India copying Pakistani/Western Culture

[praveen]

Biryani is called an Indian dish

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Hmm seems like origional devdas was etter something to put on my to do list watch old devdas -

 

[jarnee]

Ah...all thats fine..but don't send the Mahabharat to Pakistan....Hastinapur is in UP and Kurukshetra is in Haryana!!

Let me correct you real quick ..the Kingdom of "Gandhar" Shakuni's home land brother of Gandhari who was mother of "Duryodhana" Is in Pakistan now. North western punjab in Pakistan.

Read :

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gandhara_Kingdom

 

[praveen]

Let me correct you real quick ..the Kingdom of "Gandhar" Shakuni's home land brother of Gandhari who was mother of "Duryodhana" Is in Pakistan now. North western punjab in Pakistan.



Read :

Gandhara Kingdom - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

kandhahar~Gandhara philological evidence

 

[jarnee]

The main battle place of Mahabharata was in India ..But Mahabharata is associated with entire northen Indian subcontinent which include Pakistan and some bit of Afganistan

 

[jarnee]

kandhahar~Gandhara philological evidence

Maybe right thats how the name of Afghan city is Kandahar

 

[jarnee]

Pls there are no offenses ..meant to Pakistani memebers ..as what we are talking abt is 4000-3500 Yrs old facts and stories..

 

[SQ8]

There should be no offenses taken by sensible people.. as I stressed before, The Gandhara civilization, The Indus Civilization are all part of both countries history.
The battle of Uhud in Arabia is taken as part of Islamic History, but if taken out of context of good and evil, Islam and the Pagans.. still happened.
Similarly..The battles and events in mahabharta, whether or not the supernatural is associated with them, probably did occur between human beings. History can be tampered, but it still needs a certain foundation to be recorded on. And a few people living in both countries..can trace in their genes a certain great great 20x granddaddy who fought in the Mahabhartha I suppose.

What I stress is denying the common history or claiming it exclusively as yours. I stress differentiation between religious and national history. While Mohammad bin Qasim does have great significance for in Pakistani textbooks as the man who brought Islam to the subcontinent, He did not have anything to do with Pakistan as such and is as relevant in modern India's history as he is in Pakistan's.

 

[Asian.Century]

Nothing wrong if Indians copy Pakistanis and adopt those cultural things. but one thing should be made clear what belongs and what belonged on the land of Pakistan, is pakistani history and pakistani cultural heritage.

 

[Sugarcane]

Nothing wrong if Indians copy Pakistanis and adopt those cultural things. but one thing should be made clear what belongs and what belonged on the land of Pakistan, is pakistani history and pakistani cultural heritage.

It's half decade old thread.

 

[Asian.Century]

It's half decade old thread.

It is still very much relevant today as it was before.

 

[guluchulo]

Now days Indians are going back to their African roots, we should also respect our aryan roots. Anyway let them copy, our infuence reached every African tribe of India. This is old thread, no point in discussing further.

 

[Asian.Century]

Biryani is called an Indian dish

Totally Wrong!

Biryani name was derived from Persian word beryā(n), meaning fried, roasted. It was originated in Turkey o r Persia and brought to India and Pakistan by Muslim travellers and merchants and Mughal.

 

[jandk]

Totally Wrong!

Biryani name was derived from Persian word beryā(n), meaning fried, roasted. It was originated in Turkey o r Persia and brought to India and Pakistan by Muslim travellers and merchants and Mughal.

only name is same, dish is completely different

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

lol hahahah Aryan back ground lol