jhungary
MILITARY PROFESSIONAL
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2012
- Messages
- 19,295
- Reaction score
- 387
- Country
- Location
@jhungary with respect to current events in Pakistan-Afghan border , do you think it will be a good Decision for Pakistan to send its ground troops within 20-30 KM inside Afghanistan to eliminate the threat or using Artillery will be a better solution ? and how can we use these MRAPS in this Operation ?
You need to stabilise your border, before you can quell the internal insurgency.
Several years ago, I have said the problem in afghanistan is that thee remote border between Pakistan and Afghanistan is too open, when the US pushes Taliban from Afghanistan, they melt back over to Pakistan, but when the Pakistani try to push TTP out, they went into Afghanistan. The mutual support is there, but we need to push together to squeeze out the Tali. Both NATO and Pakistan did not do that, hence the problem presist today. What we are doing in the last 16 years of war is to pushes Taliban back and forth from Afghanistan and Pakistan. That's it, we did not eleminate anything during all those year ....
For the situation now, Pakistan need to close (really close) its border with Afghanistan and limit the foot traffic between the two country, the the insurgency will lose momentum in the south. I would probably push the Fronntier Corp into key area, stopping the crossing, then using Special Force and hit Key region in FATA area, eventually if both hold, you will have a less chaotic Southern/Western region.
Intrude into Afghanistan can be done if you can control your border, otherwise you push, they melt, you are simply repeating what the ISAF did during the last 17 years.
MRAPS can be used to transfer SF unit safely into and out of the hot spot. It alsoo help Pakistan by keeping the road open inside Pakistan so people are freely able to move within these area, this will increase trust and win hearts and minds for the government.
the situation does not allow a pin point artillery strike, it's always a manuever warfare, you need to use light infantry or special force for the job, then march the army in and stabilise the region after SF dislodge the hotspot. This is what I see as the only way to go.