RSS outfit wants Manusmriti reworked

[SrNair]

Mosques don't generate wealth whereas temples do. Look at the Tirupati. Assets of temples alone don't generate tax money, non-Hindus sources also contribute towards tax money. So I am entitled to speak about misuse of tax money on some irrelevant issue.

You dont need to check assets .The income itself is running for billions of rupees .
As long as they handles our temples and their incomes ,initiatives like this will always happened under Govt's money .
We dont care how you feel about it

 

[The_Showstopper]

You dont need to check assets .The income itself is running for billions of rupees .
As long as they handles our temples and their incomes ,initiatives like this will always happened under Govt's money .
We dont care how you feel about it

Its your Sanghi government now, why not let Temples property income be separated? But till then others will object to this wastage of tax money.

 

[John Reese]

Do you even understand what smrti means? Where it stands in the hierarchy?

All smrtis can be interpreted as required according to the times. They are not treated as revealed by god (only vedas and closest upanishads are...and even their commentaries are open to debate and analysis)....they (smriti) are firmly accepted to be man-made.

Thousands of years now, we have been debating and revising our interpretation of smriti text, some weakling converted hypocrite (of much more recent and dogmatic religion) opinion on it is irrelevant. Got that?

Now go be butthurt somewhere else that same cannot be said of your holy book...and that no abrahamic religion in its dogma fundamentally accepts any other path or salvation to god outside of their own....period. But at least other 2 have reformed in practice but unfortunately not yours (and probably never will for a good long time).

The results of the dissonance between modern world and unchangeable "god given" holy books are there for everyone to see, we saw another instance in Manchester recently....and its daily happening in Syria and Iraq for years now. And you seriously want to talk down on our internal debates which you have no clue about (i.e what smriti even means). Yes you do stop the show to make us laugh at your hypocrisy, nothing else. Go fail some more.

Do you think that Is his Agenda here his Whole idea Is to some how use Scapegoat And his religious extremism

 

[Nilgiri]

Do you think that Is his Agenda here his Whole idea Is to some how use Scapegoat And his religious extremism

I am aware of his agenda. Just shedding some light for passer-bys.

 

[SrNair]

Its your Sanghi government now, why not let Temples property income be separated? But till then others will object to this wastage of tax money.

Oh well .No govts abondon their cash cow irrespective of their party lineage .
So its a fair deal.a
It is also our money ,you can keep your anger to yourselves

 

[The_Showstopper]

Oh well .No govts abondon their cash cow irrespective of their party lineage .
So its a fair deal.a
It is also our money ,you can keep your anger to yourselves

Then stop moaning when people criticize the wastage of public funds.

Do you even understand what smrti means? Where it stands in the hierarchy?

All smrtis can be interpreted as required according to the times. They are not treated as revealed by god (only vedas and closest upanishads are...and even their commentaries are open to debate and analysis)....they (smriti) are firmly accepted to be man-made.

Thousands of years now, we have been debating and revising our interpretation of smriti text, some weakling converted hypocrite (of much more recent and dogmatic religion) opinion on it is irrelevant. Got that?

I don't care what it is but I do care what it says. Not sure what your "debates" were all about since it didn't rid itself of oppressive things it mentioned and people followed it in-spite of "debating".

Not sure why a Hindutva pagan who eternally feels inferior about his ancestors' continuous subjugation by "foreigners" and who claims that the opinion presented here is irrelevant yet keeps coming back to post a counter-opinion on this thread

Now go be butthurt somewhere else that same cannot be said of your holy book...and that no abrahamic religion in its dogma fundamentally accepts any other path or salvation to god outside of their own....period. But at least other 2 have reformed in practice but unfortunately not yours (and probably never will for a good long time).

Says the Sanghi whose butthurt is quite visible here.

The results of the dissonance between modern world and unchangeable "god given" holy books are there for everyone to see, we saw another instance in Manchester recently....and its daily happening in Syria and Iraq for years now. And you seriously want to talk down on our internal debates which you have no clue about (i.e what smriti even means). Yes you do stop the show to make us laugh at your hypocrisy, nothing else. Go fail some more.

And you claim it's not happening here in the land of "Dharma". I can quote many instances and I don't have work hard for that. Even better just go through the forum, you will find many such instances about what the "Oldest" religion does to its "own people" forget about the "non-Dharmics".

