Samjhauta Express bombing carried out by indian army officer

[ajpirzada]

Well not really, what this moron is saying has nothing to do with what ground investigation is showing .



Samjhauta blast was a fire bombing using plastic bottles. What he's saying is just BS, he'll sell his mom and dad, if he's not done it already for politics.

yes. he should have given the exact make of each bomb blast in a public gathering. wat a stupid politician this Congress General Secretary is? so who else will sell who?

 

[toxic_pus]

yes. he should have given the exact make of each bomb blast in a public gathering. wat a stupid politician this Congress General Secretary is? so who else will sell who?

Is Mr Digvijay Singh a part of investigation team ? Here's what a member of the investigating team had to say, prior to his tragic death.

A lot has been made of the Samjhauta Express statement that was made by the public prosecutor in the case. There was a statement made by the witness that Purohit helped in the procurement of RDX. That was a part of the case diary. It cannot be taken as gospel truth. What was wrong was the mention of the same to the media, although we had said that there is no such evidence of the same.

http://www.tehelka.com/story_main40.asp?filename=Ne061208thereis_enough.asp

 

[ajpirzada]

Is Mr Digvijay Singh a part of investigation team ? Here's what a member of the investigating team had to say, prior to his tragic death.

no he is not. but being a General Secretary he should be knowing wat is happening in his country. meaning he must be aware of the investigation.

and here u go

Purohit supplied RDX for Samjhauta bomb: ATS - Express India

secondly, the statement which u quoted was technically right as the investigation was still underway and therefore no point taking someones name.

 

[toxic_pus]

no he is not. but being a General Secretary he should be knowing wat is happening in his country. meaning he must be aware of the investigation.

Mr Singh is only the General Secretary of a political party, not even a minister in the current Government. Why should he be privy to an investigation?

and here u go

Purohit supplied RDX for Samjhauta bomb: ATS - Express India

secondly, the statement which u quoted was technically right as the investigation was still underway and therefore no point taking someones name.

Where do I go? You have posted the very report(s) that Mr Karkare debunked. Clue: check the dates. He was not only making a point of not taking names while the investigation was underway, he categorically denied any evidence of Purohit being involved.

 

[ajpirzada]

Mr Singh is only the General Secretary of a political party, not even a minister in the current Government. Why should he be privy to an investigation?


Where do I go? You have posted the very report(s) that Mr Karkare debunked. Clue: check the dates. He was not only making a point of not taking names while the investigation was underway, he categorically denied any evidence of Purohit being involved.

well i expect a general secretary of ruling party to be in touch with wats happenin in the country. not sure how it works in india.

he did not debunk anything but only said that 'it cannot be taken as Gospel truth'...... and this means what the witness is sayin is to be verified. and u can only verify it once u start looking for evidence which was non existent till then as the possible link was only established after the witness spoke.

the link i provided clearly indicates the direction in which this case was going.

lets wait for the final report if it ever comes out.

 

[toxic_pus]

well i expect a general secretary of ruling party to be in touch with wats happenin in the country. not sure how it works in india.

That may be how the affairs in Pakistan are managed. Not in India.

he did not debunk anything but only said that 'it cannot be taken as Gospel truth'...... and this means what the witness is sayin is to be verified. and u can only verify it once u start looking for evidence which was non existent till then as the possible link was only established after the witness spoke.

And what about this comment:

'...we had said that there is no such evidence of the same'

Does this comment count as anything at all?

the link i provided clearly indicates the direction in which this case was going.

lets wait for the final report if it ever comes out.

And Mr Karkare indicated that you are looking in the wrong direction.

 

[ajpirzada]

That may be how the affairs in Pakistan are managed. Not in India.


And what about this comment:

'...we had said that there is no such evidence of the same'

Does this comment count as anything at all?

And Mr Karkare indicated that you are looking in the wrong direction.

i have already answered this question.

and u can only verify it once u start looking for evidence which was non existent till then as the possible link was only established after the witness spoke.

 

[PakSher]

Col. Prohit is the terrorist behind the Samjotha Express, he is in hiding, but needs to be extradited to Pakistan. We should also issue an Interpol warrant for his arrest. Indian Government was definately involved in this.

 

[hal-fgfa]

Col. Prohit is the terrorist behind the Samjotha Express, he is in hiding, but needs to be extradited to Pakistan. We should also issue an Interpol warrant for his arrest. Indian Government was definately involved in this.

dude their are lots of terrorist in ur side those need to be extradited to india............... first think about them

 

[toxic_pus]

i have already answered this question.

and u can only verify it once u start looking for evidence which was non existent till then as the possible link was only established after the witness spoke.

