What's new

Pakistan bans English for Islamic words!

I'm absolutely proud of this decision and completely support the government on it.
What possible reason could you have to 'feel proud of this decision'? It's nothing but intolerance and the Mullahs forcing others to comply with their warped and disgusting views.

Oh Lord, rational leaves the window again.
The forum should start a campaign in support of challenging this 'Prime Minister's summary' in the courts for being anti-Islam and anti-free speech.

There is no requirement for such stupidity in the Quran, and Pakistanis need to fight back against this movement of Nawaz and the Mullahs to turn Pakistan into Stupidistan.

The word Mosque (from mosquitoes) has a derogatory meaning and used to describe Muslims by Spaniards when they went to the Masjid!

Edit: I was hoping you would research before discounting it. I don't like to spoon feed people, however here is the link:

The meaning and evolution of the word ‘Mosque’ | MuslimSpeak
As is typical of the warped mindset of our Islamic Scholars, you didn't even read the whole article, and like most of our Islamic Mullah's just cherry picked one sentence out of context to support your warped and intolerant views.

Here is the excerpt with context:

"...The conspiracy surrounding the English translation begins by asserting that the word ‘mosque’ carries with it an islamophobic history with its origins in the Spanish reconquista which saw the end of Islamic Spain.
I am not sure where it first came from, however a book entitled ‘The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Understanding Islam’ (the name says it all doesn’t it?) was the first time I encountered this. The book claims on page 14:

The English term mosque is derived from the Spanish word for mosquito and came into use during the Christian invasion of Muslim Spain in the fifteenth century. The forces of King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella boasted they would swat out Muslim prayer houses like mosquitoes. Understandably, many Muslims prefer not to use this unfortunate name amongst themselves.

It may have been through this book which the rumour began, and it may be likely as the subsequent rumours all bear similar disinformation almost word for word ...

... From our final term Mezquita there would have arisen many of the variations around Europe that exist until today. Mosqueé for example in French,Moschea in Italian etc. It was from the French term mosqueé that the English language adapted the word that we use today – Mosque.

So we may rest assured, a mosquito remains a mosquito and a mosque remains a mosque. Neither Ferdinand or Isabella were ever recorded to have ever stated that they would squash the mosques like mosquitoes, and even if they did, they would have used the word mezquita anyway which was the word already established in Spain for a masjid.
It is unfortunate that I have on many occasions read ‘warning’ chain e-mails informing Muslims to desist in using the English word ‘mosque’ due to its evil origins.. This should serve as a reminder to at least attempt to properly verify such things, and a lesson to not believe everything we read (especially from books which self-describe themselves as being for idiots). Feel free to use the words mosque, mosqueé, mezquita, and ponder over the history of this word and how it carries with it part of our Islamic legacy and is a testament to the great Muslim nation of al-Andalus which for 800 years existed in Western Europe."
 
. .
Personally I can't ever recall using the word masjid but I couldn't care less about this news.

I can't see it resulting in people getting killed (all I care about) so why is everyone losing their mind over it?

Or am I just too chilled out?

Thanks
 
. .
Personally I can't ever recall using the word masjid but I couldn't care less about this news.

I can't see it resulting in people getting killed (all I care about) so why is everyone losing their mind over it?

Or am I just too chilled out?

Thanks
It's going to set a precedent for restrictions on free speech, even more than the existing restrictions in Pakistan.

And it's just STUPID STUPID STUPID, with no Islamic justification.

This is an indirect power grab by the Mullahs, and will open the way for further restrictions on contesting the warped and intolerant interpretations of the Quran that many Muslims are taught.
 
. .
OK lets call Allah as Bhagwan,Namaz as Puja,Haj as Yatera,Rozah as Bert,Tasbeeh as Mala,Duaa as Bintee,Darood as Raam Raam etc etc etc...obviouly the benefits of secularism are not only limitless,there is no end line.

Hello grandpa,

Longtime no see. The issue is about English and not hindi-----. If for so many hundreds of years we have come thru without any issues to the integrity of our religion faith and belief----I doubt if there was any problem showing up on the horizon.

He should have talked about hanging terrorists---he should have found ways to provide justice to the citizens of Pakistan---he should have talked about about audacity of hope----he should have forced Zardari to stay in Pakistan and all his criminal cohorts-----and you brainless people are raising slogans of wah wah wah on a senseless meaningless item.

What a shame and what a disgrace----what do people think that they would do when they meet their maker on the day of judgement----.

What are you going to tell your Lord about the plight of the poor and the weak----about the corruption and decay and about perversity running a muck in the society----.

It is not good enough to say That I was honest-----you have to raise a voice----if you can write----then express yourself----you guys are talking about petty issues that have meaningless----.

We are no Al Bakistan-----we are Pakistan-----.

How brainless and thoughtless you people are that you cant see what he did----.
 
Last edited:
.
Does any body even call it mosque in Pakistan any way?
 
.
Hell grandpa,

Longtime no see. The issue is about English and not hindi-----. If for so many hundreds of years we have come thru without any issues to the integrity of our religion faith and belief----I doubt if there was any problem showing up on the horizon.

He should have talked about hanging terrorists---he should have found ways to provide justice to the citizens of Pakistan---he should have talked about about audacity of hope----he should have forced Zardari to stay in Pakistan and all his criminal cohorts-----and you brainless people are raising slogans of wah wah wah on a senseless meaningless item.

What a shame and what a disgrace----what do people think that they would do when they meet their maker on the day of judgement----.

What are you going to tell your Lord about the plight of the poor and the weak----about the corruption and decay and about perversity running a muck in the society----.

It is not good enough to say That I was honest-----you have to raise a voice----if you can write----then express yourself----you guys are talking about petty issues that have meaningless----.

We are no Al Bakistan-----we are Pakistan-----.

How brainless and thoughtless you people are that you cant see what he did----.

Extremely logical and well articulated comment.
 
. . .
I have seen this trend...Usually those who stay abroad, have this, "More Catholic than the Pope" attitude. Only in words of course.
It doesn't cost one anything to pose like a Sahabah at someone else's expense, especially over the internet. Whatever you are preaching others, you try doing that yourself. That would be enough.

It's nothing specific to religion, when I was posted in New York, I was part of this Indian community, who used to celebrate every possible Indian festival, be it Bengali or Gujarati or Marathi or Tamil etc. etc. I doubt they would have done the same had they been in India. Sometimes, it was like, "Ohh not again!! Give me a break this time!!".


Shree pandit jee,if you put your brahministic arrogance aside for a moment,and stop telling people what they should do
when they are at home or abroad and come to the point of what is being discussed here. And that is simply this ,if your belief in your Holy book calls the almighty BHAGWAN ,then you should not replace it or find a substitute word in any other language,unless over whelming majority agrees with the proposed replacement.It is just a matter of theocratic
principle . Nothing to do with "More catholic than Pope" even if you were posted in Vatican.
 
. .
i am muslim, and socialist... i am prejudiced against every reactionary statement and thought.
is it something else you were referring to ??
But you sound like a follower of secular thugs like Zardari,Asfanndyar or ultaf qaid tareek,where as Imran Khan
regards ALLAMA IQBAL(ra) as his Spiritual Leader.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom