What's new

Who is engineering the Anti-Dam Campaign on Social Media?

Sindh govt is corrupt but so as rest of Pakistan. But water issue is separate from it and is a real.problem in the south.
If my family loses business just because water has been directed to Punjab or dams been built without considering me , I will do.whatever to take revenge. Do you get the point ?
I don't care much about the project. Pakistanis don't think too much before doing anything :)
What I am saying is that distribute the water evenly or with reasonable proportion.dont just look at the north of Pakistan. It is a huge problem and needs to be taken seriously. You mentioned lack.od drinking water. But where is the water :)
Else we will.keep having bla attacks. And army will be wasted in such issues

Opposing the dams won't resolve your water woes. On the contrary, dams can resolve Sindhi demand for more water. Let the dam get built. If water isn't distributed equally you reserve the right to not only criticise the dam project, but also stage mass protests. I will be the first to support your cause.

Just admit that PPP jiyalas and other obstructionists are playing pety politics.
 
10 years ago , Alice albinia went from Kait bander to north. And she has written the real story in her book. May be time to pick that up. ( Even now it's dated and problem is worse I am.sure )

The below is about water in Larkana, Sindh :

"However, today, water in the canal is no longer potable owing to the disposal of waste in it over the years. People throwing garbage into the canal and buffaloes swimming in it is a frequent sight these days."
https://tribune.com.pk/story/151598...nal-deprives-larkana-residents-potable-water/

You can watch the same in the recent news in this thread :

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/larkana-kab-paris-banega-awam-ki-awaz-samaa-tv-08-march-2020.666696/

You have totally lost it dude. Go to sleep.
It's a long time in iftaar

Opposing the dams won't resolve your water woes. On the contrary, dams can resolve Sindhi demand for more water. Let the dam get built. If water isn't distributed equally you reserve the right to not only criticise the dam project, but also stage mass protests. I will be the first to support your cause.
 
Bhai
Sindh is not getting water already. And you are building a dam. Even fresh world bank said don't build dam on Indus anymore.
Can we talk about fair distribution of water before blaming exploited poople from South ? Punjab is green and rest of the Pakistan is yellow. Please reflect a little

Sir! Trust me, if Sindh wants more water then support building the dams. Building water reservoirs will reduce the wastage of water in the sea. This is the principle all over the world. You can ask centre to fix an quota for Sindh.
 
10 years ago , Alice albinia went from Kait bander to north. And she has written the real story in her book. May be time to pick that up. ( Even now it's dated and problem is worse I am.sure )



You have totally lost it dude. Go to sleep.
It's a long time in iftaar

Stop relying on a foreigner for facts. Use your own common sense. Now a former colonialist is going to teach us on our own historical facts. You seem so impressed by colonial propaganda.

Fact remains that particularly fuedal PPP has used the dam projects time and time again to further its own agenda. It is getting old and tiresome.
 
The water picture of Pakistan
Share:

the-water-picture-of-pakistan-1487046151-8280.jpg

https://nation.com.pk/Columnist/engr-sh-mushtaq-ahmed
Engr. Sh. Mushtaq Ahmed

February 14, 2017

145 is the approximate number of million acre feet (MAF) of surface water annually available to Pakistan on average by nature. It is the one and only country of the Muslim world blessed with such a voluminous, precious and free bounty of nature. The Indus river and its tributaries; Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Sutlej and Beas collectively known as “Indus water basin” is Pakistan’s pivotal source of fresh surface water that forms the backbone of the Pakistani economy, supplying water to the largest irrigation system of the world, that not only provides 90% of dietary needs and contributes 25% to the GDP but also actively replenishes its ground water resources. On top of that, it is a sustainable source of energy security in Pakistan. The break-up of 145 MAF is as follows. Indus (including river Kabul) provides 89.58 MAF annually (61.89% of total annual river flows), Jhelum, 22.69 MAF annually (15.67% of total annual river flows), Chenab 25.45 MAF (17.58 % of total annual river flows), and other unaccounted for diversions, post rim station of the rivers to Kotri barrage plus eastern rivers comprise of 7.0 MAF (4.83% of the total annual river flows). The total comes up to 144.72 or nearly 145 MAF annually. Out of this, on average, 102 MAF is diverted for the irrigation system. System losses (evaporation, seepage, conveyance) equal to 12 MAF annually. Surface water going to the sea is 145-(102+12) = 31MAF annually. Pakistan’s total costal length is 1100 KM, shared by Balochistan and Sindh with 750 and 350 KM respectively, is facing severe threat of land erosion due to sea intrusion. An International Panel of Experts (IPoE) conducted a study in 2004-05 and suggested an annual release of 8.86 MAF of water downstream Kotri to stop the sea intrusion as well as protection against environmental hazards.

Himalayan glaciers that contribute over 80% water to the Indus river (that feeds more than 65% of the country’s agriculture), is receding at the rate of 30 to 50 meters/annum. The Himalaya contains the world’s third largest ice mass after Antarctica and Greenland. Glacial area in Pakistan’s north is spread over an area of 16933 km2. The river Indus which originates from Tibet/China and flowing through middle riparian India enters into territorial limits of Pakistan from Gilgit Baltastan.

