What's new

China’s FC-31 has yet to prove itself a match for the US F-35 it copied

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
German newspaper Der Spiegel cited claims from former US intelligence contractor Edward Snowden earlier this month that China stole key design information on the US-built F-35 stealth fighter and used it to build their J-20 and FC-31 fighter jets.

The United States’ airline industry also said that the FC-31 jet, displayed for the first time during the 10th China International Aviation & Aerospace Exhibition in Zhuhai in November 2014, is a copy of the F-35.

Regardless of whether the FC-31 is a copy or the result of stolen designs, various airplane manufacturers and countries often produce jet models that highly resemble one another, which makes the FC-31’s remarkable resemblance to the F-35 far from unusual.

However, China’s choice to display the FC-31 at the Zhuhai Air Show has many implications.

Firstly, the decision was a move to demonstrate the country’s aerospace capacity to the world. The display of the FC-31’s excellent flight maneuverability during the exhibition demonstrates China’s capability in creating a stealth fighter.

Secondly, China aims to establish its reputation in the area to help boost aircraft sales at home and abroad. Stealth technology is important to meet the combat readiness requirements of new-generation military aircraft. Some stealth fighters, such as the F-22 and F-35, are expensive which precludes poorer nations from obtaining one.

China’s launch of the FC-31 could help build its reputation in the industry and attract potential international customers such as the Pakistan Air Force.

Thirdly, the air show will show the development of China’s aerospace industry. The industry’s technological roots can be traced back to the 1950s, when it began building copies of Russian MiG-19s and MiG-21s. It then rolled out improved versions of the original A-5, J-7M, and FC-1 types after several years of development.

The country has also launched the J-10 and the J-11, copies of the Lavi and Su-27 jets, in recent years.

China’s ability to launch the FC-31, which bears a striking resemblance to the F-35, in such a short period of time also shows its strength in the aerospace sector.

Fourthly, the FC-31’s ability to meet China’s combat readiness requirements remains to be seen.

The key to demonstrate the combat abilities of a military airplane lies in its electronic systems or avionics. Therefore, the success of the FC-31 in the future will depend on its engine and weapons systems.

China’s FC-31 has yet to prove itself a match for the US F-35 it copied | idrw.org
 
. .
There is no doubt that F-35 is better than J-31 but even F-35 is not a proven Platform ... only time will tell us how and what it will become ...
 
.
why not they understand ,,, China made F-31 way before US designing F-22,,its time to stop these accusations
 
.
Good news for PAF, we'll get a state of the art stealth platform with Ramjet powered BVRAAMs, 5th gen HOBS missiles, SDBs and PGMs, Rest is irrelevant
 
Last edited:
. . .
I see very little commonality between the f35 and the fc31 apart from stealth. Stealth crafts tend to look similar externally as they follow similar design goals, just as most sports cars are starting to all look the same....the use of computer modelling to design is resulting in common features.

The west and indians are fixated in trying to denigrate chinese capacity to design and develop advanced systems....the truth is china and their industry is moving far faster then either can accept and the speed will get faster. Time to accept the fact china has the capacity to build systems as good as anyone....period.
 
. .
"... that China stole key design information on the US-built F-35 stealth fighter and used it to build their J-20 and FC-31 fighter jets."

Just like the USA and allied stole the key designs of V-2 rocket (and associated technologies) and USA went on with luring (through a clandestine Operation Paperclip) the German top scientists, engineers, and technicians to help establishing her own space program.
 
.
Good news for PAF, we'll get a state of the art stealth platform with Ramjet powered BVRAAMs, 5th gen HOBS missiles, SDBs and PGMs, Rest is irrelevant
I hope by the time J-31 is completely ready our economy also improves a lot so we can induct these beasts in large numbers.
 
.
I see very little commonality between the f35 and the fc31 apart from stealth. Stealth crafts tend to look similar externally as they follow similar design goals, just as most sports cars are starting to all look the same....the use of computer modelling to design is resulting in common features.

The west and indians are fixated in trying to denigrate chinese capacity to design and develop advanced systems....the truth is china and their industry is moving far faster then either can accept and the speed will get faster. Time to accept the fact china has the capacity to build systems as good as anyone....period.


Why do you and your kind drag India into this? India and Indians dont talk about China or your country. We are focused on our own. Seems like you have an agenda to make us look like something we aren't. Relax, China gets its credit where its due. But where are the failures? I see it always being hidden.
 
.
If you look at below pics of mock up at air show in China during 2014 then you will know that J-31 is going to be redesigned and revamped and it look more inspired from F-22 then F-35.


FC-31 v2.0a.jpg


FC-31 v2.0.jpg
 
. .
@gambit what you think about performance of air frame of J-31 if you compare flying prototype and new mock redesign shape which one looks better 5th gen plane to be?
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom