What's new

Middle East ‘elites’: Turkey’s say in diplomacy on the rise

-SINAN-

BANNED
Joined
Feb 22, 2013
Messages
16,746
Reaction score
0
Country
Turkey
Location
Turkey
Turkey’s say in international politics is gaining strength and it will be the most powerful state in the Middle East in 10 years, according to a recent study conducted with participants from eight Middle East countries.

Nearly 85 percent of the surveyed people think that Turkey has started to have "more of a say" in international politics, the report conducted by Fatih University said. The study made between March 15 and June 1 with 50 people from each country (Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Israel, Palestine, Egypt, Libya and Tunisia) who have an “impact on the decision-making process or who have a high probability of influencing this process.” Participants included politicians, academics, civil society and press workers.

An approximately equal proportion, 85 percent, said Turkish foreign policy had "approached the Muslim world," in the report titled “How do Middle Eastern elites perceive Turkish foreign policy?” Most of the participants also had a perception of a "balanced" Turkish foreign policy between the West and the Muslim world.

The participants thought Turkey would be the most powerful state in the Middle East in 2023. Over 30 percent of the elites replied “Turkey” to the question “Which country do you think will be the most powerful state in the Middle East in 10 years?”

Iran was the second country seen as a regional power in the Middle East. However, in contrast with Turkey, Iran’s influence in the region dropped from 25 percent to 9 percent in 10 years. Iran is not among the interviewed countries as it is too difficult contact people within the country, the academics who took part in this study said.

Almost 60 percent of the participants agreed that Turkish foreign policy’s final goal is to become the leader of the Muslim world as more than 50 percent believed that Turkey is acting as the protector of ancient Ottoman territory. None of the interviewed countries, including Israel and Syria, had a foe perception of Turkey. Almost 40 percent of the Syrian participants said Turkey was the country with which they had the closest relations. But most of the interviewed Syrian participants were opponents of the al-Assad regime.

The study said more than 50 percent of the participants thought that Turkey followed a sectarian foreign policy in the region and supported Turkey’s Syria policy as more than 60 percent of them thought that Turkey should support the Syrian opposition against the al-Assad regime and said Turkey should support a democratic, unitary Syrian republic in the post-al-Assad era.

On the possible establishment of a Kurdish state, more than 30 percent of them are in favor of the foundation of an independent Kurdish state in the Middle East while more than 50 percent oppose this idea.

Source: MIDEAST - Middle East
-------------------------------

There are no people from the GCC countries, Jordan or Iran included in the survey. But we have them here :) What are your thoughts.
 
.
I think Turkey is very sectarian, their policy is based on Sunni supremacy.
 
.
I think Turkey is very sectarian, their policy is based on Sunni supremacy.

Subject is more or less Turkey being the most powerful state in the Middle East in 2023 and having diplomatic weigh.

But this a study made by a Turkish university and without the participants from GCC countries, Jordan or Iran. As an Iranian can you express your thoughts about the subject.
 
.
Subject is more or less Turkey being the most powerful state in the Middle East in 2023 and having diplomatic weigh.

But this a study made by a Turkish university and without the participants from GCC countries, Jordan or Iran. As an Iranian can you express your thoughts about the subject.

Turkey and Iran are already the most powerful Muslim countries in the region.
 
. .
Iran is 93% Shia but has supported Sunni groups.

Turkey only exclusively supports Sunni groups. They did not support the revolution in Bahrain.


Turkey could become powerful if it tries to cross over to Shia side as well, if it supported the Bahrain revolution, it would have gained influence there , but now Shias see Turkey as hostile.

In my opinion Turkey could become the most powerful Muslim country in the region if it could cross that line and support both Sunni and Shias in the region. It could extend it's influence even in Iran.
 
.
Turkey and Iran are already the most powerful Muslim countries in the region.

Sorry, but no, there is a big hack of a difference between Turkey and Iran. Suffice to say that they're economically superior, and technologically head and shoulders above Iran. While Turkey's economy is booming, welcoming heavy industrialization, Iran is the other way around.

Iran never supported any Sunni movement with the exception of Palestine and Al-Qaida in Iraq.
 
.
Indeed, if we were close with eachother, i mean A tri-alliance Pakistan, Iran and Turkey. We'd definetly be much more powerful but, Iran chose Russia. Pakistan chose US and China and Turkey chose nato. Fuvck peace fuvck the middle east :)
 
.
Turkey and Iran are already the most powerful Muslim countries in the region.

