Another idiot criticizing Pakistan

[MultaniGuy]

The person asking question actually picked Palistan, he just responded.

True, true.

But then he said that why the Muslim world is in such a mess.

He could have mentioned belly dancing in the Arab world.

 

[fitpOsitive]

True, true.
But then he said that why the Muslim world is in such a mess.
He could have mentioned belly dancing in the Arab world.

May be he never saw belly dancing. Lets pretend that he is just innocent.

 

[Pakistani E]

Those western islamic countries also include Marzai as muslims these non muslims trying to mix up with muslims in those countries who give them room to expand. qadiyani every where in West Salman rushdi is in UK malala altaf hussain, hussain haqqani who are they assets of western world they never let islam grow the way it grows in Islamic world, Yes we do have alot of problems but we will overcome insha'Allah soon.

None of these people you listed are Ahmadis. However, Bin Laden, Baghdadi, Faisal Shahzad, Mohammed Sidique Khan, Germaine Lindsay and Shahzad Tanweer, Al Zarqawi etc etc (Basically thousands of terrorists) are/were Sunnis and they are growing Islam the way you like it.

You guys have a terrorism problem. It's not my fault if the world looks at you as terrorists.

 

[Hamza913]

Although Abdur Raheem Green is a good man, he is completely wrong about Pakistan.

Pakistan is much more Islamic than India or the United Kingdom.

Lol people commit bigger Shirk in UK than in Pakistan.

Those Christians in UK commit a bigger shirk than those stupid palmists in Pakistan.


Your views?
@Kaptaan @waz @Irfan Baloch @Zarvan

Regards,

Ali

I'm sorry but I have to agree with Abdur Raheem Green. Pakistan is a far cry from Islam.

We won't be a good Muslim country until the shrines are gone, we rule by Sharia, music and dancing are banned, and we stop the honour killings.

Brother Green can go and fck himself, we are Muslim in our own way. We don't need this douchebag with a beard to tell us our business.

Swearing is haram and having a beard is compulsory in Islam, so you're not helping your case at all.

 

[MultaniGuy]

I'm sorry but I have to agree with Abdur Raheem Green. Pakistan is a far cry from Islam.

We won't be a good Muslim country until the shrines are gone, we rule by Sharia, music and dancing are banned, and we stop the honour killings.



Swearing is haram and having a beard is compulsory in Islam, so you're not helping your case at all.

Yes, but Pakistan is more Islamic than India or UK where he is from.

Then he criticizes Pakistan.

 

[Hamza913]

There is not one fully democratic Muslim country why is that?
@DESERT FIGHTER
Why are all the democracy supporting Muslim scholars mainly from western countries?Its because of the collective attitude of their society where questioning power is encouraged

?

Democracy is haram, in Islam it is mandatory to follow Sharia, not man made laws which people decide.

Yes, but Pakistan is more Islamic than India or UK where he is from.

Then he criticizes Pakistan.

That's not a very good argument. Hindustan and the UK aren't even Muslim majority countries, to say we are better than them is like saying we have the best sight among the blind.

 

[MultaniGuy]

I'm sorry but I have to agree with Abdur Raheem Green. Pakistan is a far cry from Islam.

We won't be a good Muslim country until the shrines are gone, we rule by Sharia, music and dancing are banned, and we stop the honour killings.



Swearing is haram and having a beard is compulsory in Islam, so you're not helping your case at all.

There are also honor killings in the west, when the husband kills the wife for cheating on him.

Or when the boyfriend kills the girlfriend for finding a new boyfriend.

 

[Hamza913]

There are also honor killings in the west, when the husband kills the wife for cheating on him.

Or when the boyfriend kills the girlfriend for findind a new boyfriend.

And? Does that magically make us better?

 

[MultaniGuy]

And? Does that magically make us better?

I am just saying don't just dwell on social problems.

Look at the bigger picture here.

Abdur Raheem Green is a good man, but seriously I know many other Muslim countries that derserve criticism like Egypt and Turkey.

Heck even Turkey doesn't claim to be Islamic.

In fact in Turkey alcohol raki is the national drink. lol

Why doesn't he criticize Turkey.

And? Does that magically make us better?

You make some valid points. but seriously Mr. Green makes too many hasty generalizations about Pakistan.

And to compare India to Pakistan, please. In India people or the Hindus commit worse shirk than a Pakistani could do.

 

[Hamza913]

I am just saying don't just dwell on social problems.

Look at the bigger picture here.

Abdur Raheem Green is a good man, but seriously I know many other Muslim countries that derserve criticism like Egypt and Turkey.

Heck even Turkey doesn't claim to be Islamic.

In fact in Turkey alcohol raki is the national drink. lol

Why doesn't he criticize Turkey.

He can't go through a list and single out every country.

Pakistan was brought up, so he answered using Pakistan as an example. That's it. If the guy brought up Turkey, Green would have discussed about Turkey instead.

Look, I'm a Salafi. Trust me when I say, we don't view any Muslim majority country highly.

 

[MultaniGuy]

He can't go through a list and single out every country.

Pakistan was brought up, so he answered using Pakistan as an example. That's it. If the guy brought up Turkey, Green would have discussed about Turkey instead.

Look, I'm a Salafi. Trust me when I say, we don't view any Muslim majority country highly.

All Sunni Muslims are Salafi.

 

[Hamza913]

I am just saying don't just dwell on social problems.

Look at the bigger picture here.

Abdur Raheem Green is a good man, but seriously I know many other Muslim countries that derserve criticism like Egypt and Turkey.

Heck even Turkey doesn't claim to be Islamic.

In fact in Turkey alcohol raki is the national drink. lol

Why doesn't he criticize Turkey.


You make some valid points. but seriously Mr. Green makes too many hasty generalizations about Pakistan.

And to compare India to Pakistan, please. In India people or the Hindus commit worse shirk than a Pakistani could do.

Shirk is shirk, no matter how it's done.

Asking the dead for help instead of Allah and praying towards shrine seems pretty shirk-ish to me.

 

[MultaniGuy]

What about Saudi Arabia? Even Saudi Arabia is not a perfect Islamic society.

 

[Hamza913]

All Sunni Muslims are Salafi.

I guess you'd use the term Wahabbi.

 

[MultaniGuy]

Shirk is shirk, no matter how it's done.

Asking the dead for help instead of Allah and praying towards shrine seems pretty shirk-ish to me.

Yes you are right about that.

Local superstitions need to be eliminated.