India and China :Jostling for space in the sea??

[Gabbar]

god,who will use tanks in the first round of attacks , tanks will be only transport to southern tibet (your so-call arunachal ）if there will be a india-china war, assuming PLA cross the Himalayas,it will be just 400miles from New Delhi ,tank is useless then.sorry,PLA is not interest in New Delhi,PLAN just need to keep the IN away from south china sea in the war ,if PLA show up in indian ocean,it will be just a escort mission.

I got a admit you do have sense of humor. While you sitting close to your cristal ball, can you tell me how many divisions of mechanized infintery, and armored divisions and how much air-force resistance you are expecting from Indian defence forces.

 

[Gabbar]

I can confirm the validity of this. Here's some approximate numbers:

US imports >95%
Europe imports ~100%
India imports ~90%
China imports ~65% (can be reduced to 30% if use local reserves)

These numbers are based not on 'reserves booked' by national oil & gas companies, rather one where the reserves are located. For example, the "North Sea" has been a mature field for last 30 years!!! Do you guys know that Egypt has produced MORE oil than ALL OF NORTH SEA COMBINED -- while Egyptian fields still producing well for another few decades, the North Sea has been at break-loss for the last decade?

If any pipelines or refineries or tankers or wells are attacked, you can rest assured EVERYONE will be affected. Both buyers and sellers will see all of their investments blown up. So this discussion about India attacking China is immature and childish. Please close the thread or move-on.

You are absolutely right, India will never attack China. India does not have enough means for long war, especialy with China. India just needs to have enough defence to repel any attack. And I also dont believe that China will attack India. I think there are enough smart people on both sides to realize that war will not solve any thing, dialoge and trust is the way to go.

 

[praveen]

god,who will use tanks in the first round of attacks , tanks will be only transport to southern tibet (your so-call arunachal ）

You can't use tanks there geography does'nt help you

if there will be a india-china war, assuming PLA cross the Himalayas,it will be just 400miles from New Delhi

,
Can you sustain your LOC?can you sustain your logistics?Can you cross the himalayas?.They are the worlds greatest geographical barriers .Atmost you can do a punitive expedeition in arunachal nothing more than that can be done.What about Tibet? who is going to hold the Tibetians there.You also forgot about the terrain after the himalayas

tank is useless then

Not a question of being useless ,you simply can't use them

.

sorry,PLA is not interest in New Delhi

You can't simply get there.The PLA cannot fight outside the chinese borders

,

PLAN just need to keep the IN away from south china sea in the war

You forgot about Japan ,Taiwan ,Vietnam,Russia,South Korea ,Philipines and Indonesia.More importantly US.The PLAN simply cannot focus on India only ,unlike us who can focus on China

if PLA show up in indian ocean,it will be just a escort mission

Two frigates in the IOR cannot make much of a difference

 

[praveen]

same number in 1962

our PM was unaware of the Chinese noble intentions.We learn't something never trust the chinese.You backed even before we gave the response in 1962

 

[aimarraul]

Can you sustain your LOC?can you sustain your logistics?Can you cross the himalayas?.They are the worlds greatest geographical barriers .Atmost you can do a punitive expedeition in arunachal nothing more than that can be done.What about Tibet? who is going to hold the Tibetians there.You also forgot about the terrain after the himalayas
You forgot about Japan ,Taiwan ,Vietnam,Russia,South Korea ,Philipines and Indonesia.More importantly US.The PLAN simply cannot focus on India only ,unlike us who can focus on China

our LOC and logistics in Tibet why am i wasting time on you

like i said, PLAN won't playing a important role in the china-india war if there is not naval port around india,so will IN .there is 2000 miles border in front of each other, do not paranoid if PLA show up in IO

 

[praveen]

our LOC and logistics in Tibet why am i wasting time on you

The question is can you sustain your LOCs in arunachal.Why abouthe divisions you need to keep Tibet stable.

like i said, PLAN won't playing a important role in the china-india war if there is not naval port around india,so will IN

InN will be playing all we need to do is scuttle your trade routes

.

there is 2000 miles border in front of each other, do not paranoid if PLA show up in IO

There are also the Himalayas.PLA can never show up in IO

 

[aimarraul]

do you know what is that mean if IN scuttle our trade routes.......

 

[praveen]

do you know what is that mean if IN scuttle our trade routes.......

You have to rely on the US regarding the freedom of seas.If the PLAN is going to come full force into the IOR who is going to watch Taiwan ,Japan and Russia.Heck if the US gives us the permission it will be field day for us .How will PLAN sustain logistics?

Even If the US keeps a CBVG to nominally guard Taiwan the PLAN has a nightmare scenario

 

[praveen]

idiot ,it will not be a border war anymore,i don't think anyside will have energy doing business then

It will be a spill of the border war.For us we will be having energy India
does not have the choke points that China suffers from.India can sustain its logistics

 

[aimarraul]

It will be a spill of the border war.For us we will be having energy India
does not have the choke points that China suffers from.India can sustain its logistics

how can you understand china won't suffer of any resources if there is war。。。。。china is not japan who is lack of everything ,china's enconmic will hurt then,so will india's

 

[SinoIndusFriendship]

It will be a spill of the border war.For us we will be having energy India
does not have the choke points that China suffers from.India can sustain its logistics

Do you realize Bharat dearly lacks logistics? Lack of roads, pipes, oil, food, clothing, energy, water.... so many things. 37,000 communal riots a year. Now imagine what all-out-war will do to Bharat. It'll lead to a Dalit/OBC + Minorities/Muslim Uprising that will overthrow the Brahmin dictatorship. That will spell the end of fanatical Hinduism, which in long run is beneficial for your poor citizens.

Please get rid of these negative thoughts! Yes, India is capable of inflicting much damage to ANY nation (including USA) - but it cannot sustain the retaliation. Peace is the best and ONLY option for a wise person.

 

[duhastmish]

parveen this - pakistasni -china man wont understand he is one of those - who just lick - them bolloks for no reason - this is not the place for their jingoism - this is suppose to be discourse oriented thread not their - cozy honeymoon bed.

he can talk shyt as much he want but it wont matter untill he give us some proof or talk logical.

just ignore him untill he come up with some thing intelligent.

ground reality is that - we did loose some grab on our indian sea - but now indian navy is grabbing its foothold back with the deals with - maldives , srilanka Mauritius island , Vietnam etc.

 

[SinoIndusFriendship]

parveen this - pakistasni -china man wont understand he is one of those - who just lick - them bolloks for no reason - this is not the place for their jingoism - this is suppose to be discourse oriented thread not their - cozy honeymoon bed.

he can talk shyt as much he want but it wont matter untill he give us some proof or talk logical.

just ignore him untill he come up with some thing intelligent.

ground reality is that - we did loose some grab on our indian sea - but now indian navy is grabbing its foothold back with the deals with - maldives , srilanka Mauritius island , Vietnam etc.

Huh?! Delusional thinking - your terrorist agents the LTTE just got extinguished in SL, and Myanmar & Thailand will get their islands back (which was unrightfully handed over by the Brutish). Regarding VN, they are smart to stay away from you guys.

Please, get some sense in your head that you are in no position (and morally should not) wage war with ANYBODY. That includes tiny nations like Sikkim that you can easily defeat. That's a friendly warning.

 

[duhastmish]

sino what did you smoke today brother ? i dont want to cross the line and i will not.

but you are just trolling and making this thread something else - this is a forum made sucessful by some very intelligent and worth members - who actually spend their worthy time here. dont ruin it for every body.

you talking of something which is not related to forum. and show us the proof for your claims .

whats with sikkim now and your ltte claims .

just keep your self updated with news - that will tell you Indian response to china.

i also would like to warn you friendly that - such posts can make people not take you seriously. i read lot of post from you - and i liked many of them although disagreed with many but still liked them.

 

[aimarraul]

we've seen lots of thread like this one recently,indians always claim they can control china through IO,let me make it easier,IO is very important to china and rest of world in the peacetime,but it's nothing but a ocean to china when it comes to india-china war,PLAN won't take a long trip to there ,just like IN won't come to south china sea