonial Hindu regime) so we become partner on Muslim league's platform.

Thanks for Telling me, I am grateful. I should also be told that in Lahore resolution by Sher E Bangla A.K Fazlul Haque there were multiple Muslim Nations Mentioned But Jinnah changed it to "One" muslim nation.

dude this same topic has been repeated since this forum was created... and all end the same way... can you pls stop

Have you watched the video? Or Just responded for the sake of responding?

India is the one who is responsible don't make this bull crap a reason .. bihar is the poor state in india. U think pakistan sud support bihar to seprate from Indian and later we blame it was GDP. Keep ur bulls hit with u.

India is a federal state, Bihar is responsible for Bihar. Dont make this bull crap reason and Comparison, When Mujib asked for a federal state he was considered a traitor.

add floods and population factor for east, even if true, we were growing on our own, why you left my question again, where your jute went after 71?

You think I am making stories up?? Jute was the major earning source, Go ask any older Pakistani who knows about Pakistan's economy. Jute products still earn money but the demand went down because of Plastic ropes now a days. But 60 years ago, Entire world used rope made of Jutes.

 

[Max]

Thanks for Telling me, I am grateful. I should also be told that in Lahore resolution by Sher E Bangla A.K Fazlul Haque there were multiple Muslim Nations Mentioned But Jinnah changed it to "One" muslim nation.

ideally Muslim should be one Nation as our Prophet (PBUH) wanted, but we dont live in ideal world, we live in world of inferiority filled Bengali leaders who were doing agartala conspiracy in 1968 with Hindus before a single bullet was fired by evil Pakistani soldier..

 

[Michael Corleone]

Thanks for Telling me, I am grateful. I should also be told that in Lahore resolution by Sher E Bangla A.K Fazlul Haque there were multiple Muslim Nations Mentioned But Jinnah changed it to "One" muslim nation.



Have you watched the video? Or Just responded for the sake of responding?



India is a federal state, Bihar is responsible for Bihar. Dont make this bull crap reason and Comparison, When Mujib asked for a federal state he was considered a traitor.



You think I am making stories up?? Jute was the major earning source, Go ask any older Pakistani who knows about Pakistan's economy. Jute products still earn money but the demand went down because of Plastic ropes now a days. But 60 years ago, Entire world used rope made of Jutes.

i have seen and i agree with it partially... but there will be denials and accusation by fellow pdf members and it's just not worth it.

 

[Max]

You think I am making stories up?? Jute was the major earning source, Go ask any older Pakistani who knows about Pakistan's economy. Jute products still earn money but the demand went down because of Plastic ropes now a days. But 60 years ago, Entire world used rope made of Jutes.

Yes, you are shamelessly making stories. period..

 

[Sheikh Rauf]

Thanks for Telling me, I am grateful. I should also be told that in Lahore resolution by Sher E Bangla A.K Fazlul Haque there were multiple Muslim Nations Mentioned But Jinnah changed it to "One" muslim nation.



Have you watched the video? Or Just responded for the sake of responding?



India is a federal state, Bihar is responsible for Bihar. Dont make this bull crap reason and Comparison, When Mujib asked for a federal state he was considered a traitor.



You think I am making stories up?? Jute was the major earning source, Go ask any older Pakistani who knows about Pakistan's economy. Jute products still earn money but the demand went down because of Plastic ropes now a days. But 60 years ago, Entire world used rope made of Jutes.

India is the reason mody admitted itself that they trained muktibahni it's them who killed gandi they going to kill any sane person in india.
But on topic again it's india who's interfering in Pakistan creating terrorists killing kids and innocent people since 47.

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

Yes, you are shamelessly making stories. period..

You are an immature Kid. Period.

 

[H!TchHiker]

View attachment 377824

You are an immature Kid. Period.

So you are saying there was no Agartala conspiracy ? Long before 1971 ?
Why don't you bring facts and numbers instead of scratching stories
What was the share of jute in that era out of total export ? How much was the earning ? Where did that jute disappear
You consider Mujibur hero and we as traitor we both are separate now so what's the point now ? Hero of one nation is usually the traitor of other

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

i have seen and i agree with it partially... but there will be denials and accusation by fellow pdf members and it's just not worth it.

Agree and disagree what?

So you are saying there was no Agartala conspiracy ? Long before 1971 ?
Why don't you bring facts and numbers instead of scratching stories
What was the share of jute in that era out of total export ? How much was the earning ? Where did that jute disappear
You consider Mujibur hero and we as traitor we both are separate now so what's the point now ? Hero of one nation is usually the traitor of other

The annual rate of growth of the gross domestic product per capita was 4.4% in the West Pakistan versus 2.6% in East Pakistan from 1960 to 1965. Bengali politicians pushed for more autonomy, arguing that much of Pakistan's export earnings were generated in East Pakistan from the exportation of Bengali jute and tea. As late as 1960, approximately 70% of Pakistan's export earnings originated in East Pakistan, although this percentage declined as international demand for jute dwindled. By the mid-1960s, East Pakistan was accounting for less than 60% of the nation's export earnings, and by the time Bangladesh gained its independence in 1971, this percentage had dipped below 50%.


Agartala Conspiracy case isnt proven, All the accused were released by Ayub Khan.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

i am happy we got separated, it was an illogical union from day one, a tiny piece of land thousand miles away from west surrounded by Bharat from all sides.

