Most of Pakistan isn't a part of the Indian sub-continent

[MultaniGuy]

Please do not use the term "Indian subcontinent".

Use the term "South Asia" or the "Subcontinent"

Thanks.

Sure that may be the origin of the word but as it is used in English vernacular, it does not mean Of My Homeland.

If a Native American comes and tells that he is a Desi, it won't mean he is from the homeland. It will mean he is confused. In English vernehcular Desi is used exclusively by the people of Indian Subcontinent and that includes Indians, Pakistani and Bangaldeshi.


I am not commenting on your nation. I am commenting on your nations diaspora living in foreign countries. Certainly I have quite a bit of visibility in that, they are living in my country and I see almost all the aspects of their life.


Thats how vernaculars works. Do you think you are using all the words according to their original meaning? If that was the case no one would be "Surfing the web". Languages and their usage evolve.


Pakistani have way less common with me certainly. I am of Scottish origin. Honestly, how is it possible that you will have more in common with people living thousand of Kilometres but not with people who were living with you in British empire of India. You may certainly have some commonality with Persians. But for a large chunk of Pakistani, closest people are the ones from Indian Punjab.


Sure! Lets see some faces from Lahore!

So here is what I did. I searched Lahore Market Crowd in images.google.com and too the first image with faces visible. It happens to be the first image itself.

Lets see Delhi Market Crowd. And apply the same process.

Here is one for London (Europe) BTW, to which you claim being close, the same process :

Now tell me which one is day/night difference.

Sorry buddy, we Pakistanis have nothing in common with you Indians.

Even genetics studies could convincingly show this.

As more North Indians and South Indians and East Indians intermarry, the difference between Pakistan and India will only grow.

Ancient India included Central Asia but current day Pakistanis are mostly of Arab origin and are not natives to the subcontinent.

Don't bullshit here. We Pakistanis are not arabs.

We Pakistanis are Punjabis, Sindhis, Pathans, Kashmiris, and Baloch. We have a unique culture and identity. Don't try to water down my country's culture and identity.

Pakistanis are Arabs. Here are some indisputable facts

1) Pakistanis take pride in being descendants of Umayyad general Muḥammad ibn Qāsim who invaded Indian subcontinent and made Indians as the slaves of the Arabs

2) Pakistanis follow tribe system like their Arab forefathers rather than the caste system followed in Indian subcontinent the natives. For example, even Muslims from India and Bangladesh follow caste system for marriages but there is no caste system in Pakistan

3) Pakistan love Arab culture and hate anything to do with Indian subcontinent culture. This is an important fact. People in Indonesia, Malaysia, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Iran are all Muslims but they still take great pride in their local culture and history but in case of Pakistanis they hate any and all local culture and history prior to the conquest of the land by Umayyad general Muḥammad ibn Qāsim. Pakistan's history starts with this event.

Pakistanis are not arabs you misinformed guy.

We are not arabs. @waz has already answered you.

 

[Rusty]

Freedom my foot. Your Arab forefathers invaded my lands and made my forefathers slaves, displaced them from my native lands and forced my forefathers take refuge in other lands of the subcontinent.

You do realize that you ancestors were also invaders why brought sankrit and Hinduism.

If you want to talk indigenous, you have to look at the bush people who are eating ants.

 

[Musalman]

too bad even british dont agree with retards like yourself.

For example... Richard Burton who travelled the entire region and more... researched and wrote a book:
https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.22744

He mentions how one can see the difference even in physical and facial features when one enters Sindh which has always remained a STATE... And is rightfully called the mother of south asia..

Sindh is probably the oldest state/kingdom/country in south asia with its own unique culture.. and has aborbed other races from as far as central asia...

This is a book about Races living in Sindh/Indus... go through it..


That is nonsense.

The word 'desi' is never used for 'people' by Pakistani... but always in sense of food... for example desi ghee,desi murghi etc... you will almost never find Pak calling themselves desis or farmi lol.

As for Panjabis... sire... its always the indian sikhs who call themselves Panjabis... and almost never indian.

For reasons they are proud of their panjabiness and have some sort of superiority complex vis other indians.

So you think Im a retard just because I do not agree with you?
It is sad that parents these days do not teach their kids how to make a decent conversation.
Fact is that no matter what we do, we can not change the fact that we are not middle eastern.

 

[BringHarmony]

Sorry buddy, we Pakistanis have nothing in common with you Indians.

Even genetics studies could convincingly show this.

As more North Indians and South Indians and East Indians intermarry, the difference between Pakistan and India will only grow.

I am a Canadian of Scottish descent and sure enough you folks have nothing in common with me.

