Is Pakistan just an extension of North India?

[Tea addict]

Lol you do know that muslims ruled what is now considered India, right? Do you also know that those muslim rulers had armies that were a mix of central asians, persians and pukhtoon troops. So what do you think happened to them?

No it's not, other than IoK and Punjab; all of your states are quite different ethnically, culturally, linguistically (native languages), historically and so on.


Mauryan Empire enjoyed a loose century-old reign over the Indus before the people got rid themselves of that filth. Other than that, there has been no Indian power that has seriously held control of modern-day Pakistan.


Not North India but North West India (especially Punjab) and a large portion of them have their origins in Pakistan. They make up 3-5% of your population yet dominate your sports, entertainment and etc...


That's pretty BS, almost all Punjabis i've met abroad associate more with Pakistan than they do with India. Sikhs especially talk about undivided Punjab.

Yah right everyone knows which desis ruled whom.. Shouting louder won't change the fact.. It's better to accept invaders as your ancestor than doing that.
And I am from the state that rules the sports, Haryana. And that's what I said, other than Punjabis, other north Indians are the last ones who associate themselves with Pakistan. Dogras, himachalis, pahadis of uttrakhand, Haryanvis, Delhi and north Rajasthan.. Only punjabis, that to from manjha region associate themselves with you.. We consider you as equal as a Bhaiya from bihar.

We know the history, importance and heritage of our motherland very well and it seems that you know it too. But frankly I don't care about North Indians and the Ganges. That's your remit. It's a shame its neglected by modern Indians who care more about the Indus.

I am sure plenty of interesting events happened in the Ganges region too. Can you name five?

I ain't naming anything and being Haryanvi I am also claiming Indus. Deal with it. My people are doing research on Indus valley civilization, the saraswati river while your people glorify your invaders.. Even in this thread itself the people claiming Indus in second sentence say "we ruled you for 1000 years during Muslim rule".. How confuse your people are..

 

[Kabira]

Indians are the last ones who associate themselves with Pakistan. Dogras, himachalis, pahadis of uttrakhand, Haryanvis, Delhi and north Rajasthan.. Only punjabis, that to from manjha region associate themselves with you.. We consider you as equal as a Bhaiya from bihar.

I'm sorry but how are you not bhaiya while speaking hindi and belonging to cow belt? While punjabis are bhaiyas lmao

Haryanvis are bhaiyas in language, looks of people, culture etc Dogras are more like north punjab/potoharis, not sure why you include them in your north india cultural sphere. Rajasthan and Delhi are part of hindi cow belt. Utharkhandis are like Nepalis, Indians mixed with Tibetan like people.

 

[Trango Towers]

Can someone here tell me at least 5 things which distinguishes Pakistan from north India?
I feel if I visit Indian Punjab or jammu or haryana, I need not visit Pakistan... Instead it is worthwhile visiting eastern India or southern India as they are linguistically and culturally much different than north.

First you need Pakistan's permission to enter Pakistan.
Paksitan is very different from Indian. I have visited north India. It's amazing but then again so is Pakistan and so is the diversity.
If you enjoy travelling you will love it

 

[MultaniGuy]

Can someone here tell me at least 5 things which distinguishes Pakistan from north India?
I feel if I visit Indian Punjab or jammu or haryana, I need not visit Pakistan... Instead it is worthwhile visiting eastern India or southern India as they are linguistically and culturally much different than north.

What a bullshit post.

We Pakistanis have nothing to do with you Indians.

Bug off!

LOL
Pakistan Tops Google Search For **** Materials like Camel Sex, Child Rape, Donkey Sex, Horse Sex

All lies, which have been debunked.

It is USA and Japan which lead the world in pornography.

This is just libel against Pakistan.

 

[UnitedPak]

I ain't naming anything and being Haryanvi I am also claiming Indus. Deal with it. My people are doing research on Indus valley civilization, the saraswati river while your people glorify your invaders.. Even in this thread itself the people claiming Indus in second sentence say "we ruled you for 1000 years during Muslim rule".. How confuse your people are..

You are claiming Indus for the people of Ganges? A stretch, even for majestic Urdu speaking Haryanvi. Maybe you should research what the Mughal invasions did to your own identity.

You can research atlantis too for all I care.

 

[Tea addict]

You are claiming Indus for the people of Ganges? A stretch, even for majestic Urdu speaking Haryanvi. Maybe you should research what the Mughal invrahjns did to your own identity.

You can research atlantis too for all I care.

What mughal invasion did to my identity? I still have Desi first name with Desi surname.. Speaks the same language which my ancestor spoke, follow the same culture and religion and most of all, consider my ancestor as my own. Its your first name which has Turkish, Persian, afghan or Arab roots with your Desi surnames.. Try to implement Arabic culture, national language is Urdu and glorify your invaders.. I have already said it, you yourself know your own people relates with bin qasim than raha dahir.. And its your own education system and brainwashing which has led them to this stage.. Not our problem.

