Would the creation of a new national language work for Pakistan?

[pak-marine]

Ya alla go ahead I m all for " Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan

 

[KingMamba]

Each province should teach their provincial language and English. Urdu should be dropped as the national language maybe give Karachi Urdu and English.

 

[Bilal.]

Yes there are couple of issues with priority first.
But that doesn't mean to ignore everything else.

Ignore other things like inventing new language while the country is sliding? Well duh!

 

[KingMamba]

If you want to combat bollywood influence Persian should be the national language but truth is we all love to watch Indian kuriya do their little dances but hate having to admit it. Katrina Kaif though.

 

[Bilal.]

If you want to combat bollywood influence Persian should be the national language but truth is we all love to watch Indian kuriya do their little dances but hate having to admit it. Katrina Kaif though.

I don't watch Bollywood... If you are so concerned about Bollywood then why not start by not watching it?

 

[FNFAL]

Dont enforce a "national/official" language. While it works very well for monolithic socities, it will be a bane for multi lingual, multi cultural melting pots.
I guess English and urdu are just as fine ain their current role. You have many other ways to show unity.

My 2 cents!

 

[Jaanbaz]

Official language should be English. But Persian is way better...

Then RIP Persian. Pakistanis will speak Persian in a way that will make Iranian's ears explode.

 

[KingMamba]

I don't watch Bollywood... If you are so concerned about Bollywood then why not start by not watching it?

You missed the sarcasm in my post, I can't help that. I am not concerned about bollywood except the fact that they should work on their horrible fight scenes.

 

[PakhtunGuy]

Ya alla go ahead I m all for " Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan

Thats offensive. Watch your tone.

Each province should teach their provincial language and English. Urdu should be dropped as the national language maybe give Karachi Urdu and English.

Thats more reasonable.
But I don't like to see English as national language.
Mother tongues or provincial languages should be national languages and be protected.
Switzerland has also German, French, Italian and Romansh as national languages.
I wonder how they do it. Maybe Pakistan could take an example?

 

[slapshot]

Many people discussed whether Urdu should be replaced with Persian or Arabic etc.
Because to be honest Urdu has nothing to do with Pakistan and the British made Urdu to the national language of Pakistan since occupation before occupation it was Persian.
Still today Urdu remains national language and English official language of Pakistan. And our mother tongues (Pashto, Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi and Kashmiri [languages spoken in Kashmir region]) are only regional languages.

Making our mother tongues to national languages of Pakistan is the right direction in my opinion and necessary.
But Pakistan being a multi ethnic state also needs a unity language like Urdu today.
Replacing Urdu with Arabic or Persian brings its benifits but it is also not our languages to be honest.

So what if we create a new national language and it replaces Urdu.

One example would be:

Grammar: Balochi (for example)
Vocabulary: Punjabi (20%), Pashto (20%), Sindhi (20%), Balochi (20%) and Kashmiri/Koshur (20%) = 100%
Name of the language: Pakistani (P=Punjab, A= Afghania, K= Kashmir, S= Sindh, TAN= Balochistan)


I know it is not realistic. It is more realistic if Persian or Arabic replaces Urdu.
But what do you think?

No we shouldn't. Personally I think Arabic would have made more sense as national language but now that we have gone through all difficulties to adapt Urdu it would be waste of time looking in other directions. Urdu is understood in every corner of Pakistan and people are are happy with it. A much needed step should be to write/teach all our educational course content in our national language like other developed countries.

 

[pak-marine]

Thats offensive. Watch your tone.

which part offended you mind telling as well .. ?

 

[PakhtunGuy]

which part offended you mind telling as well .. ?

Ya alla go ahead I m all for " Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan

His name is الله or Allah. Subhanahu wa ta3la.
Also there is no such thing as "Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan"
Not even in Arabic.
And whats wrong with Arabic? Arabic is language of Islam, Quran, and Prophet Muhammad saw.

 

[pak-marine]

His name is الله or Allah. Subhanahu wa ta3la.
Also there is no such thing as "Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan"
Not even in Arabic.
And whats wrong with Arabic? Arabic is language of Islam, Quran, and Prophet Muhammad saw.

a)dont object or poke your nose in things which you do not understand before coming up with your religious lecture google ya alla and see what it means

b) i didnt objected to arbic read again my post

 

[Water Car Engineer]

I vote for Arabic.

 

[Musafir117]

I recommend Ishraon ki Zuban, less we talk less we fight each other.