KSA definively is the most powerful. No doubt about it.
hundred thousands jobs in USA depend on them. they have USA in their pocket. And you can see it :
who did 9/11 ? saudis : they got no blame: Iraq was attacked.
Syria ? USA let do KSA and Qatar but more KSA (you see how Qatar was weaken)
Iran? no need to say
Lebanon ? support of Hariri mafia
Iraq ? Iraqis can say here

Let's be honnest about it. Turkey is acting wise but cannot be described as powerful diplomatic country. it is just a NATO friendly country, necessary it's true.
 
.
Iran is 93% Shia but has supported Sunni groups.

Turkey only exclusively supports Sunni groups. They did not support the revolution in Bahrain.


Turkey could become powerful if it tries to cross over to Shia side as well, if it supported the Bahrain revolution, it would have gained influence there , but now Shias see Turkey as hostile.

In my opinion Turkey could become the most powerful Muslim country in the region if it could cross that line and support both Sunni and Shias in the region. It could extend it's influence even in Iran.

If Iran supported the Sunnis, then why would your newly-elected president promised to grant the minorities within the Iranian society full rights as the majority in the country? Why are they supporting a minority against the majority in Syria? Why Iran is assisting the Bahraini terrorists to commit more violence? Why Iran is poking its nose in every single Arab affair?

Turkey on the other hand is different and unique.
 
.
If Iran supported the Sunnis, then why would your newly-elected president promised to grant the minorities within the Iranian society full rights as the majority in the country? Why are they supporting a minority against the majority in Syria? Why Iran is assisting the Bahraini terrorists to commit more violence? Why Iran is poking its nose in every single Arab affair?

Turkey on the other hand is different and unique.

Because Turkey is not ruled by deluded, moronic and reactionary Iranian Mullah's that falsely claim Arab ancestry and thus believe that they have a God given right to meddle in every single Arab country "because they are one of us".

:omghaha:

Look at that Iranigirl member (who is not a female in real life according to most Iranian members) who is already busy talking about what country x or y can do in terms of meddling.

There is only one solution for them and that is to destroy them, their slaves and supporters. Through marginalization, proxy wars and direct combat.

Syria is just the start of it.

Unless they will be toppled but Iranians are harmless and could barely defend themselves if the same Mullah's were about to kill their families. We have seen it again and again.

Enough is enough.
 
.
KSA definively is the most powerful. No doubt about it.
hundred thousands jobs in USA depend on them. they have USA in their pocket. And you can see it
who did 9/11 ? saudis : they got no blame: Iraq was attacked.
Syria ? USA let do KSA and Qatar but more KSA (you see how Qatar was weaken)
Iran? no need to say
Lebanon ? support of Hariri mafia
Iraq ? Iraqis can say here

Let's be honnest about it. Turkey is acting wise but cannot be described as powerful diplomatic country. it is just a NATO friendly country, necessary it's true.

If you are referring to Military industry, then I'm afraid Sir you are wrong, Al-Salam, a Saudi-based company had taken the lead years ago. However, KSA has been investing in the US for ages now, which refutes each and every single claim that the US-KSA relation is based on oil solely. Moreover, KSA buys US debits, if you know what I mean.

I don't think that Al-Hariri family is a gang though :)
 
.
Hariri is seen as "mafia " style in Lebanon. Well that is most comments i get from Lebanese in Paris.

About KSA and more than hundred thousand jobs dependant on KSA in USA.
There is an excellent book suggest to me by an Israelian friend :
The American House of Saud: The Secret Petrodollar Connection
1985 so quite old but it says very well the links

but just do calculation
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/8000747/US-secures-record-60-billion-arms-sale-to-Saudi-Arabia.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/17/business/energy-environment/us-reliance-on-saudi-oil-is-growing-again.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
 
.
Hariri is seen as "mafia " style in Lebanon. Well that is most comments i get from Lebanese in Paris.

About KSA and more than hundred thousand jobs dependant on KSA in USA.
There is an excellent book suggest to me by an Israelian friend :

1985 so quite old but it says very well the links

but just do calculation
US secures record $60 billion arms sale to Saudi Arabia - Telegraph
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/17/business/energy-environment/us-reliance-on-saudi-oil-is-growing-again.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

Sir,

I never said you were wrong, all what I'm saying is that the bilateral relations goes way beyond energy,and all. I'm quite well-aware of the arms deal package, I know the people who lobbied for it in Congress :).
 
.
Sir,

I never said you were wrong, all what I'm saying is that the bilateral relations goes way beyond energy,and all. I'm quite well-aware of the arms deal package, I know the people who lobbied for it in Congress :).

I can't believe that people believe the opposite to be the case to be honest. Anyway given the lack of knowledge about the Arab world from many users here it is not really that surprising, is it my friend?
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom