LCA vs JF17 turn rate,roll time and loop comparison video
- Thread starter Srinivas
- Start date
- Status
k7x
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2009
- Messages
- 318
- Reaction score
- 0
Truth always hurt..
Sour grapes for someone are not always sour for everyone.. For those who dont know what they are talking about. Lca is a failed project/product. period.
and why this comparision . JF17 is already a winner. see below
Jf 17 is 90 % composit surface where as LCA is all metal now and composits Will be done in future.
JF 17 is Unstable aircraft in all axis , controlled by fully redundunt FWB system, where is LCA will be made fully FWB in phases, currently it flys like mig 19, 21, airbus a320
.
JF17 has onboard Oxygen generator to extend operational range, where as LCA doestn have it.
JF17 has 9 hardpoints, where as LCA has 8 hardpoints
JF17 has twin seater trainer but LCA twin seater is never developed
JF17 is being developed to land on an aircraft carrier , where as LCA is not.
JF17 RCS is very less as its body is made of composits , where as LCA a school bus on air.
and i can go long...like this. I know what you should do in above text
Funding for a jointventure devlopment is not same as developing some thing with foreign components.
1. It is a wise decision to buy, proven componenets and use it initally. later when you can build it they will be replaced.
LCA is not 100% indian, even if it is 40% indian it is a significant achievement for india and a grand success.
Coming to turn compariosn... come to chennai, our autos are also like these flights, 3 wheels and airborn most of the time. they can take u turn, in less than the time you can turn.. all these comparion is not accurate as we dont know anything about the speed of the ac & intention of the show.
Sour grapes for someone are not always sour for everyone.. For those who dont know what they are talking about. Lca is a failed project/product. period.
and why this comparision . JF17 is already a winner. see below
Jf 17 is 90 % composit surface where as LCA is all metal now and composits Will be done in future.
JF 17 is Unstable aircraft in all axis , controlled by fully redundunt FWB system, where is LCA will be made fully FWB in phases, currently it flys like mig 19, 21, airbus a320
. JF17 has onboard Oxygen generator to extend operational range, where as LCA doestn have it.
JF17 has 9 hardpoints, where as LCA has 8 hardpoints
JF17 has twin seater trainer but LCA twin seater is never developed
JF17 is being developed to land on an aircraft carrier , where as LCA is not.
JF17 RCS is very less as its body is made of composits , where as LCA a school bus on air.
and i can go long...like this. I know what you should do in above text
Funding for a jointventure devlopment is not same as developing some thing with foreign components.
1. It is a wise decision to buy, proven componenets and use it initally. later when you can build it they will be replaced.
LCA is not 100% indian, even if it is 40% indian it is a significant achievement for india and a grand success.
Coming to turn compariosn... come to chennai, our autos are also like these flights, 3 wheels and airborn most of the time. they can take u turn, in less than the time you can turn.. all these comparion is not accurate as we dont know anything about the speed of the ac & intention of the show.
Thorough Pro
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2008
- Messages
- 13,232
- Reaction score
- -21
- Country
- Location
Awesome
RETIRED MOD
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2006
- Messages
- 22,023
- Reaction score
- 5
These videos mean squat unless the machines were tested to their absolute limits on each trial.
In different videos pilots could have just pushed their birds a little harder. As you can see Pak47 posted a video of JF-17 beating the LCA.
Unless they were tested for this purpose at the same time, there won't be any proof. Not even a tiny indication of the truth.
In conclusion, don't create troll threads.
In different videos pilots could have just pushed their birds a little harder. As you can see Pak47 posted a video of JF-17 beating the LCA.
Unless they were tested for this purpose at the same time, there won't be any proof. Not even a tiny indication of the truth.
In conclusion, don't create troll threads.
- Status
Similar threads
