Message for PM of India: Avoid cosying up to Iran

[BJP*]

We never said anything anti India in OIC meetings. We are the ones who stopped resolution being passed against you on Kashmir.

I respect your feeling as Iranian citizen but Iran has already taken anti India stand.
Iran's supreme leader backs Kashmir 'struggle' - Hindustan Times
Iran's Kashmir remarks upset India | NDTV.com

 

[Abdi-Karim Elmi]

yeah destroy each other while the arabs happily pick on the spoils. [/QUOTE

Imagine the Arab conquest failed in the middle east and were wiped out by the Byzantine and Sassanids.

yeah destroy each other while the arabs happily pick on the spoils.

imagine the arab conquest failed in the 7th century.

 

[INDIC]

And what did you get in return ?

A boot up your wazoo !

Learn some self respect Iranians.

Because there is a sectarian angle in the ideology of the militants in Kashmir.

 

[Holmes]

Dude where do you get this stuff ?

The potential for trade with Israel is much much more than potential for trade with Iran. Our trade with Iran consists of only crude and some textiles, grain exports etc.

But with Israel it encompasses a whole lot from critical defence tech, scientific co-operations, space research, new technologies in irrigation, renewable energy, counter-insurgency training/exchange etc etc.

Whatever it maybe, We have much historical alliances with Iran/Persia than to jews. So I'd put my safe bet on iran instead.
Making nuclear iran on our side would help to balance power in Asian region.

 

[UKBengali]

Whatever it maybe, We have much historical alliances with Iran/Persia than to jews. So I'd put my safe bet on iran instead.
Making nuclear iran on our side would help to balance power in Asian region.

What a lot of Indians do not understand is that over the long run, the Jews will be far less beneficial to India than Iran.

True the Jews are currently helping India's defence industry with technology transfer but by the start of the next decade India is likely to be self-sufficient in most of the areas that they are getting help in. Also the Whites are getting less and less important as each year passes. In 10 years time they will be far less influential that they are now. By 2030, most Asians won't think much of whites any more and won't care what they think, and so even if being friends with Jews made the whites like you a bit more it would be irrelevant anyway.

Iran on the other hand looks set to make the transition to an advanced economy within the next 10-15 years and it has huge land, agricultural, energy and huge potential market/technology that will be very useful for a country like India.

India has little to gain by taking sides with Jews over the long run. The future is with countries like Iran, Indonesia and Brazil.

 

[PteX]

Whatever it maybe, We have much historical alliances with Iran/Persia than to jews. So I'd put my safe bet on iran instead.
Making nuclear iran on our side would help to balance power in Asian region.

Then i suggest you don't go gambling with anything more than your words because you would lose.

 

[timetravel]

What a lot of Indians do not understand is that over the long run, the Jews will be far less beneficial to India than Iran.

True the Jews are currently helping India's defence industry with technology transfer but by the start of the next decade India is likely to be self-sufficient in most of the areas that they are getting help in. Also the Whites are getting less and less important as each year passes. In 10 years time they will be far less influential that they are now. By 2030, most Asians won't think much of whites any more and won't care what they think, and so even if being friends with Jews made the whites like you a bit more it would be irrelevant anyway.

Iran on the other hand looks set to make the transition to an advanced economy within the next 10-15 years and it has huge land, agricultural, energy and huge potential market/technology that will be very useful for a country like India.

India has little to gain by taking sides with Jews over the long run. The future is with countries like Iran, Indonesia and Brazil.

wrong the future is in cooperation...and Israel has been a friend of India. India is not leaving its friends now or later. India would try to balance and if possible bring Israel and Iran closer as it is the best outcome for all 3.

what makes u think India would abandon NAM policy when it will be super power in future when it did not do so till now.

 

[Paan Singh]

What a lot of Indians do not understand is that over the long run, the Jews will be far less beneficial to India than Iran.

True the Jews are currently helping India's defence industry with technology transfer but by the start of the next decade India is likely to be self-sufficient in most of the areas that they are getting help in. Also the Whites are getting less and less important as each year passes. In 10 years time they will be far less influential that they are now. By 2030, most Asians won't think much of whites any more and won't care what they think, and so even if being friends with Jews made the whites like you a bit more it would be irrelevant anyway.