But then you folks live with Indians, you folks speak like Indians, you folks dress like Indians, you folks even have common dance and songs, you folks flock to common movies, you folks even intermarry as well and heck about 70-80 years back you folks used to live together with Indians. Sure as hell they would have romped a lot of you and vice versa. Heck your own leader was born somewhere in India, I guess?

If you guys talk like a duck, walk like a duck, look like a duck, sorry buddy you are a duck. Cya.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

I am a Canadian of Scottish descent and sure enough you folks have nothing in common with me.

But then you folks live with Indians, you folks speak like Indians, you folks dress like Indians, you folks even have common dance and songs, you folks flock to common movies, you folks even intermarry as well and heck about 70-80 years back you folks used to live together with Indians. Sure as hell they would have romped a lot of you and vice versa. Heck your own leader was born somewhere in India, I guess?

If you guys talk like a duck, walk like a duck, look like a duck, sorry buddy you are a duck. Cya.

Oh great. We got another poutine eating retard on this forum.

 

[BringHarmony]

Oh great. We got another poutine eating retard on this forum.

And yet you flock to our countries. Begging for visas. Anyways, you are welcome! We are nice folks. Just keep leave your shitty thinking and behaviour at the border. Thanks!

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Oh great. We got another poutine eating retard on this forum.

He’s obviously an Indian.

 

[BringHarmony]

He’s obviously an Indian.

In all these threads there is one single common theme among Pakistan folks. If someone is critical or even so as to be slightly differing in opinion with you folks, they must be Indian. A weird world view you have. You folks often say 'don't hyphenate us with Indians'. Guess what? You do it to yourself by labelling anyone having a contrary view to yourself.
In your universe of discourse there are only two sets. India and Pakistan. And then you say why people put you two together.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

And yet you flock to our countries. Begging for visas. Anyways, you are welcome! We are nice folks. Just keep leave your shitty thinking and behaviour at the border. Thanks!

I'd never go to Canada. So I have no clue what you mean by 'our countries'.

He’s obviously an Indian.

I know but you have to play along with these mentally ill people.

 

[BringHarmony]

I'd never go to Canada. So I have no clue what you mean by 'our countries'.

Judging by the new arrivals in Surrey, I guess safe to say there is a hell lot of your lot coming to Canadian shores than the other way round.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

I'd never go to Canada. So I have no clue what you mean by 'our countries'.



I know but you have to play along with these mentally ill people.

Lol. These are the only ones who lie about their ethnicity to abuse others.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

I am a Canadian of Scottish descent and sure enough you folks have nothing in common with me.

But then you folks live with Indians, you folks speak like Indians, you folks dress like Indians, you folks even have common dance and songs, you folks flock to common movies, you folks even intermarry as well and heck about 70-80 years back you folks used to live together with Indians. Sure as hell they would have romped a lot of you and vice versa. Heck your own leader was born somewhere in India, I guess?

If you guys talk like a duck, walk like a duck, look like a duck, sorry buddy you are a duck. Cya.

LIES.......LOL.................Imran Khan was born in 1952 in Lahore, Pakistan:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imran_Khan

..........you've blown your cover and given away that you're an indian.... ........so much so for being a "Scottish Canadian"...........

 

[BringHarmony]

LIES.......LOL.................Imran Khan was born in 1952 in Lahore, Pakistan:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imran_Khan

..........you've given blown your cover and given away that you're an indian.... ........so much so for being a "Scottish Canadian"...........

Weren't you guys fighting about some building in Mumbai few days back? About some of your really important leader being born there or lived there?

And please layoff so many smileys. For a person claiming to have lived for 30 years or more, you appear as 5 years old.

And how come do you deduce that I am not a Canadian? Because I don't know your current leader's birthplace? That's weird thinking.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Weren't you guys fighting about some building in Mumbai few days back? About some of your really important leader being born there or lived there?

And please layoff so many smileys. For a person claiming to have lived for 30 years or more, you appear as 5 years old.

And how come do you deduce that I am not a Canadian? Because I don't know your current leader's birthplace? That's weird thinking.

Nice attempt at backtracking........

Think you were talking about the Jinnah house. But he passed away in 1948. You're not insinuating that Imran Khan was born in mumbai are you?.........

So what part of Scotland do you originate from? Please note that Scotland is not in india....

 

[BringHarmony]

So what part of Scotland do you originate from? Please note that Scotland is not in india....

I didn't. My forefathers came from there. Quite a while back. I didn't guess "Scottish descent" would be so confusing for someone claiming to have spent 30 years in London. You sure it was London and not Lahore? You know it could be hard to tell sometimes for certain folks.

Here is a helpful link.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/descent

BTW, I am yet to hear why are you so reluctant on proving your prowess at telling Indians and Pakistani faces apart, if it is so easy as you claim.