Can a Muslim say "Merry Christmas"?

[BATMAN]

Greet with love!!!! and Adhan!!! ????

Women can have children from his past life and you happen to become father by virtue of new relationship.. but leave it.

long story short... i don't agree and trust the explanations of Zakir Naik. I also not consider it sin to greet non Muslims in Islamic way.

 

[acetophenol]

Even if it happens to be a sin,i shall bear it with happiness,for Prophet Muhammed (Swallalahi alaiya swalam) has taught muslims to be the part of the joy and sorrow of your fellow being,
MERRY CHRISTMAS!

 

[BATMAN]

Even if it happens to be a sin,i shall bear it with happiness,for Prophet Muhammed (Swallalahi alaiya swalam) has taught muslims to be the part of the joy and sorrow of your fellow being,
MERRY CHRISTMAS!

I don't know why only in 2011 such questions keep pooping up.

Quran even taught us that we are allowed to make society with followers of books of God.

We can eat, greet and make relationship.

Why would a Muslim deny Quran and follow fake Hadees and fake Mullah!!!

No Mullah is allowed to invent new Islam post 9-11 and especially, a mullah who is launched by RAW to carry forward their objectives, and discuss issues of non-importance, need to be uncovered!

 

[Lighting_Fighter]

some scholars say yes some say no

 

[acetophenol]

I don't know why only in 2011 such questions keep pooping up.

Quran even taught us that we are allowed to make society with followers of books of God.

We can eat, greet and make relationship.

Why would a Muslim deny Quran and follow fake Hadees and fake Mullah!!!

No Mullah is allowed to invent new Islam post 9-11 and especially, a mullah who is launched by RAW to carry forward their objectives, and discuss issues of non-importance, need to be uncovered!

Quran is the most mistaken book in the world. Maybe circulation of translated version will reduce it.

 

[shuntmaster]

What about muslims greeting 'Happy New Year'?
I have also read that muslims cannot greet 'Salam' to non-muslims, since a muslim cannot be at peace with a non-muslim. Is this true?

 

[BATMAN]

Quran is the most mistaken book in the world. Maybe circulation of translated version will reduce it.

If it helps you... you may give it a second try in your country.

 

[Lighting_Fighter]

Actually Qur'an is the most read book in the world. Only this info shows that it is Allah's words. We are suppose to know arabic then we would not need to read translation. Now let me give you challege could you find proof in quran any mistakes? if so post it here i will take it to the sheikh myself.

 

[acetophenol]

What about muslims greeting 'Happy New Year'?
I have also read that muslims cannot greet 'Salam' to non-muslims, since a muslim cannot be at peace with a non-muslim. Is this true?

Its false dude. Actually quran encourages us to say salam to everyone

 

[Lighting_Fighter]

as I said before if it is not anti islam we can greet you back with same greetings.

 

[BATMAN]

What about muslims greeting 'Happy New Year'?
I have also read that muslims cannot greet 'Salam' to non-muslims, since a muslim cannot be at peace with a non-muslim. Is this true?

It is a pure propaganda.. contrary Islam teach us to greet the non Muslims.
Life of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is full of such examples.
He greeted even those who were enemy of his life.

 

[acetophenol]

If it helps you... you may give it a second try in your country.

Why bring your hatred towards my nation in every thread? There is no need to give quran or gita or bible a second chance in my nation as they already has a good position.

 

[tamygu]

When muslims are obligated to recite suras from koran while pissing and shiting so why cant they say merry christmas unless muslim themselves dont consider Isa masih as prophet.But such is not the case.Btw merry christmas.

 

[BATMAN]

When muslims are obligated to recite suras from koran while pissing and shiting so why cant they say merry christmas unless muslim themselves dont consider Isa masih as prophet.But such is not the case.Btw merry christmas.

You are complaining and answering both in same email!

I believe you are not looking for answers or i'll happily offer my self.

 

[shuntmaster]

Should Muslims Greet the Kafir with "Salam"?

I was taught by my Wahabi (strict Sunni sect) teachers that Muslims (which I no longer am) can reply salaam (peace) to the kafir (non-Muslims) if they are greeted this way first and if the person appears to be sincere, as a matter of politeness. But Muslims should never say it first to kafirs nor reply with Assalamualaikum ("Peace be upon you") nor with the more formal Assalamu alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa barakatuh ("Peace be unto you and so may the mercy of Allah and His blessings").

Can a Muslim greet a Non Muslim with Salam or wish back? Dr Zakir Naik - YouTube