Why do Indians consider Pakistan one of their own vs Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh?

[Jackdaws]

Bullshit. Indus valley civ is indus valley civ. It has nothing to do with bharat nepal or burma. Stop appropriating our history and heritage.

The Indus Valley Civilization has 8 major urban centers. 3 are in present day Pakistan, 5 are in present day India. You just need to deal with it, sadly.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

You are free to believe what you want. If you are uncomfortable with your roots, that's entirely your business. Sindhi and Punjabi are Iranic? Absurd.


Who has denied that it is a separate sovereign entity as well? These seems to be a lot of insecurity and inferiority complex in your words.



When?

Says the lot trying to compare to us in every way possible.

The Indus Valley Civilization has 8 major urban centers. 3 are in present day Pakistan, 5 are in present day India. You just need to deal with it, sadly.

@Indus Pakistan look what we have here

 

[Jackdaws]

Says the lot trying to compare to us in every way possible.

Keep telling yourself that. If no one else does, at least you will start believing it.

 

[jamahir]

What language you speak?
mother tongue

Deccani Urdu.

Example phrase like "Hau katay", to mean "That is how it is".

It is OK. But my question was broad in nature. I intend to know, what at present Deccan implies?

Deccan comprises Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, parts of Karnataka, parts of Maharashtra.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

Keep telling yourself that. If no one else does, at least you will start believing it.

Go on any forum or anywhere where the uncivilized lot of your country has access to and they will flood anything slightly related to Pakistan to show how " us and them are the same" or "they are just like us" do you in your shame deny this fact?

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

The Indus Valley Civilization has 8 major urban centers. 3 are in present day Pakistan, 5 are in present day India. You just need to deal with it, sadly.

And the evidence for that is?.........

 

[SIPRA]

Deccani Urdu.

Is the language, spoken by Asaduddin Owaisi, Deccani Urdu?

 

[Longhorn]

I wonder how long it will be before the Indians revoke Article 370 in Bangladesh.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

look what we have here

I think I have been through this many times. So not going to waste my time over it again but will make following points -

if my garden has a mountain of apples and a few roll into my neighbours garden. Big deal. Is he gonna count the apples that rolled into his garden [10, 15 or 20] and then he has more apples then the mountain I have? I have one mountain of apples. He has 20 apples.

Indus. Yes note Indus. Not Ganga. Mot Brahamaputra. Not Godavari. Not Narmada etc. Now find out which country Indus is analogous top. Look at my name. End of.


Below are major river systems of India. Note that Indus is on the perphery and mainly taken by Kashmir [which is disputed] and Sikh Punjab. That leaves rest of 1.2 billion India either Ganga, Narmada, Brahamaputra etc.

 

[Jackdaws]

And the evidence for that is?.........

Look it up -
5 urban IVC sites in India -
Dholavira
Lothal
Rakhigarhi
Ropar
Kalibanga

3 urban IVC sites in Pak -

Mohenjodaro
Harrapa
Ganweriwal

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

I think I have been through this many times. So not going to waste my time over it again but will make following points -

if my garden has a mountain of apples and a few roll into my neighbours garden. Big deal. Is he gonna count the apples that rolled into his garden [10, 15 or 20] and then he has more apples then the mountain I have? I have one mountain of apples. He has 20 apples.

Indus. Yes note Indus. Not Ganga. Mot Brahamaputra. Not Godavari. Not Narmada etc. Now find out which country Indus is analogous top. Look at my name. End of.


Below are major river systems of India. Note that Indus is on the perphery and mainly taken by Kashmir [which is disputed] and Sikh Punjab. That leaves rest of 1.2 billion India either Ganga, Narmada, Brahamaputra etc.

They will keep telling themselves lies to prove how they are the same people as us. A inferiority complex that's beyond any medication. They will keep lying and keep lying and keep lying. This is a part of whom they are. They have no shame wherever they are proven wrong or b$tch slapped. They will get back up and lie about it not happening. Quite a shamesham lot.

Look it up -
5 urban IVC sites in India -
Dholavira
Lothal
Rakhigarhi
Ropar
Kalibanga

3 urban IVC sites in Pak -

Mohenjodaro
Harrapa
Ganweriwal

Where does the Indus run? India? Stop with you obsession of a foreign state and its history.

 

[Longhorn]

Whr did i say that,,ofcourse pukhtuns r not bhayya.
U think tamils or other south Indians look like northindians,,,,or for that matter northeasterners look anything like others. We r a far more diverse country thn u.
But the point is,,,both have significant population of similar people,,vis a vis the bhayyas.n yes punjabis alongwith kashmiris r bhayya people.

That's a long winded way of saying that in every Pakistani face you see your own historic inferiority and defeat.

 

[Jackdaws]

They will keep telling themselves lies to prove how they are the same people as us. A inferiority complex that's beyond any medication. They will keep lying and keep lying and keep lying. This is a part of whom they are. They have no shame wherever they are proven wrong or b$tch slapped. They will get back up and lie about it not happening. Quite a shamesham lot.


Where does the Indus run? India? Stop with you obsession of a foreign state and its history.

Clearly you neither understand geography nor history. Live in your bubble.

 

[jamahir]

Is the language, spoken by Asaduddin Owaisi, Deccani Urdu?

Yes.

 

[SingHee]

I extremely doubt it, Punjab and Sind were never known as "Hindustan". Hindustan was the area around Delhi and UP only. Different parts of Punjab in earlier times had different "indigenous names" such as the central Punjab was called "Madra" and at some other points it was called "Taka" etc. Sindh was always called Sindh, even parts of southern Punjab, eastern balochistan and southern KPK were also at times considered "greater Sindh". Kashmir was always called "Kashmir" or "Kasperia" etc. in the past, northern parts of KPK areas along with some adjoining areas in eastern Afghanistan were called "Gandhara" for most part of their history. The northern parts of Punjab were called "Pothohar".

There was no such term as "Hindustan" in use in the ancient past, because the term "Hindustan" originated rather recently only during Turkic and Mughals times for areas around Delhi/UP where their centre of power lied. The word "Punjab" was also coined by the same Mughals to "differentiate" the areas lying west of "Hindustan" that is Delhi/UP areas. I read somewhere that one of the Sikh gurus had referred to himself as "Madari" in reference to the ancient name of central Punjab that is "Madra", the the name "Madra" was in use as late as few centuries ago in some circle of central Punjab. I wouldn't be surprised if the word "Majha" for the central Punjab that is still used in indian Punjab is a corrupted form of the ancient name of this region "Madra" and the language spoken in this area which they call in indian punjab as "Majhi" being originally "Madari" language or the modern standard punjabi of central Punjab.

See Madra located in the modern central punjab of Pakistan in the ancient times in this map

According to Indians and some recent western scholars, this whole Hind being a mispronunciation of Sind is based on ancient Persians not being able to pronounce the S in Sind. Completely unbelievable for a people who are known for using the word serpent.

What's even more telling is that many Pakistanis appear to actually believe this.