Iran on the other hand looks set to make the transition to an advanced economy within the next 10-15 years and it has huge land, agricultural, energy and huge potential market/technology that will be very useful for a country like India.

India has little to gain by taking sides with Jews over the long run. The future is with countries like Iran, Indonesia and Brazil.

India never left its allies....
take example of past...

 

[UKBengali]

^^^ Nations do not have permanent allies, only permanent interests.


Jews are only important to India now, they will not be in the future. - think I have more than explained why in my post.

India is finished if it thinks like the 2 posters above.

 

[Paan Singh]

^^^ Nations do not have permanent allies, only permanent interests.


Jews are only important to India now, they will not be in the future. - think I have more than explained why in my post.

India is finished if it thinks like the 2 posters above.

i agree with your point that interest brings the allies but there are other factors too and it depends on how the geo strategic positions n influence changes..

 

[INDIC]

Whatever it maybe, We have much historical alliances with Iran/Persia than to jews. So I'd put my safe bet on iran instead.
Making nuclear iran on our side would help to balance power in Asian region.

India and Iran collaboration is mainly based on Iran's fear of the spread of wahabbism like Taliban and international isolation. Since oil is an important resource we also need to buy their oil when we are hit by inflation.

But Iran always love to interfere in our internal issues, that things irks us a lot and not good from Iran's side.

 

[timetravel]

^^^ Nations do not have permanent allies, only permanent interests.


Jews are only important to India now, they will not be in the future. - think I have more than explained why in my post.

India is finished if it thinks like the 2 posters above.

well we will see how the world is in 2050. No point debating that right now.

But if going by past and present India Israel are close friends now and helping each other make their countries stronger.

Also Indians don't hate Jews like you do. In fact there is a lot of admiration and love for them in this country. So no matter what India would never be hostile to Jews and Israel. India has been a country and society which has welcomed Jews always long before the defense relations started, and it will remain so always. The level of defense cooperation may go up and down. That's all.

Hating Jews is the preoccupation of Arabs and your country. Indians never were and will never be party to it.

 

[cyphercide]

Iran is of the utmost importance for India as she provides for the biggest leverage that we could ever ask for.....and if you can't comprehend that, that's all on you cuz you're a dumba** like the rest of the fundoos.

 

[karan21]

What a lot of Indians do not understand is that over the long run, the Jews will be far less beneficial to India than Iran.

True the Jews are currently helping India's defence industry with technology transfer but by the start of the next decade India is likely to be self-sufficient in most of the areas that they are getting help in. Also the Whites are getting less and less important as each year passes. In 10 years time they will be far less influential that they are now. By 2030, most Asians won't think much of whites any more and won't care what they think, and so even if being friends with Jews made the whites like you a bit more it would be irrelevant anyway.

Iran on the other hand looks set to make the transition to an advanced economy within the next 10-15 years and it has huge land, agricultural, energy and huge potential market/technology that will be very useful for a country like India.


India has little to gain by taking sides with Jews over the long run. The future is with countries like Iran, Indonesia and Brazil.

10000 percent agreed. Man i an happy to see some smart posters who understand world politics and relations.

Iran is what India needs to get with and fortunately our defence planners understand that. The aesa radars and avionics that we once bought from isre are niw made in india completely. Isreal is too small to be economically effective for india. Stop being emotional. Isreal will be no use for india in 3 yrs from now. Middle is over 1.5 billion strong. Embrace them.

 

[timetravel]

Iran is of the utmost importance for India as she provides for the biggest leverage that we could ever ask for.....and if you can't comprehend that, that's all on you cuz you're a dumba** like the rest of the fundoos.

it is not about whether Iran is important or not. But there is no way India would become HOSTILE to Israel for Iran or some other county. thats just not happening.

When we dont care about US and can have good relations with Iran. In future when we will be 100 times more stronger, why would be spoil out relations with Israel for some other country. MAKES ZERO SENSE.