I'm sorry but how are you not bhaiya while speaking hindi and belonging to cow belt? While punjabis are bhaiyas lmao

Haryanvis are bhaiyas in language, looks of people, culture etc Dogras are more like north punjab/potoharis, not sure why you include them in your north india cultural sphere. Rajasthan and Delhi are part of hindi cow belt. Utharkhandis are like Nepalis, Indians mixed with Tibetan like people.

I didn't said Punjabis are Bhaiyas, I said there exists a superiority complex which led us to believe that both our western (pakistanis) and eastern (bhaiyas) neighbors are inferior to us. North Indian states can take on both Pakistan and rest of India in sports and still win

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Lol well in that case as a pukhtoon i am happy with that. But on a serious all ethnicities are now influenced by each other in Pakistan. The biggest example is the food. Chapli kebeb is a pukhtoon dish but is a favorite all over the country just like lahori kunna, sindhi biryani and balochi sajji.

Sindhis don’t make biryani..

They make pulao... ask any Sindhi.

 

[Soulspeek]

Since when Goa became part of the North India? Have you ever checked the map? Now read the title of the thread again before stomping on your stupidness here.

It was a general quote... Not specifically about North India... I commented upon the general perception among a Pakistanis that Indians dont get to eat beef dishes etc.

Why your panty got in a twist?

You Pakistanis dont brag about beef n stew n nihari etc in future...

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Yah right everyone knows which desis ruled whom.. Shouting louder won't change the fact.. It's better to accept invaders as your ancestor than doing that.
And I am from the state that rules the sports, Haryana. And that's what I said, other than Punjabis, other north Indians are the last ones who associate themselves with Pakistan. Dogras, himachalis, pahadis of uttrakhand, Haryanvis, Delhi and north Rajasthan.. Only punjabis, that to from manjha region associate themselves with you.. We consider you as equal as a Bhaiya from bihar.

I ain't naming anything and being Haryanvi I am also claiming Indus. Deal with it. My people are doing research on Indus valley civilization, the saraswati river while your people glorify your invaders.. Even in this thread itself the people claiming Indus in second sentence say "we ruled you for 1000 years during Muslim rule".. How confuse your people are..

Forget the fact that so called invaders were our people (Pashtun,Baloch,Gilzai,Qazalbash)...

Tell me something.. you hate bhaiya right ?

But even indian panjabis consider you “bhaiyas”..

The irony is that you are classified as a bhaiya... even in the northern most province of your own country..

And in Pak.. anything other than Indian panjab is bhaiya Land, hindi speaking,cow thumping bhaiyas .

While the other half of India has an image in our eyes as something like this;

I swear to God that this is the mental image the average Pak has of you guys.

 

[Kabira]

I didn't said Punjabis are Bhaiyas, I said there exists a superiority complex which led us to believe that both our western (pakistanis) and eastern (bhaiyas) neighbors are inferior to us. North Indian states can take on both Pakistan and rest of India in sports and still winView attachment 469246

I'm sorry but Biharis and Haryanvis are one and same. Stop this nonsensical north Indian umbrella term to run away from your heritage bhaiya.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

I'm sorry but Biharis and Haryanvis are one and same. Stop this nonsensical north Indian umbrella term to run away from your heritage bhaiya.

Ironic isn’t it?

Same Haryanvi and meos in Pak are considered bhaiyas and Urdu speakers in Pakistan..

 

[Tea addict]

Forget the fact that so called invaders were our people (Pashtun,Baloch,Gilzai,Qazalbash)...

Tell me something.. you hate bhaiya right ?

But did I d ien indian panjabis consider you “bhaiyas”..

The irony is that you are classified as a bhaiya... even in the northern most province of your own country..

And in Pak.. anything other than Indian panjab is bhaiya Land, hindi speaking,cow thumping bhaiyas .

View attachment 469250 View attachment 469251

While the other half of India has an image in our eyes as something like this;

View attachment 469249

View attachment 469252

I swear to God that this is the mental image the average Pak has of you guys.

Where is said I hate Bhaiyas? Started with wrong assumption and try to build your entire argument on that? Nah.

I'm sorry but Biharis and Haryanvis are one and same. Stop this nonsensical north Indian umbrella term to run away from your heritage bhaiya.

Try harder.

 

[Kabira]

Ironic isn’t it?

Same Haryanvi and meos in Pak are considered bhaiyas and Urdu speakers in Pakistan..

Funny thing is he look down on Biharis while being Haryanvi. And look down on punjab while including dogras who are more like punjabis in his imaginary north indian super race number 1 in sports.

Indians who couldn't produce single great fast bowler in their entire cricketing history

 

[chatterjee]

Yes. All of the citizens of the artificial state are Indians too.
fact is fact

 

[Imad.Khan]

Sindhis don’t make biryani..

They make pulao... ask any Sindhi.

Really? I have even seen shan spices for sindhi biryani