Should Pakistan just repatriate Kashmiri Muslims?

[third eye]

Maybe a storm in the eye?

Thats why I am personally in favour of keeping Pakistan's Hindu population. So that we can take jizya from them. Imposing jizya on them will humiliate India.

Which storm ?

They already are Hindus in Pak, do you guys take Jaziya from them ?

Humiliate India !! They are Pak citizens, you recommend that Pak unjustly burdens its own citizens to humiliate another nation ? !!

Brilliant .

 

[Apprentice]

Another gem from a madrassah-graduate! The only people you will ever humiliate in the rush to prove your stupidity to the world at large, are yourselves.

Most Muslims no longer care what non-Muslim thinks of us.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Most Muslims no longer care what non-Muslim thinks of us.

Barring exceptions, they never did.

 

[third eye]

Also they will go back to help their relatives

If they cross legally , they are welcome.

Cross illegally & they stop a bullet

 

[Acknowledge]

Jammu Muslims can be sent to Mirpur and Poonch divisions of Azad Kashmir. Since those 2 divisions are the same ethnically/culturally as Jammu and were once part of the same Jammu province in the old princely state.

Ladakh Muslims can go to Gilgit Baltistan. Again geographically and ethnically/culturally contiguous and were part of the same Frontier province of the old princely state.\

Kashmir Valley Muslims can be shifted to Muzaffarabad division of Azad Kashmir (since that was part of the old Kashmir province and and also has a large ethnic Kashmiri population).

Its more important for Kashmiri people to be free and their sufferings to end. Sometimes I fell they should just do hijrat to Azad Kashmir. Many Kashmiris have already come across the LOC (illegally and at huge peril). People in Indian occupied Kashmir say that the Indian government does not allow them to migrate to Azad Kashmir.

If we can't get Kashmiri land free then we should at least repatriate Kashmiris to the free side of their homeland.

What do you think?

Don't take it personally. Pakistan Army doesn't give a damn about the Kashmiris. They want the land.

 

[Apprentice]

Which storm ?

They already are Hindus in Pak, do you guys take Jaziya from them ?

Humiliate India !! They are Pak citizens, you recommend that Pak unjustly burdens its own citizens to humiliate another nation ? !!

Brilliant .

The only reason Jinnah wanted to keep Pakistan's Hindu minority was to use them as hostage to make sure India's Muslim minority would be given their rights. Thats what was decided in the Lahore resolution between the Muslim league leaders of all the British Indian provinces.

Don't take it personally. Pakistan Army doesn't give a damn about the Kashmiris. They want the land.

There are Kashmiris in Pak Army. The two are inseparable.

 

[third eye]

The only reason Jinnah wanted to keep Pakistan's Hindu minority was to use them as hostage to make sure India's Muslim minority would be given their rights. Thats what was decided in the Lahore resolution between the Muslim league leaders of all the British Indian provinces.

Please share a link to the part in bold.

Has this silly idea worked ?

 

[Acknowledge]

There are Kashmiris in Pak Army. The two are inseparable.

Just like we have Kashmiris in police and paramilitary forces.

The reality is different. Pakistan Army wants Kashmir land for obvious strategic reasons. The people of Kashmir are used as a fig leaf to fool gullible masses.

 

[Bombaywalla]

Most Muslims no longer care what non-Muslim thinks of us.

I can't disagree with that 'cause if you did, you wouldn't be in half the mess you are in today.

 

[Zibago]

If they cross legally , they are welcome.

Cross illegally & they stop a bullet

The help will involve things Indians dont like

 

[Apprentice]

Please share a link to the part in bold.

Has this silly idea worked ?

https://books.google.com.au/books?i...ties hostage theory lahore resolution&f=false

 

[Zibago]

The only reason Jinnah wanted to keep Pakistan's Hindu minority was to use them as hostage to make sure India's Muslim minority would be given their rights. Thats what was decided in the Lahore resolution between the Muslim league leaders of all the British Indian provinces.



There are Kashmiris in Pak Army. The two are inseparable.

Nope they were kept here because they have as much right on Pakistan as you and I

 

[SarthakGanguly]

The only reason Jinnah wanted to keep Pakistan's Hindu minority was to use them as hostage to make sure India's Muslim minority would be given their rights. Thats what was decided in the Lahore resolution between the Muslim league leaders of all the British Indian provinces.

True. The shrewdest Indian in the 20th century.

Nope they were kept here because they have as much right on Pakistan as you and I

Boy, the Bhatt in you is still strong.

 

[hussain0216]

Just like we have Kashmiris in police and paramilitary forces.

The reality is different. Pakistan Army wants Kashmir land for obvious strategic reasons. The people of Kashmir are used as a fig leaf to fool gullible masses.

Kashmir is a muslim majority state should like the rest of Pakistan had the right to separate from india and hindus

 

[Apprentice]

Nope they were kept here because they have as much right on Pakistan as you and I

Pakistan was founded on the basis of the two nation theory. How can Hindus belong in Pakistan? Quaid e Azam wanted to keep them so we could ensure the rights of the Muslims left behind in India.