Miss India Sayali Bhagat (Hindu) In love with Pakistani Cricketer Shoaib Malik(Muslim

[notsuperstitious]

So dating muslims is OK even if its unislamic, but dating hindus is not ok because its unislamic.

Religion teaches love, yes!

 

[Patriot]

Why else do you think this thread is receiving so many responses? Because the subject in discussion here is a Male who's dating a Hindu woman.



No, the debate revolved around the fact that Shoaib was dating a Hindu woman. No body's talking about dating in 'General'.



I don't have a problem, didn't you read my post? I simply asked the question for the sake of my own knowledge. I could care less about what any individual does in his life, my question was simply to understand the mindset of people who're promoting the idea that a Muslim dating a Hindu individual isn't a big deal.

Dating itself is a big deal in our society and the large part of the 'Population' you're so proudly referring to, does that under secrecy. Which means that throughout our country it is still not accepted.

But it's funny to see how you just said that due to some 'restrictions' you wouldn't let someone from your own family do something like that but on the other hand you're also promoting the idea that it's not a big deal if some dates or better yet, dates a Hindu individual. Its THEIR problem right? Exactly the point of my question. As long as it doesn't effect US, we're ok with EVERYTHING happening in our society.

Hypocrisy much?

No hypocrisy...it's moral values of our family.They do KNOW that dating hindu man is wrong therefore they will note date a hindu man.Now if Shoib family has no problem with it then why should we?He is not comitting some illegal crime..more like a moral crime which allah will judge him.Nearly 95% College Students (Co-Ed Colleges) date with no secrecy.

 

[Beskar]

No hypocrisy...it's moral values of our family.They do KNOW that dating hindu man is wrong therefore they will note date a hindu man.Now if Shoib family has no problem with it then why should we?He is not comitting some illegal crime..more like a moral crime which allah will judge him.Nearly 95% College Students (Co-Ed Colleges) date with no secrecy.

95%? Generalization much?

I can assure you, if you've lived in Pakistan, you'd know that the students who're into dating aren't doing it openly. How many stories have you heard where the girl's dad proudly opens the door for his daughters 'boyfriend' so that they can go out for a nice romantic evening?

You're living in a delusion my friend. DHA and Elite living doesn't equal to the 95% of our country's students/teenagers. All of whom which you claim are dating openly.

 

[Zob]

fine your family morals don't confuse it with islam because if you want to be islamic dating altogether is wrong...but ofcourse you want to be in the middle and progressive and libreal and what not...so you say these are my family morals but 95% of pakistanis do it and another genralization CO-EDUCATION students do it.....i can assure you ALOT OF NON-CO EDUCATION students do it to....so as long as others do it its ok when it comes to you its wrong.... this is not islam this is just hypocrisy

 

[Elmo]

Nearly 95% College Students (Co-Ed Colleges) date with no secrecy.

Seriously, when was this survey conducted and which cities?

 

[booo]

How is he wrong about what he said? He isn't making anything up.

I could've said something similar w.r.t islam. but thats just not me! For him Islam could've been the greatest religion, but disgracing the other religion shows the shallow side.

 

[Lockheed F-16]

Ahh I am so happy that eventually you all got my point. I told you all that many hypocrites r here. You thinkd ating is normal but when ur sister would do that I don't want to experience wht you would do. So just be honest, I have been honest, have been attacked by ilovef16, whose name I certainly know, but I was honest and I am proud of it. So please talk abt something as though you would be involved in it.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Why else do you think this thread is receiving so many responses? Because the subject in discussion here is a Male who's dating a Hindu woman.



No, the debate revolved around the fact that Shoaib was dating a Hindu woman. No body's talking about dating in 'General'.



Did you even read the posts in this thread? Who's asking shoaib here to stop dating?



I don't have a problem, didn't you read my post? I simply asked the question for the sake of my own knowledge. I could care less about what any individual does in his life, my question was simply to understand the mindset of people who're promoting the idea that a Muslim dating a Hindu individual isn't a big deal.

Dating itself is a big deal in our society and the large part of the 'Population' you're so proudly referring to, does that under secrecy. Which means that throughout our country it is still not accepted.

But it's funny to see how you just said that due to some 'restrictions' you wouldn't let someone from your own family do something like that but on the other hand you're also promoting the idea that it's not a big deal if someone dates or better yet, dates a Hindu individual. Its THEIR problem right? Exactly the point of my question. As long as it doesn't effect US, we're ok with EVERYTHING happening in our society.

Hypocrisy much?

Why should SaadA sacrifice his right to choose whats good for him in order to defend Shoaib Malik's right to choose whats good for him? Logical fallacy.

For example, I do not have to be a muslim to defend your right to practice islam now, do i?

 

[pak-marine]

sorry *** post!

 

[Goodperson]

It seems gossip for cheap publicity, was her film supposed to be released in Pakistan ?

 

[Ratus Ratus]

On a passing point since there appears to be good, bad and a few ugly points here that the following be played while you read the thread.

The Good, The Bad & The Ugly a reminder

Peace!

 

[Al-zakir]

So dating muslims is OK even if its unislamic, but dating hindus is not ok because its unislamic.

Dating is not OK in Islam regardless religious affiliation. It's simply not allowed and majority doesn't do it except few liberals.

Religion teaches love, yes!

Yes but not what are you referring to.....

 

[notsuperstitious]

Yes but not what are you referring to.....

I was refering to love for fellow humans, but you are right, when religions divide people in various groups what love will that lead to?

 

[murshid]

i blame it totally on indians.
indians has badly harmed our culture . today young boys and girls dating each other , you can find young boys buying condom openly from medical stores.

our religion has also inflrated by the indian thoughts , one day i even heard my close friend saying " sab bhgwan ki marji hai".

i suggest it should be stricktly for pakistanis and we should ban indian as well as bangladeshies from his forum,

 

[Ratus Ratus]

i suggest it should be stricktly for pakistanis and we should ban indian as well as bangladeshies from his forum,

Brilliant idea.
But you also have to ban all non Pakistanis anyway.
Then you better ban an Pakistani who lives in the western environment just in case they are polluted by such ideas as well.

That just leaves pakistanis that live and were born in Pakistan.
Keep it all nice and home grown.
Good open forum