Geography was not in favor of so called east Pakistan.

It is your statement that is illogical. Tiny piece of land? By West European standards BD is a large country. And that land has so much more resources that once upon a time it sustained a population bigger than that of West Pakistan.

 

[bluesky]

now dont confuse me with numbers, where is that jute on which we Pakistani become super rich?

Jute has almost been replaced with synthetic fiber in around 1975. It does not glitter now. However, its days are coming back. Plastic bags exhaust pollution that damages environment. World is now coming back to the natural fiber, jute. Jute will again become the golden fiber.

nothing, i was tellin him that Bengal was not part of "Pakistan" Plan, its just we have mutual interest (independence from British and wanna be colonial Hindu regime) so we become partner on Muslim league's platform.

1) But, the Indian Muslim League was formed in Dhaka by the call of Nawab Salimullah in a 1906 conference. The conference was joined by all the then Indian Muslim leaders, Zamindars and Nawabs.
2) Who presented the Lahore Resolution for Pakistan in 1940? It was another Bhukha Bangali, Sher-e-Bangal A.K. Fazlul Haq, the then Chief Minister of Bengal. He was the only Muslim Chief Minister in the entire India.
3) In the 1946 Provincial election under the British, Shahid Suhrawardy became also the only Muslim to hold the position of Chief Minister of Bengal. All the Capitals of today's Pakistan only non-Muslim League parties own.

Do not you think now that Bengali Nata Muslims were forwarding and struggling to establish Pakistan and they did more than the present fanatic Pakistanis did. Anyway, Pakistan Chapter has ended with us. Who wants to be a part of a country where even yesterday 72 people were killed by the fanatic Muslims?

 

[H!TchHiker]

Agree and disagree what?



The annual rate of growth of the gross domestic product per capita was 4.4% in the West Pakistan versus 2.6% in East Pakistan from 1960 to 1965. Bengali politicians pushed for more autonomy, arguing that much of Pakistan's export earnings were generated in East Pakistan from the exportation of Bengali jute and tea. As late as 1960, approximately 70% of Pakistan's export earnings originated in East Pakistan, although this percentage declined as international demand for jute dwindled. By the mid-1960s, East Pakistan was accounting for less than 60% of the nation's export earnings, and by the time Bangladesh gained its independence in 1971, this percentage had dipped below 50%.


Agartala Conspiracy case isnt proven, All the accused were released by Ayub Khan.

Mujib crony admit that agartala conspiracy was right on the floor of bangladesh assembly..
A traitor testimony in assembly as a herioc act
"In 2010, and on the anniversary of the withdrawal on 22 February 2011, surviving conspirator and Deputy Speaker of the Parliament Shawkat Ali confessed to the parliament at a point of order that the charges read out to them were accurate, stating that they formed a Shangram Parishad (Action Committee) under Sheikh Mujib for the secession of East Pakistan"..
% % no number no figures how much jute was composed of all the export "Pat-sun k Khusbhu Islamabd k roads sa ati hain" That was disappeared after creation..Sigh what a irony of nature...Bangladesh will never be able to stand as independent nation now in-front of India..

Jaffar az Bengal, Mujib az bangal Hasina az bangal nang-e-deen, nang-e-millat, nang-e-watan"

 

[Bilal9]

Guys forty five years have passed. Just let it go. Take some lessons but look forward not backwards.

 

[monitor]

Almost same in your charat as well, very little difference, where that jute went after you left Pakistan..? it was all conspirecy therories of inferiority sicken bengali leaders.

http://southasiainvestor.blogspot.com/2011/12/economic-comparison-between-bangladesh.html

One of irony of jute was many jute mills were burn down after smuggling to India which they exported as Indian jute and capture Bangladeshi market.

 

[Max]

But, the Indian Muslim League was formed in Dhaka by the call of Nawab Salimullah in a 1906 conference. The conference was joined by all the then Indian Muslim leaders, Zamindars and Nawabs.

does it matter? what it gained till 1936? it was nothing without Northern leadership..

2) Who presented the Lahore Resolution for Pakistan in 1940? It was another Bhukha Bangali, Sher-e-Bangal A.K. Fazlul Haq, the then Chief Minister of Bengal. He was the only Muslim Chief Minister in the entire India.
3) In the 1946 Provincial election under the British, Shahid Suhrawardy became also the only Muslim to hold the position of Chief Minister of Bengal. All the Capitals of today's Pakistan only non-Muslim League parties own.

what if he presented? idea of Pakistan was much older, Iqbal, Rahmat Ali etc purposed this even before. what it have to do with my post? btw Punjab was always under Muslim Prime ministers during British rule.

Do not you think now that Bengali Nata Muslims were forwarding and struggling to establish Pakistan and they did more than the present fanatic Pakistanis did. Anyway, Pakistan Chapter has ended with us. Who wants to be a part of a country where even yesterday 72 people were killed by the fanatic Muslims?

There was no need of this shit, tell me which part of my post have burned your ugly arse so i can remove that..

@Oscar @waz @Khafee

You are an immature Kid. Period.

Keep living in ur delusions.. son.. you did nothing for us. Pakistan was always ahead of you in economic indicators and we were able to sustain it without your precious jute.

 

[Saiful Islam]

Stop wasting your time foolish people. Pakistan stays as Pakistan & Bangladesh stays as Bangladesh. What benefit is it bickering about something that should be left in the past.