The murder of history in Pakistan

[Rusty]

I suppose Gujrat was just a big understanding, and 47 there was killing on all sides, not just by us.

Hes clearly a troll
leave him, he will be banned soon enough.

 

[SamantK]

Huh? what's the problem?
what did I miss?
I know that the books lie about the wars, what else do you want?

I would like to you guys to see through the lies, which you cannot, and you missed everything.

 

[Kaniska]

Well pakistanis, let me present the cream of the matter in clear words. You all are converted Hindus. (Deny as much as you want by trolling here or by distorting your history books). You cant run away from truth and your self.

It is you who propogated 2-N theory that Muslims cannot live with hindus. We did not. You had probelms with hindus we dont.

Pakistan is not created on the basis of ethnic, linguistic or cultural background. It is a sort of artificial state. The only glue that holds your state together is the Anti-India rhetoric and shared hatread towards hindus. Shed the hatread and you will see that you are no difernt that Indian muslim or even from your distant relative, the Indian hindu.

Pakistan-Hatred=India.

So time and again you need to shore up the anti_india and anti Hindu sentiments which is fundamentally critical to your existence.

You are spot on dude...But one small correction to be added...

Pakistan-Hatred to Evil Hindu=India

Hence pakistan can not even imagine stop hating India becoz they know that what will be its outcome....
The prime example is BD...For a moment BD people thought that Evil Hindoos are not be hated( Of course the story is different now)...And the results are very much clear in 1971. And now having an experience of 1971 Pakistan Gov and Army can never think of encouraging and entertaining anything that can bring any positive thought about India..So distortion of history is a part of this entire package.....

 

[pak-marine]

Some of the people bred on these books become journalists, columnists and editors of popular magazines and digests … making all possible allowances for’ the margin of duplication, we are still left with a very conservative figure of say thirty million people being told what they should not be told and hearing what they should not hear.
1
spot on thats where the problem lies , people were taught robbers were heros ...! and its not just Pakistani history books Islamic books are also altered to suit individuals or groups agendas ...

 

[Rusty]

The reason why I was hesitant to thank her...lest she be labeled as an India lover...which is absolutely false. She must be more patriotic than any other Pakistani.

Just like how the Maoist are more patriotic then any other Indians

 

[Rafi]

Of course I didn't
Why would I learn about Indian history in My Canadian education?

ANd yes I did answer your question.
History is a narrative of the people.
In my Canadian History we were taught about how great the European settlers were and how they brought all the good things with them. We were never taught how they butchered the natives or how they stole the land.

As for Pakistan, if we taught about every single king who ruled, then people would have to stay in school till they were 40.
Those kings are not important in our narrative.

Here, Here - all countries and societies embellish or have myths signifying their establishment, case in point the national holiday of thanksgiving in the US and Canada, ask a Native American what he thinks of that.

The reason why I was hesitant to thank her...lest she be labeled as an India lover...which is absolutely false. She must be more patriotic than any other Pakistani.

Who are indians to tell us, who is a patriot or not, Miss Roy is also a great indian patriot - I am sure you agree.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Of course I didn't
Why would I learn about Indian history in My Canadian education?

ANd yes I did answer your question.
History is a narrative of the people.
In my Canadian History we were taught about how great the European settlers were and how they brought all the good things with them. We were never taught how they butchered the natives or how they stole the land.

As for Pakistan, if we taught about every single king who ruled, then people would have to stay in school till they were 40.
Those kings are not important in our narrative.

Didint know u had ur education in canada...
But what i have mentioned is the point of the thread..
U see indonesians are also muslims, but they respect their hindu heritage..
They have built statues of arjuna and krishna in jakarta, with quotes from mahabharata.. Their national symbol is garuda.. Their AF is called garuda air force.. Garuda is mount of lord vishnu..
we are not expecting u guys to name after gods.. Just mentioning it in history books will be good...

 

[RazPaK]

Where on earth we have blatant lies and hatred in text books? North Korea?

Why should i not be critical of this, the textbooks actually groom people to get confused and with introduction of all the pan Islamic stuff we have a confused nation which cannot even dare properly condemn the monsters which are eating her. Everything gets termed a conspiracy and any one daring to differ is a self hater

But you are not being intellectually honest.


Why do I need to be groomed to hate India?

My mother's uncle is still alive, being a mute from having his tongue cut out by Sikh fundos.

The monsters you are referring to are the lib facists, that cannot provide solutions to any problem, but beat a dead horse.

Pakistan as a society is evolving, so essentially you and other libs are preaching to the choir.

And preaching for the sake of money and doggy biscuts from Bhartis and the west.

 

[Rusty]

I would like to you guys to see through the lies, which you cannot, and you missed everything.

I have said this before and I will say it again, what is it with you people and one liners?

Why can't you guys elaborate your point and make it clear with logical and thought out points?

Simply saying "see through the lies" is not enough. We are not in your temple looking for enlightenment.

And just so there are no confusions, I have never had any education in Pakistan, so I don't know which "lies" you want me to see through.

 

[humanfirst]

Pakistan wasn't only part of this civilisation, it was also the birthplace of it. That's right, you claim you hate us yet your following a Pakistani religion

The lands mentioned in great hindu epics vedas are scattered throughout indian subcontinent,From Indraprastha,ayodya,dwaraka to ghandhara..It is not the heritage any one single modern nation but the whole of south asia including India,pakistan,Bangladesh and nepal.

 

[Rafi]

Didint know u had ur education in canada...
But what i have mentioned is the point of the thread..
U see indonesians are also muslims, but they respect their hindu heritage..
They have built statues of arjuna and krishna in jakarta, with quotes from mahabharata.. Their national symbol is garuda.. Their AF is called garuda air force.. Garuda is mount of lord vishnu..
we are not expecting u guys to name after gods.. Just mentioning it in history books will be good...

Good for the Indonesian people, but it is our decision what our outlook should be, not for foreigners.

 

[Rusty]

Didint know u had ur education in canada...
But what i have mentioned is the point of the thread..
U see indonesians are also muslims, but they respect their hindu heritage..
They have built statues of arjuna and krishna in jakarta, with quotes from mahabharata.. Their national symbol is garuda.. Their AF is called garuda air force.. Garuda is mount of lord vishnu..
we are not expecting u guys to name after gods.. Just mentioning it in history books will be good...

The difference between Indonesia and Pakistan is that Indonesia does not have a neighbor 4x it's size that is actively hostile to it.

 

[SamantK]

I have said this before and I will say it again, what is it with you people and one liners?

Why can't you guys elaborate your point and make it clear with logical and thought out points?

Simply saying "see through the lies" is not enough. We are not in your temple looking for enlightenment.

And just so there are no confusions, I have never had any education in Pakistan, so I don't know which "lies" you want me to see through.

Read the posts which have been presented already, I expected that you have read the whole thread but you have not. There is no point explaining something which has already been explained, just read the whole thread, many 'lies' are presented.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Good for the Indonesian people, but it is our decision what our outlook should be, not for foreigners.

History is not ur or mine decision to take... Its not what u choose to become... Its about what had happened...
And said, u didnt know things about ur own anchestors which i had mentioned earlier at post 90... So u dont know them, proves what ur govt had decided about ur anchestors like porus or the general which ur family claim heritance from...

 

[veer bhogya vasundhara]

Pakistan wasn't only part of this civilisation, it was also the birthplace of it. That's right, you claim you hate us yet your following a Pakistani religion

another delusionary reply........ there was no pakistan then...... it was BHARAT...... be it pakistan or india..... no one hates the land..... its the people who bring shame to land....talking about radicals both in pakistan and india..... hope u understand.