I am aware of his agenda. Just shedding some light for passer-bys.

Yet another expose

 

[SrNair]

Then stop moaning when people criticize the wastage of public funds.


I don't care what it is but I do care what it says. Not sure what your "debates" were all about but it didn't rid itself of oppressive things it mentioned and people followed it in-spite of "debating".

Not sure why a Hindutva pagan who eternally feels inferior about his ancestors' continuous subjugation by "foreigners" and who claims that the opinion presented here is irrelevant yet keeps coming back to post a counter-opinion on this thread


Says the Sanghi whose butthurt is quite visible here.


And you claim it's not happening here in the land of "Dharma". I can quote many instances and I don't have work hard for that. Even better just go through the forum, you will find many such instances about what the "Oldest" religion does to its "own people" forget about the "non-Dharmics".


Yet another expose

Public funds that sourced from the incomes of our temples.

 

[The_Showstopper]

Public funds that sourced from the incomes of our temples.

Public funds come from all sources not just temples. If you don't want people criticizing this kind of wastage, then ask your beloved Sanghi government to separate the funds from temple source.

 

[SrNair]

Public funds come from all sources not just temples. If you don't want people criticizing this kind of wastage, then ask your beloved Sanghi government to separate the funds from temple source.

We are taking our share from the public fund which is far less than the sourcing from incomes from our temple.
We will welcome any such initiatives. Then we will liberals that jumps for nothing .

 

[Hindustani78]

Naah its Narada

“Na aham thisthAmi vaikunthe, yoginAm hridaye na cha Mudd bhakta yatra gAyanti, tatra thisthAmi NArada”.

[Oh Narada, neither you would find Me in Vaikuntha nor you would get Me by following the wandering yogis, wherever My devotee calls for Me, I make My self available to him.]

 

[The_Showstopper]

We are taking our share from the public fund which is far less than the sourcing from incomes from our temple.
We will welcome any such initiatives. Then we will liberals that jumps for nothing .

Fair enough but a better option is to separate them completely which your Sanghi government should do, not sure why they aren't doing while they claim to fight for Hindu rights. Anyways I hope Sanghis won't be moaning if citizens ask for better utilization of tax money instead of wasting it on things like these.

 

[SrNair]

Fair enough but a better option is to separate them completely which your Sanghi government should do, not sure why they aren't doing while they claim to fight for Hindu rights. Anyways I hope Sanghis won't be moaning if citizens ask for better utilization of tax money instead of wasting it on things like these.

Again did I already told to you?
Noone abondons a cash cow .

We are also the citizens .And for us this is our fair share that taken from our temples .It is noone dads hereditary property.
This is our right and we are using our fair share for religions purposes .
We dont cares if others moaning about this

 

[The_Showstopper]

Again did I already told to you?
Noone abondons a cash cow .

We are also the citizens .And for us this is our fair share that taken from our temples .It is noone dads hereditary property.
This is our right and we are using our fair share for religions purposes .
We dont cares if others moaning about this

LOL So you are indirectly stating that BJP/RSS doesn't really care for Hindus/Hindu rights. As I said previously, you can go burn your money for all I care, but to do that you need to claim your share. You can't waste tax-payers' money stating that you also have a claim to it.

If you don't care about our moans, why keep coming back

 

[SrNair]

LOL So you are indirectly stating that BJP/RSS doesn't really care for Hindus/Hindu rights. As I said previously, you can go burn your money for all I care, but to do that you need to claim your share. You can't waste tax-payers' money stating that you also have a claim to it.

If you don't care about our moans, why keep coming back

We knows who cares about us and dont need your statements to prove it.
Our money , money from our temples ,not some tax payers .
Because it is good to hear your dog cry .

 

[The_Showstopper]

We knows who cares about us and dont need your statements to prove it.
Our money , money from our temples ,not some tax payers .
Because it is good to hear your dog cry .

Oh yeah you know that. I am not trying to prove anything. Sangh and BJP's actions speak for themselves.

Not your money. No Till the time the money is not streamlined/divided, you can't claim them for yourself. For example Anil Ambani can't go around splurging money while the Dhirubhai's property is undivided claiming that he is doing this with his share. So as I said, separate the money generated by temples and claim it to be yours until then bear with us. As simple as that.

Not gonna keep repeating myself over this again.