He deserves to be punished for taking the law in his hands,whatever the reasons.
And you really think everything that the cops in india is legal?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He deserves to be punished for taking the law in his hands,whatever the reasons.
Contrary to what do you believe (or want to believe),I was the 1st to raise the doubt.And no,I'm neither supporting or condemning him based on this particular article.What I was praising him were for his humint network and his intentions to bring those hideous criminals to justice.
And inserting a mole into the terrorrist network is the oldest and most effective way of conducting CO-IN OPs,nothing wrong in that.And about this article,what if the writter got it all wrong that the officer didn't kill those who he encouraged but killed those who were the real ones based on thehir info??Or what if he intentionally did this as a propaganda?See,the possibilities are just endless.
as I said earlier my point of argument is not whether he did the act as said in the article with quotes from cops or not , my argument is if he encouraged and dragged youth in to joining terrorist org to be arrested or killed later then he has done wrong,do you or do you not agree ? The comments on this thread was like " so what if he did so, the youth is guilty of joining terrorist org so deserve to be trapped and killed like that " I don't agree with that.
This is the definition of entrapment and creating armed rebels and fomenting your own insurgency. India consistently blames Pakistan for it's insurgency in Kashmir and says most of the fighters are Punjabi, and now it is known a major Indian police officer in IoK is recruiting rebels and fomenting their rebellion themselves via entrapment. It's not like they are able to kill all of those they recruited.
This also means the rebels India has killed recently may be rebels they themselves recruited and entrapped hence easily killed them.
And you really think everything that the cops in india is legal?
Some times you have to stop thinking about the method and start thinking of getting the job done at any means necessary.There is a reason that phrase was invented that 'Catching the bull by its horns'. . . . . . . . . . .
Nobody can deny that something like this does not happen, but this is a small case, majority of terrorists were pakistanis. You dont see any terrorism in kashmir now, because pakistan stopped pushing them (or cant push them).
Homegrown insurgency simply does not exist anymore there.
Translation: Yes, entrapment does happen, but let's ignore that and concentrate on "terrorism" that used to emanate from Pakistan.
Firstly, Pakistan's support for Kashmir's Muslims is widely seen both within Pakistan, and generally within the wider Muslim world, as a moral issue. It is also NOT the main topic of this thread, which is about the entrapment activities of Sub-Inspector Sharma. Kindly do not derail the thread - there have been other threads that deal with this particular issue, and you can certainly start one of your own.
Secondly, your comment "this is a small case" is counter-factual to the original article, according to which, a wider investigation has been launched into the activities of Sharma and his bodyguard. IF this were a "small case", such an investigation would surely have been unlikely.
You want to present India in a good light? Concentrate on the fact that the authorities at least arrested Sharma, and launched the investigation. Which is considerably superior, morally and legally, to the complete inaction on the part of the British and American authorities (see my previous post) against officers involved in entrapment in their countries. For this, the Indian authorities - and #Agnostic Indian, #SR-91 and #Joekrish on this thread - deserve to be thanked for not trying to defend the morally indefensible.
I am not the one derailing the therad, that should be blamed on the gentleman who tried to imply majority of terrorists are fake terrorists proped up by Indian agencies.
ontopic, I dont want to defend these people, they should launch a proper investigation and punish all involved including the guy in news.