Vietnamese vs Cantonese: Guangdong-Guangxi alliance vs Vietnam, which one is more powerful?

[yahoocom1984]

The Great Cantonese region= Guangdong-Guangxi alliance

Guangdong province: 106 million people, 179,800 km2

Guangxi province: 47 million people, 236,700 km2

GDP:

Guangdong province: 1.104 trillion USD
Guangxi province: 240 billion USD
Vietnam: 188 billion USD

Population:

1. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 153 million (Guangdong: 106 million people, Guangxi: 47 million people)
2. Vietnam: 90 million

Land area size:

1. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 420,000 km2
2. Vietnam: 332,698 km2

Guangzhou city

GDP:

1. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 1.34 trillion USD
2. Vietnam: 188 billion USD

Electricity consumption:

1. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 607,000 Gwh
2. Vietnam: 130,100 Gwh


Guangxi

Navy:

China south sea navy VS Vietnam people's navy

Army and air force:

Guangzhou Military Region VS Vietnam people's army and air force


Guangzhou Military Region

 

[yahoocom1984]

Guangdong-Guangxi alliance is not as powerful as Yangtze River Delta region (Zhejiang-Jiangsu-shanghai Confederation ,2 provinces + 1 city)



Population rank:

1.Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 153 million

2. Zhejiang-Jiangsu-shanghai confederation: 150 million



GDP rank:

1. Zhejiang-Jiangsu-shanghai confederation: 2.1 trillion USD

2. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 1.34 trillion USD


Electricity consumption rank

1. Zhejiang-Jiangsu-shanghai confederation: 1,040,000 Gwh

2. Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 607,000 Gwh

 

[Place Of Space]

Happy new year! I am sorry, but what's the actual meaning comparing this?

 

[Luca1]

I think, you do know that Wo Yue and Nan Yue were independent states in history of China.

Isn't that long time ago?

 

[biendong]

Isn't that long time ago?

over 2,000 years ago.

 

[Rechoice]

I would like to join the whole China into Vietnam.. Happy new year! Forget about this meaningless compare. Everyone can pretend to be a Chinese posting anything.

Nooope.

South China was land of Van Lang Empirer of Viets. Han Chinese have to settle back to ur native land (Zhong Yuan) in North China.

 

[Place Of Space]

I would like to join the whole China into Vietnam.. Happy new year! Forget about this meaningless compare. Everyone can pretend to be a Chinese posting anything.

My Vietnamese buddy, my first sentence is only a joke.

Nooope.

South China was land of Van Lang Empirer of Viets. Han Chinese have to settle back to ur native land (Zhong Yuan) in North China.

Can you be relax at the moment? We are just ordinary persons, not diplomat, not govnment, nobody. He want two province, I prefer to all provinces. Okay, t's my failed joke right. ....

 

[steelseries779]

Nooope.

South China was land of Van Lang Empirer of Viets. Han Chinese have to settle back to ur native land (Zhong Yuan) in North China.

When I visited Guangxi, I find Persons there look similar to Vietnamese.

 

[yahoocom1984]

how can 47 mill chinese people can do in mountainous area in Guang Xi ? I think this is fake data produced by PRC propaganda.

You can visit Guangxi,it's big province and has two "centres", one in North, on in South... In North it's Guilin, in South it's Beihai.

Also the culture and dialects from North Guangxi and South Guangxi are quite different. The appearance of North Guangxi people and South Guangxi people are also quite different.

North Guangxi are mostly people from North China, South Guangxi are the natives.

North Guangxi people are taller, and have lighter skin tone, and they speak Southwest Mandarin language.

South Guangxi people speak some old Cantonese language, and they are shorter and have darker skin tone. The people and culture there in South Guangxi may resemble Vietnam in some parts

But in 1979 Sino-Vietnamese war, most soldiers invaded Vietnam actually are from South Guangxi. The soldiers from Guangxi are famous, they are called "wolf soldiers" in the history

When I visited Guangxi, I find Persons there look similar to Vietnamese.

Actually, The South Guangxi is more similar to Vietnam, the North Guangxi is a little bit different. North Guangxi is similar to Sichuan and Hubei both in dialects and people's appearance, they are taller, and have lighter skin tone, and they speak Southwest Mandarin language.

South Guangxi speak some old Cantonese, and they are shorter and have darker skin tone. The people and culture their may resemble Vietnam in some parts

 

[IPen]

No need to make this kind of comparison, we are not at the same level at all.

If my Chinese friends really wanna counter the Viet trolls, I suggest find some abject Vietnam news and post.There must be plenty of them.

 

[magic-007]

I think, you do know that Wo Yue and Nan Yue were independent states in history of China. Wo Yue and Nan Yue were weak, so Han Chinese have conquered both then they have lost independence until now.

bullshit ,wuyue was conquered the state of chu in the spring and autumn and the warring states period ,but the chu did not belong to china/huaxia then the chu was conqured by the state of qin /qin dynasty. the nan yue was conquered by han dynasty. however ,all of these countries were related to huaxia / china. but now ,we all are of han chinese.

 

[yahoocom1984]

Population rank:

1.Guangdong-Guangxi alliance: 153 million

2. Zhejiang-Jiangsu-shanghai confederation: 150 million
bravo, Nan Yue Guo, Wu Yue can regain independence from China and join to UN.

Zhejiang, Guangdong and Jiangsu relies on raw material from other provinces to boost their economy, and also all these provinces, most farmers don't grow rice anymore, so need rely on other provinces for the food production.

 

[steelseries779]

You can visit Guangxi,it's big province and has two "centres", one in North, on in South... In North it's Guilin, in South it's Beihai.

Also the culture and dialects from North Guangxi and South Guangxi are quite different. The appearance of North Guangxi people and South Guangxi people are also quite different.

North Guangxi are mostly people from North China, South Guangxi are the natives.

North Guangxi people are taller, and have lighter skin tone, and they speak Southwest Mandarin language.

South Guangxi people speak some old Cantonese language, and they are shorter and have darker skin tone. The people and culture there in South Guangxi may resemble Vietnam in some parts

But in 1979 Sino-Vietnamese war, most soldiers invaded Vietnam actually are from South Guangxi. The soldiers from Guangxi are famous, they are called "wolf soldiers" in the history



Actually, The South Guangxi is more similar to Vietnam, the North Guangxi is a little bit different. North Guangxi is similar to Sichuan and Hubei both in dialects and people's appearance, they are taller, and have lighter skin tone, and they speak Southwest Mandarin language.

South Guangxi speak some old Cantonese, and they are shorter and have darker skin tone. The people and culture their may resemble Vietnam in some parts

You know very well about Guangxi Province. Indeed, north Guangxi, for example, Guilin or Liuzhou (i'm not sure) speaks southwest mandarin, their living habit is similar to Sichuan or Guizhou, they love spicy food very much, but south Guangxi are very different.

 

[magic-007]

You know very well about Guangxi Province. Indeed, north Guangxi, for example, Guilin or Liuzhou (i'm not sure) speaks southwest mandarin, their living habit is similar to Sichuan or Guizhou, they love spicy food very much, but south Guangxi are very different.

what province are you from? don't derail the thread,let's back to the topic

 

[steelseries779]

what province are you from? don't derail the thread,let's back to the topic

I'm from dalian, immigrated from Shandong. Ok, but this is true, that's why OP compare Vietnam with Guangxi, they do share many similarities.