What's new

The Russian-Pakistani $10 Billion Pipeline Will Promote Eurasian Integration

Joined
Jun 15, 2016
Messages
13,768
Reaction score
-2
Country
Netherlands
Location
Netherlands
Written by Andrew KORYBKO on 12/10/2018

Russia and Pakistan signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) late last month to carry out a feasibility study for prospectively building a $10 billion undersea gas pipeline that Moscow hopes will eventually connect Iran, Pakistan, and India.

The megaproject was first floated last November during President Putin’s visit to Tehran at the time, and the progress that’s been made since then to get to the point of signing this MOU speaks to the fast-moving and increasingly strategic nature of Russian-Pakistani relations as each Great Power seeks to diversify their international relationships with non-traditional partners such as one another in order to better adapt to the changing complexities of the emerging Multipolar World Order. Just as importantly, however, it also proves Russia’s willingness to “balance” competing pairs of Great Power rivals in order to retain regional stability, such as what it’s slated to do between Pakistan and India if its pipeline plans succeed. The bet that Russia is tacitly making is that tensions between those two countries will diminish if they enter into a Russian-facilitated relationship of complex interdependency with one another through this pipeline.

There are also other tangential benefits to this megaproject as well.

The first is that it’s much more geopolitically viable than the $10 billion TAPI pipeline from Turkmenistan that has to pass through conflict-plagued Afghanistan, which could potentially become delayed or ultimately rendered unviable if Daesh establishes a presence in the western part of the landlocked country through which this project will traverse. Relatedly, so long as India has the political will to resist the US’ sanctions threats, then the Russian-built pipeline from Iran could ensure that it remains one of the Islamic Republic’s main energy consumers. Even if it doesn’t and the project ends up stopping in Pakistan, then it’s possible that Russia could cooperate with Saudi Arabia – which recently committed billions of dollars to CPEC – and China to build a CPEC-parallel pipeline to the People’s Republic. Failing that, an indisputable point to consider is that Russia and Pakistan are nevertheless still cooperating to break the US-imposed “isolation” of Iran.

Russia-and-Pakistan-signed-a-memorandum-of-understanding.jpg

This seemingly simple observation is a lot more important than many might initially think.

Both partnered Great Powers have years of experience surviving under different manifestations of American pressure, though Iran certainly takes the cake from both of them when it comes to this, and all three will have to pool their collective resolve to resist the increased pressure that they’ll surely come under by the US if they do indeed go forward with these pipeline plans. The combination of their shared incentives to cooperate with one another and the similar position that they’ll be put in vis-à-vis American pressure because of it could conceivably contribute to a strengthening of their trilateral relations that might in turn form an important axis of stability in Eurasia and further the ultimate goal of a Golden Ring of multipolar Great Powers if Turkey and China eventually join this multilateral platform of resistance. Assessed in this manner, Russia’s planned pipeline with Pakistan could be a real geostrategic game-changer.

https://orientalreview.org/2018/10/...n-pipeline-will-promote-eurasian-integration/
 
I really hope our government is aware of the full implications of CAATSA. @GriffinsRule if we can go against CAATSA here, then we should be able to buy the SU-35 as well.

https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/Programs/Documents/hr3364_pl115-44.pdf

SEC. 232. SANCTIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF PIPELINES IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION. (a) IN GENERAL.—The President, in coordination with allies of the United States, may impose five or more of the sanctions described in section 235 with respect to a person if the President determines that the person knowingly, on or after the date of the enactment of this Act, makes an investment described in subsection (b) or sells, leases, or provides to the Russian Federation, for the construction of Russian energy export pipelines, goods, services, technology, information, or support described in subsection (c)— (1) any of which has a fair market value of $1,000,000 or more; or (2) that, during a 12-month period, have an aggregate fair market value of $5,000,000 or more. (b) INVESTMENT DESCRIBED.—An investment described in this subsection is an investment that directly and significantly contributes to the enhancement of the ability of the Russian Federation to construct energy export pipelines. (c) GOODS, SERVICES, TECHNOLOGY, INFORMATION, OR SUPPORT DESCRIBED.—Goods, services, technology, information, or support described in this subsection are goods, services, technology, information, or support that could directly and significantly facilitate the maintenance or expansion of the construction, modernization, or repair of energy export pipelines by the Russian Federation.
 
Undersea pipeline to connect Iran, pakistan and India ?
I dont get it, why undersea when all three are connected by land ?

Moreover pakistan is going for another IMF bailout package so any deal with russians is impossible for pakistan, nor they have stature to go against US sanctions.

So even if india and russia throws its weight behind this since pakistan is a weak link this project is just that a pipe dream.
 
Written by Andrew KORYBKO on 12/10/2018

Russia and Pakistan signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) late last month to carry out a feasibility study for prospectively building a $10 billion undersea gas pipeline that Moscow hopes will eventually connect Iran, Pakistan, and India.

The megaproject was first floated last November during President Putin’s visit to Tehran at the time, and the progress that’s been made since then to get to the point of signing this MOU speaks to the fast-moving and increasingly strategic nature of Russian-Pakistani relations as each Great Power seeks to diversify their international relationships with non-traditional partners such as one another in order to better adapt to the changing complexities of the emerging Multipolar World Order. Just as importantly, however, it also proves Russia’s willingness to “balance” competing pairs of Great Power rivals in order to retain regional stability, such as what it’s slated to do between Pakistan and India if its pipeline plans succeed. The bet that Russia is tacitly making is that tensions between those two countries will diminish if they enter into a Russian-facilitated relationship of complex interdependency with one another through this pipeline.

There are also other tangential benefits to this megaproject as well.

The first is that it’s much more geopolitically viable than the $10 billion TAPI pipeline from Turkmenistan that has to pass through conflict-plagued Afghanistan, which could potentially become delayed or ultimately rendered unviable if Daesh establishes a presence in the western part of the landlocked country through which this project will traverse. Relatedly, so long as India has the political will to resist the US’ sanctions threats, then the Russian-built pipeline from Iran could ensure that it remains one of the Islamic Republic’s main energy consumers. Even if it doesn’t and the project ends up stopping in Pakistan, then it’s possible that Russia could cooperate with Saudi Arabia – which recently committed billions of dollars to CPEC – and China to build a CPEC-parallel pipeline to the People’s Republic. Failing that, an indisputable point to consider is that Russia and Pakistan are nevertheless still cooperating to break the US-imposed “isolation” of Iran.

Russia-and-Pakistan-signed-a-memorandum-of-understanding.jpg

This seemingly simple observation is a lot more important than many might initially think.

Both partnered Great Powers have years of experience surviving under different manifestations of American pressure, though Iran certainly takes the cake from both of them when it comes to this, and all three will have to pool their collective resolve to resist the increased pressure that they’ll surely come under by the US if they do indeed go forward with these pipeline plans. The combination of their shared incentives to cooperate with one another and the similar position that they’ll be put in vis-à-vis American pressure because of it could conceivably contribute to a strengthening of their trilateral relations that might in turn form an important axis of stability in Eurasia and further the ultimate goal of a Golden Ring of multipolar Great Powers if Turkey and China eventually join this multilateral platform of resistance. Assessed in this manner, Russia’s planned pipeline with Pakistan could be a real geostrategic game-changer.

https://orientalreview.org/2018/10/...n-pipeline-will-promote-eurasian-integration/

has the author looked at a map ?
 
has the author looked at a map ?

Discussions on these threads may help regarding the route;

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/pakistan-russia-set-to-make-history-in-moscow-next-week.578886/page-3
https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/paki...ffshore-pipeline-deal-next-week.561711/page-2
https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/saud...ree-cpec-projects.579224/page-4#post-10821707

@maximuswarrior I was too lazy to write all those posts again here, so I shared links to other threads, hopefully its not offending.
 

your links are more confusing
 
your links are more confusing

Ok. Lemme run a hypothesis;

1. From IGAT-7's end point - Iranians will lay an onshore pipeline to South near Chahbahar.
2. At that onshore node, at Chahbahar, Gazprom will establish a common distribution facility with two separate compression stations, supplying gas to two independent pipelines.
i) One to Pakistan, through Persian gulf, into Arabian sea, ending at Gwadar (This pipeline shouldn't be more than 100km).
ii) Second, to India, through Persian Gulf, into Arabian Sea, ending at Gujarat or Mumbai, circumventing Pakistan's all EEZs.

Hope this helps.

upload_2018-10-13_11-55-33.png


eez-jpg.501784
 
Last edited:
Undersea pipeline to connect Iran, pakistan and India ?
I dont get it, why undersea when all three are connected by land ?

Moreover pakistan is going for another IMF bailout package so any deal with russians is impossible for pakistan, nor they have stature to go against US sanctions.

So even if india and russia throws its weight behind this since pakistan is a weak link this project is just that a pipe dream.
Too many variations in your post.... I try to match my reply.

Undersea is Indian request, they don't want any pipeline in Pakistan.
Pakistan is not going to IMF for the first time. As our PM says relax... it's not like heaven has crashed upon us.
Last but not least, don't throw any further weight upon Pakistan.
 
"Pipeline is from Russian operated gas field in Iran", I hope it will help you understand map.

It does not matter who operates the field in Iran. The pipeline goes over Iranian territory. Iran is not known to give others permission to operate pipelines on their soil.

Why build submarine pipeline when you can build one over land ? That is a lot cheaper. It is not like Russia or Pakistan are flush with cash.

If the objective is to make money setup a LNG terminal on the Iranian coast buyers will automatically come

Too many variations in your post.... I try to match my reply.

Undersea is Indian request, they don't want any pipeline in Pakistan.
Pakistan is not going to IMF for the first time. As our PM says relax... it's not like heaven has crashed upon us.
Last but not least, don't throw any further weight upon Pakistan.

Nobody is building undersea pipeline without India signing off on the deal

Ok. Lemme run a hypothesis;

1. From IGAT-7's end point - Iranians will lay an onshore pipeline to South near Chahbahar.
2. At that onshore node, at Chahbahar, Gazprom will establish a common distribution facility with two separate compression stations, supplying gas to two independent pipelines.
i) One to Pakistan, through Persian gulf, into Arabian sea, ending at Gwadar (This pipeline shouldn't be more than 100km).
ii) Second, to India, through Persian Gulf, into Arabian Sea, ending at Gujarat or Mumbai, circumventing Pakistan's all EEZs.

Hope this helps.

View attachment 504803

eez-jpg.501784
your explanation is great. the whole project is uneconomical. It is cheaper to load LNG on ships and send them
 
Nobody is building undersea pipeline without India signing off on the deal

No body will build under sea pipeline even if India's all population sign it off. You really have to be a goose head to actually believe it.
 
Undersea pipeline to connect Iran, pakistan and India ?
I dont get it, why undersea when all three are connected by land ?

Moreover pakistan is going for another IMF bailout package so any deal with russians is impossible for pakistan, nor they have stature to go against US sanctions.

So even if india and russia throws its weight behind this since pakistan is a weak link this project is just that a pipe dream.
Same is my thought .

"Pipeline is from Russian operated gas field in Iran", I hope it will help you understand map.
Bari jabardast planning hai.
 
Back
Top Bottom