here is the breakdown k
hindi---sanskrit origin/ for hindus since theyre holy book is in sanskrit
urdu---persian origin therefore a muslim language since it shares most of its alphabets and gramar style with arabic
Punjabi --- written in both sanskrit and persian style
whats the debate here ??
WRONG
infact there cannot be any debate at all in the very first place. because the vey base of the debate is wrong. which is religion even arabic used to be spoken by the pagan's of the region before Islam had arrived & HOLY QURAN revealed in arabic.now when a massage is delivered it have to be in a language so that people when reads it gets the massage which is delivered ,the HOLY TOHRA which from the Hebrew root harah (Hebrew: תּוֹרָה, "Instruction"), Tanakh (Hebrew Bible), or possibly Ebonics or armianic HOLY BIBLE Biblical Aramaic Although most scholars believe that the historical Jesus primarily spoke Aramaic,[1] some believe he also spoke Hebrew and Greek.[2] The towns of Nazareth and Capernaum, where Jesus lived, were primarily Aramaic-speaking communities, although Greek was widely spoken in the major cities of the Mediterranean Basin. Jesus may have also known enough Hebrew to discuss the Hebrew Bible, and he may have known Koine Greek through commerce in nearby Sepphoris. HOLY TELMUD, HOLY ZABUR (Arabic: زبور‎
THE HOLY QURAN in Arabic
what you said as regard to urdu being a muslim language which it is not, can form the very bases of conflict & a source of disparity among the muslims in large if we say that urdu is a muslim language then tell me logically & practically how will a hindi speaking ,bengoli, speaking,panjabi tamil,telegu,maliyalam,assamese, malaysian,indonesian,sinhalese,brunei, english speaking,french speaking etc etc muslims feel will it be fair to them no this very notion can divided people on the basis of language,regionalism,ethnicity,tradition,culture,and nationalism and as a matter of fact is not only wrong but also dangerous
while islam preaches peace,love,humanity,unity, MOHAMMED (P.B.U.H) was declared a mercy to the universe ISLAM is it self a universal religion & not confined to any one particular region or ethnicity when even te Arabs & non-Arabs are equal in islam how can urdu have a spacial status fact urdu is both Indian & Pakistani so even if i take the wrong notion or myrhs that urdu is a muslim language an Indian urdu speaker wether with persian or dravidian,punjubi,persian,bengoli,hindi,arabic dialects is as much urdu like the pakistanis who speak it as well as well as an indian urdu speaker muslim or hindus,christains etc is as much Indian & muslim as any pakistani who speaks it are pakistani & muslim
as regards to the myth of urdu being muslim language you have conveniently ignored that its not about the language in the very first place. though arabic is important & not any other
language be it urdu or hindi or dravedian etc common sense if it is only one language its ok but if it is the specific few then it is inequality & conflicts while islam is albout equality peace & justice
ISLAM is not about the language (except only Arabic because it was revealed in it not in urdu or hindi or dravadian or persian) ISLAM all about its "KNOWLEDGE" & its "MASSAGE"
eg : Surah 96. The Clot, Read, Proclaim
( Proclaim! (or read!) in the name of thy Lord and Cherisher, Who created Created man, out of a (mere) clot of congealed blood Proclaim! And thy Lord is Most Bountiful He Who taught (the use of) the pen Taught man that which he knew not ....
Iqra/ bi-ismi rabbika allathee khalaqa.Khalaqa al-insana min AAalaqin. Iqra/ warabbuka al-akramu . Allathee AAallama bialqalami . AAallama al-insana ma lamyaAAlam
points being here is He Who taught (the use of) the pen Taught man that which he knew not ....)
& not he thought man urdu,persian,hindi,dravidian etc
(Taught man that which he knew not ....)
so what man knew not simple its "KNOWLEDGE" & its "MASSAGE"
