Afghans: Artillery from Pakistan kills 4 civilians

[Patriot]

TTP Militants are hiding there

AJE Exclusive: Pakistan Taliban leader plays waiting game - YouTube

Retaliation on civilians? must be proud of the bravery?

It's called collateral damage.Our aim is to kill Militants not your Army - If we wanted to do that we would do it..unfortunately colletral damage is part of the war.

 

[Hashshāshīn]

Retaliation on civilians? must be proud of the bravery?

Look, I am 100% sure that the targets weren't civilians, but obviously sometimes civilians die (as US always says when it kills your civilians over and over)

 

[Sher Malang]

Well I cannot find the link, but I am 100% sure it was posted on this forum. Maybe someone else can post it.

Nonetheless, your ANA does not attack Pakistani tribals and villagers?

Okay, ANA had attacked Pakistani posts decades ago but do you mean PA is taking the revenge now?

TTP Militants are hiding there

AJE Exclusive: Pakistan Taliban leader plays waiting game - YouTube


It's called collateral damage.Our aim is to kill Militants not your Army - If we wanted to do that we would do it..unfortunately colletral damage is part of the war.

If our Army does harm Pakistan then attack them directly why to rain blind shells on civilian locations? these mofo militants well know where to hide from shells and I am totally against both Taliban AF/TTP they both have sucked the blood of innocents so from my side there is no sympathy if PA targets TTP in Afghanistan.

 

[RazPaK]

Okay, ANA had attacked Pakistani posts decades ago but do mean PA is taking the revenge now?

Decades?


Your special forces trained by Uncle Sam, came at night in jeep 5 km inside our territory and abducted some of our villagers.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

ANA does attack our villages and later accuse the taliban of it......... few years back ANA with 8 vehicles and 4 bikes tried to cross into Pakistan and fired at an FC post...... in retaliation the "sufi" havaldar at the post fired the 14.7 AA gun at them killing 4 ANA soldiers..... who fell in a drain... the bodies were later handed to the ANA after a few hours... later that night ANA had hidden weapons for a surprise attack on the FC post which we recovered and sent to FC HQ in quetta.

True story.

 

[Sher Malang]

Look, I am 100% sure that the targets weren't civilians, but obviously sometimes civilians die (as US always says when it kills your civilians over and over)

I have discussed this issue a while ago; there is a difference between US drones and these shells. These are blind shells which numbers in hundreds and most of them fall in civilian locations - this isn't the first civilian causality from these shells; show me one militant causality from these shells which are falling from last one year or more?

ANA does attack our villages and later accuse the taliban of it......... few years back ANA with 8 vehicles and 4 bikes tried to cross into Pakistan and fired at an FC post...... in retaliation the "sufi" havaldar at the post fired the 14.7 AA gun at them killing 4 ANA soldiers..... who fell in a drain... the bodies were later handed to the ANA after a few hours... later that night ANA had hidden weapons for a surprise attack on the FC post which we recovered and sent to FC HQ in quetta.

True story.

Stories can be made by anyone, evidence please?

PS: few years before ANA was even not able to stand completely against local terrorists how come it went all across the border and attacked Pakistan FC posts?

Decades?


Your special forces trained by Uncle Sam, came at night in jeep 5 km inside our territory and abducted some of our villagers.

I honestly didn't read/heard anything like that, if you have the links please post it here.

 

[datalibdaz]

Good going Pak Army...shower them with more heavy artillery. Kill these terrorist along the border..

 

[Pakistanisage]

You cannot send terrorist into Pakistan and not expect a backlash. TTP has their bases in Afghanistan and operate against PA from there so PA has the right to fire back.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Stories can be made by anyone, evidence please?

Thts not a story... it happened near your Paktika province..

 

[saiyan0321]

terrorist come through those villages what do you want us to do attack kabul we will attack places where we se them coming and again how is this different from drone policy after all they attack places to where civilians die you see that as a success you see our dieing soldiers as a success every week your terrorist and ana attack our check post it is you who is being biased

You cannot send terrorist into Pakistan and not expect a backlash. TTP has their bases in Afghanistan and operate against PA from there so PA has the right to fire back.

yep if america can do i why not us after all its all cheers when they drone civilians but when someone else does it its wrong typical biased

 

[Pukhtoon]

Okay, ANA had attacked Pakistani posts decades ago but do you mean PA is taking the revenge now?



If our Army does harm Pakistan then attack them directly why to rain blind shells on civilian locations? these mofo militants well know where to hide from shells and I am totally against both Taliban AF/TTP they both have sucked the blood of innocents so from my side there is no sympathy if PA targets TTP in Afghanistan.

I have discussed this issue a while ago; there is a difference between US drones and these shells. These are blind shells which numbers in hundreds and most of them fall in civilian locations - this isn't the first civilian causality from these shells; show me one militant causality from these shells which are falling from last one year or more?




Stories can be made by anyone, evidence please?

PS: few years before ANA was even not able to stand completely against local terrorists how come it went all across the border and attacked Pakistan FC posts?



I honestly didn't read/heard anything like that, if you have the links please post it here.

Close Enough

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Stories can be made by anyone, evidence please?

PS: few years before ANA was even not able to stand completely against local terrorists how come it went all across the border and attacked Pakistan FC posts?

It happened 2 years back.

 

[Sher Malang]

It happened 2 years back.

Provide the source and 2 years ago they were not as strong as today; the number of trained ANA were below 100 thousand, we even didn't had 'special forces' kandaks but 'commandos' which was newly established! I totally doubt your story.

Close Enough

Iftar is near in Pakistan; you better do iftar and come back with something good - decades ago was not the ANA which is today clear?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Provide the source and 2 years ago they were not as strong as today; the number of trained ANA were below 100 thousand, we even didn't had 'special forces' kandaks but 'commandos' which was newly established! I totally doubt your story.

Source... dude my father was the commandant and i was there...

 

[Sher Malang]

Source... dude my father was the commandant and i was there...

My father was also the chief of army at that time and he totally reject this claim.. !

Okay buddy I am not against PA when it comes for killing these militants but it should not harm civilians as it may backfire at it's worse case! lets condemn every bad and cherish good thing and killing civilians is bad.