Given that Mr Karkare was the head of ATS investigating the Samjhota express his unambiguous comment of 'no evidence' would have indicated, under normal circumstances, that they had already looked into the evidence, after the witness spoke, and established there was no connection between Purojit and the blast. However I understand why it is necessary for a Pakistani to spin that like a top.

Now either it is your inner Pakistani that is spinning it, or you have access to some information that we don't.

 

[Bang Galore]

well i expect a general secretary of ruling party to be in touch with wats happenin in the country. not sure how it works in india.

Well! See what happened to the President of the same party when he made similar allegations some 10 years ago. He had to finally issue a grovelling apology. So much for their credibility !


Kesri to face trial in RSS defamation case
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
NEW DELHI, OCT 15: A city court today framed charges against former Congress president Sitaram Kesri for allegedly defaming the RSS by holding the Hindu organisation responsible for last year's Coimbatore bomb blasts in which over 60 people were killed.

Chief Metropolitan Magistrate (CMM) R K Gauba, who also dismissed Kesri's application for discharge, fixed January 17 and 18 next year for commencement of trial in the case after the former Congress chief pleaded `not guilty'.

`These allegations coming from the mouth of the leader of the oldest political party of the country are capable of being understood in a defamatory manner only...' Gauba said, quoting his predecessor Prem Kumar's April 1998 order summoning Kesri in the case.

Kesri had sought his discharge in the case in July, saying he had made the alleged defamatory statement against the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh `in good faith and for the protection of public good', and requested the court to recall the summons.

The RSS had dragged Kesri andtwo newspapers - the Times of India and the Nav Bharat Times - to court in April last year for allegedly defaming the organisation by holding it responsible for the Coimbatore bomb blasts during last year's Lok Sabha poll campaign.

The court asked Kesri to face trial and prove himself innocent.

`The accused (Kesri)... while seeking dropping of these proceedings is not restraining himself to the claim of a bonafide belief in the truth of his utterances, but has rather chosen to reiterate and re-assert those allegations against the complainant (RSS) which formed part of his impugned statement leading to his summoning.

"He has chosen the path of justifying his assertion not on mere `belief' but on `truth' of the allegation levelled by him. This gives rise to various questions which would need trial," the court observed.

On September 14, RSS had withdrawn the case against the Times of India and the Nav Bharat Times following publication of correction/clarification by thenewspapers in their September 11 editions published from the capital.

The CMM had separated Kesri's trial from that of the two newspapers following a Delhi high court order to this effect early this year.

Copyright © 1999 Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Ltd.

lets wait for the final report if it ever comes out.

That would be an excellent idea especially since in any case you are basing your entire suspicion on the basis of the statements of Indian investigators and now of Indian politicians. It was Indian investigators who after all arrested Col.Purohit and no one in the government or the army stopped them. There is no reason to believe that a congress government will support Hindu organisations whatsoever.

yup. quite different from wat ground investigation is pointing towards.

Why would the Americans want to and what would they gain from making an accusations against LeT members and that too in the U.N.?

I make no bones of the fact that Hindu organisations that indulge in terror deserve the same treatment that terrorists belonging to any other religion should get. If in the end, Hindu terrorists are indeed implicated in the Samjautha blasts they will get no sympathy from me. Col.Purohit, even if he was not involved in this train blast was involved in a terrorist attack (in Malegaon) and he deserves to get exemplary punishment for it. No one is supporting that scumbag.

It's just that self serving members of the Congress or the communists are regarded with suspicion and no great sanctity is attached to their words.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Given that Mr Karkare was the head of ATS investigating the Samjhota express his unambiguous comment of 'no evidence' would have indicated, under normal circumstances, that they had already looked into the evidence, after the witness spoke, and established there was no connection between Purojit and the blast. However I understand why it is necessary for a Pakistani to spin that like a top.

Now either it is your inner Pakistani that is spinning it, or you have access to some information that we don't.

Its just spin, just an excuse to save Hafeez Saeed.

One accused had claimed that Purohit had suppied RDX for Samjhauta blast (except that RDX was not used there)

Then ATS itself clarified that they'd investigated the angle and concluded Purohit had nothing to do with Samjhauta. This was BEFORE Karkare was killed by Pakistani terrorists (shoo away conspiracy theorists!)

The same angle was investigated by IB and Haryana Police independently, same conclusion. Infact IB named Arif Qasmani of Karachi BEFORE UN named him and sanctioned him. All this I've posted with links on the Abhinav bharat thread, in case anyone really wants to know and not just keep spinning.

 

[ejaz007]

dude their are lots of terrorist in ur side those need to be extradited to india............... first think about them

We would be happy to hand them over to you. The less we have the better.

 

[mahi25]

terrorism has only one color that is black..!!and yes they might have done because of years of attacks on india by pakistan and the inefficiency of government to tackle those attacks