Muslim invasion created Dalits and tribals in India, says RSS

[jbond197]

So you are now admitting that they were High-Low caste division in Indian society even before the colonial missionaries came???

If we go by what the topic is about then they ought to be there before Britishers as Muslims came before them.

 

[The Unnamed]

By that same logic, why din't the Shudra's appoint themselves higher caste ?

Why din't the shudra's take over Hinduism ? ..... what stopped them ? surely you have to wonder about such simple questions.

because power was taken away from by god's system. both mental power and physical power. by birth they were born into their jobs.

do u not know this ? r u retarded ?

you know what ? because of people like you, our religion is still considered a pagan religion of rituals. you can't think.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

So you are now admitting that they were High-Low caste division in Indian society even before the colonial missionaries came???

Are you seriously asking me if a janitor has the same social status as a Prime Minister ? ...or if that is possible in any age and in any society or in any continent ?

How many years back are you discussing ? 100 years back ? 500 years back ? 1000 years back ? 2000 years back ?

 

[Iggy]

Oh but that argument does not hold. You would like to diminish the flaws of Christianity by passing on the muck and saying all are were equally bad, but that is not so. Just because you believe in a dead man on a stick does not mean everyone else does so. Just because the Christian history starts at 6000 year old earth does not mean the Hindu history starts at 6000 year old earth too. Dharmic religion history is not the same as Abrahamic ones. So no, Hindus do not have to accept that Hindu history was cruel just to jolly please you and lighten your burden.

Is it too hard for you to understand that i am not comparing any religion rather i am saying to undone the mistake of the past than blaming it on others??

 

[The Unnamed]

Are you seriously asking me if a janitor has the same social status as a Prime Minister ? ...or if that is possible in any age and in any society or in any continent ?

How many years back are you discussing ? 100 years back ? 500 years back ? 1000 years back ? 2000 years back ?

Are you seriously asking me if a janitor has the same social status as a Prime Minister ? ...or if that is possible in any age and in any society or in any continent ?

How many years back are you discussing ? 100 years back ? 500 years back ? 1000 years back ? 2000 years back ?

why should a janitor be treated as an inferior being to the PM ? his rights are the same as the PM's and vice versa.

 

[Desi_Dalek]

Is it too hard for you to understand that i am not comparing any religion rather i am saying to undone the mistake of the past than blaming it on others??

Forget about reasoning to him. Some people cannot see beyond each others religion. You should stop before he start accusing you of being either a Muslim or a Communist.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

because power was taken away from by god's system. both mental power and physical power. by birth they were born into their jobs.

do u not know this ? r u retarded ?

you know what ? because of people like you, our religion is still considered a pagan religion of rituals. you can't think.

What "power" was taken away and by "whoem" ? the ability to fly and climb walls like spiderman ?

How does one "take away" mental power ? ...how does one "take away" physical power ?

Shudra's were the one who owned the land and did farming. They were the one's who owned cows. Clearly no one could take away their food. Education was not exclusive to brahmins. Anybody who could pay the fee was accepted into a gurukul. When did that change ? Why did that change ? What drastic change took place that destroyed this system ?

Veda Vyasa was born of a fisher women and today his birth day is Guru Poornima. So what mental power was taken away from him ?

When logic fails, name calling starts ...... so then its time to treat you the way you deserve to be treated.

 

[Donatello]

BJP came with a promise of change and undoing all the wrongs of socialist India. If we did not want change, then we would have voted for Congress only, no?

Don't know about that, since i DO NOT live in India. We get to know India from the people we meet and the media that speaks. However, it seems that BJP is hell bent on diverging attention to useless topics like these here in this thread, what is the point of that? Create further agitation?

 

[abjktu]

If we go by what the topic is about then they ought to be there before Britishers as Muslims came before them.

Nope..There was no major Islamic invasion in Kerala either..The only one was during Tippu reign,that too was in 3-4 Northern Kerala districts..

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

why should a janitor be treated as an inferior being to the PM ? his rights are the same as the PM's and vice versa.

...... how old are you ?

Time for you to grow up and live in the Real World.

Or do you also want to ask why Aishwarya Rai married Abhishek Bachchan and not you ?

 

[baajey]

do u have some issues man ???
I do in pdf with liars, hypocrites and cowards. Nothing personal.

u joined this saturday man

 

[Iggy]

Forget about reasoning to him. Some people cannot see beyond each others religion. You should stop before he start accusing you of being either a Muslim or a Communist.

Happens a lot mate..his arguments mainly revolves around my religion and state..

 

[abjktu]

Are you seriously asking me if a janitor has the same social status as a Prime Minister ? ...or if that is possible in any age and in any society or in any continent ?

How many years back are you discussing ? 100 years back ? 500 years back ? 1000 years back ? 2000 years back ?

You seems diverting things..
Who invented caste system??
Brahmins or Islamic/missionary invaders??

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

Forget about reasoning to him. Some people cannot see beyond each others religion. You should stop before he start accusing you of being either a Muslim or a Communist.

1. Its a "her" not a "him"
2. Seiko is a Christian, so no need to call him a muslim or a communist.
3. Don't poke your head in somebody's else's conversation.

You seems diverting things..
Who invented caste system??
Brahmins or Islamic/missionary invaders??

I am not sure who "invented" caste system, I guess its the Portuguese. If you want a specific name, I will have to google it.

If you are talking about Varna, then that is part of Hinduism and is not attributed to any one particular person or community

Again, how is that relevant ?

 

[The Unnamed]

...... how old are you ?

Time for you to grow up and live in the Real World.

Or do you also want to ask why Aishwarya Rai married Abhishek Bachchan and not you ?

maybe u should move to usa, sweden, norway, new zealand etc..open ur eyes.

1. Its a "her" not a "him"
2. Seiko is a Christian, so no need to call him a muslim or a communist.
3. Don't poke your head in somebody's else's conversation.



I am not sure who "invented" caste system, I guess its the Portuguese. If you want a specific name, I will have to google it.

If you are talking about Varna, then that is part of Hinduism and is not attributed to any one particular person or community

Again, how is that relevant ?

it's you. that id has survived because it has a woman's name. both you and i know it.

@levina