In 1950, Pakistan was rated by international agencies as a water abundant country. In 1951, annual water availability in Pakistan per capita stood at 5650 m3 which was more than 3 times the threshold value of 1700 m3/capita/annum. In 1992, the UN Fund for Population stated that Pakistan was a water stressed country with only 1700 m3/capita/annum of the commodity available. In 2003, Pakistan’s per capita availability of water declined from threshold value. Currently Pakistan is a water scarce country with alarmingly reduced availability around 940 m3/capita/annum, which is critically less than the threshold value. The country’s per capita annual water availability is poised to drop further if there is no paradigm shift in the prevalent water infrastructure. The reasons, inter alia, for water scarcity in Pakistan is a simultaneous effect of overpopulation, climate change and more importantly, non-development of major reservoir(s) after Tarbela dam. The Minister for Water and Power Khawaja Asif, has said on the floor of the National Assembly more than once that the water crisis was not too far away and could prove to be more crippling than the current energy crisis we confront. The minister for Planning and Development Ahsan Iqbal, on the occasion of the International Water Day, warned of possible diversion of water by the Afghan government. We need to remain alert about development activities of the Afghan government on Kabul river. If we failed to formulate and implement an effective water management policy, it will lead to a disaster.
Due to the natural phenomenon of sedimentation, the storage capacity of three reservoirs, Mangla, Tarbela and Chashma has reduced from 16 MAF to 11.2 MAF. After raising Mangla Dam, the storage capacity has enhanced to 14.15 MAF. In other words, Pakistan so far, has developed a live storage capacity of 10% of average annual flow of its rivers which is far below the world average 40%. The country’s water storage capacity is limited to a 30-day supply compared to 1000 days for Egypt, 900 days for US, 600 days for Australia and 220 days for India, while the global standard is 120 days.

Anticipating a water crisis in the wake of extreme weather conditions, Indus River System Authority (IRSA) pointed out that minimum 22 MAF storage capacity should be developed at the earliest. In this regard, last year, Chairman IRSA wrote a letter to the Secretary Water and Power, and asked the government to freeze the country’s Public Sector Development Projects (PSDP) for five years and direct these funds for the construction of major water reservoirs on all feasible sites on a war footing as a national priority.
Pakistan built two large multipurpose (storage and power) dams, Mangla (1967) and Tarbela (1975) consequent to Indus Water Treaty (IWT) 1960, which brought the green revolution and food self-sufficiency in the country. Pakistan has not built any large dam since 1975. While water is essential for life, agriculture and industry, the government is neglecting the water sector by allocating mammoth budgetary resources to roads, highways and bridges, including projects like the metro bus and train. 22 MAF of surplus water, which goes to waste annually is a problem, and needs to be conserved by building new storages. There is no site available for construction of a dam on river Chenab while the one on river Jhelum has already been exploited by constructing Mangla Dam. Had the Kalabagh Dam (KBD) on river Indus been constructed, there would have been no need of stop-gap measures to Pakistan’s energy needs such as import of exorbitant LNG which costs the consumers dearly compared to indigenous conventional natural gas. It is high time that all baseless and untrue stances are set aside and an enormously important decision is taken earnestly for setting up the multipurpose KBD (6.1 MAF plus 3600MW) which happens to be technically ready for construction.
 
PPP wrote letters to US asking for F16s to be blocked. So there you have it then.

PPP produced gems like Hussain Haqqani. A man who sits in exile and uses social media to vent frustration against Pakistan. PPP has a vast track record of undermining Pakistan. These fuedal thugs hide behind their fake liberal agenda. They pretend to be avid lovers of democracy. In practice it is all the same rotten filth.
 
Last edited:
Basically PPP along with Indian support. PPP is yet another disgruntled Sindhudesh filth.

Superb analysis. The power of social network data analysis.
The PPP doesn’t care about Sindhudesh ideologically. Manipulating Sindhi nationalism is just another means for the PPP to retain control in Sindh.
 
The PPP doesn’t care about Sindhudesh ideologically. Manipulating Sindhi nationalism is just another means for the PPP to retain control in Sindh.

Most definitely. The current crop of PPP doesn't even care about Benazir Bhutto or the Bhutto clan for that matter. This party has been hijacked by fuedal thugs. It represents the worst of the worst kind. After Zardari hijacked the party PPP DNA got reprogrammed.
 
Last edited:
I remeber when Pano Aqil cantonment was being built there was same hue cry.:coffee:

I hate to say this, but this propaganda reeks with the same BS we have been witnessing lately all over Pakistan. It is just a different setting and a different issue. It is too predictable. The same faces. The same voices.

The state needs to go ahead with the dam project. There should be zero delay and compromise. Anyone who instigates violence needs to be locked up.

If there are genuine concerns regarding water distribution they need to be addressed.
 
I don't see PPP lasting very long as Zardari kids are all looney toons characters vis a vis Pakistani awaam. Some of them might respect them as foreign babu gods but most are not able to realate with them.
Most definitely. The current crop of PPP doesn't even care about Benazir Bhutto or the Bhutto clan for that matter. This party has been hijacked by fuedal thugs. It represents the worst of the worst kind. After Zardari hijacked the party the PPP DNA got reprogrammed.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom