Forget Kashmir, worry about your own survival: Krishna to Pak

[SMC]

I like how Indians in this topic use correlation as causation. So much for the logical and rational nation.

Anyhow, the Indian FM is using irrelevant reason fallacy as his argument. The logical Indians probably haven't seen this.

 

[karan.1970]

both india and pakistan are failed states according to me because people are suffering on both sides........

That by the way is not definition of a failed state. A failed state is where the chances of things getting worse are significantly higher than things remaining same or getting better.

 

[SMC]

That by the way is not definition of a failed state. A failed state is where the chances of things getting worse are significantly higher than things remaining same or getting better.

Nope, not really. It's where the government has no control over the country. Somalia is a good example. The failed states list uses media articles (red flag) to derive their rankings, plus uses their own definition of failed state.

 

[Awesome]

Was there any point to saying this to Pakistan other than causing insult? Do you really think we're going to heed Indian 'advice'?

 

[Markus]

Was there any point to saying this to Pakistan other than causing insult? Do you really think we're going to heed Indian 'advice'?

Those words by SM Krishna were meant for the world audience at UNGA. it was not "only" for Pakistan, it never was.

On the contrary, UNGA is the place to show everyone of what you think of others and this is what Ahmadinejad also did.

 

[HAIDER]

Well, it more like Indian counter strike on Qurashi stance on deteriorating condition of Kashmir valley.

 

[Awesome]

So we shouldn't take it personally, is that it?

 

[Markus]

So we shouldn't take it personally, is that it?

Do you guys ever do?

 

[chadha]

times of india, nuf said

kashmir is a disputed area according to the united nations, so what happens in kashmir is the pakistan problem, indians realize this but mr krishna is making nonsense statements just to divert the attention of audience..

yes, pakistan is facing problems, but mocking the hardships pakistan is facing will not help.

kashmir is an integral part of india so u guys have no right to comment on it as we in your internal issues

 

[karan.1970]

Its the standard tit for tat.. Pakistan says something, India responds.. Pakistan responds back, and so on till India and Pakistan tire out or another issue takes over...

That reminds me.. It was astonishing the speed at which Kashmir issue went backstage (in the world media as well as this forum) during the last 1 week of CWG fiasco. Shows how fickle we all are...

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Ok 'understood' sir...aur bolo?

No matter how much emotional you get. No matter how much you shout. No matter how much you run around the world saying otherwise. No matter what you do...

[J&K was with India 63 years ago.

Now lets take a reality tour..

No it was a majority muslim state ruled by a non muslim ruler.
It had its right to accession to india or Pakistan ... just like Junagarh(which wanted to become a part of Pakistan ..but was occupied by india),....same goes fo hyderabad ...

J&K is with India now.

Wont remain occupied by india till long... just like 57% Kashmir tht we liberated in 47-48...

PAKISTANI FLAGS ARE BEING HOISTED IN iOK!

J&K is going to remain with India in the foreseeable future, Inshallah.

Wet dreams..... do u believe in Allah?...coz he despises opressers like india...

Now it is you who has to decide whether you want to spend your time, money and evergy on a lost cause or on a cause which can still be salvaged...

My friend open ur eyes.

Be wise, choose wisely.

Thanks.

History repeats itself...for those who refuse to learn from it.

India has never remained united... occupiers have always occupied it etc... Think again.

So learn from history my friend. You are already in a very bad state, why do you want to worsen the situation and bring further suffering upon your country and your people?

We are handling terrorists.... go look after the worse situation in india where farmers are commiting mass suicide etc.... ur economy has no trickledown effect.... rich r getting richer..poor r dying.

Are u threating Pakistan with suffering? Pal.... chose ur words and actions wisely.... go for a B.S surgical strike and expect a heavy bombardment on delhi.

 

[Areesh]

The old guy is frustrated. Is ki shadi karwao. Sub theek ho jaye ga.

 

[Swift]

That's very surprising,,,Indian taking this guy "Bob Woodward" very serious who been famous in journalist circle as cut and paste book publisher. A guy who has non of his own research, but taking news from left and right and publish books...

As far far as Krishna statement, it quite useless statement which just want to give cover to recent mass killing of Kashmiri unarmed protesters....
Last thing, these present economic scenario won't affect Pakistan because more then 70 percent population of Pakistan lives in villages, where they have no issue of food and daily needs. This present economic crisis is only emerge from corruption and economic meltdown in the region..

So true these 70% dont need electricity, there kids dont need education, water for irrigation , medicine.

Life is so different when u are in Amrica isnt it.

 

[HAIDER]

kashmir is an integral part of india so u guys have no right to comment on it as we in your internal issues

If it makes you happy....like always,..obsession never ends, people shouting for freedom but Indian govt still in love with it decade old obsession...

 

[Illusive]

Slowly up the ante to fulfill the ultimate goal, thats what happening here. First Obama and now Krishna. I hope these strong statements are backed up by actions.

Now what Pakistan? still time left to take the right turn.