[Request] Source of Sprartly Islands Belonging to China

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

I'm tired of explaining this map to Vietnamese,learn Hanzi before you make stupid claims.

Show me so-called chinese "historical territory" bullshit in SCS on the chinese map 1904?

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

1838 Vietnam Map:

Đại Nam entire map drawn in 1838 by Emperor Minh Mạng, it show Paracels and Spratly belong to Vietnam (that time Vietnamese still used Chinese characters)

 

[Snomannen]

1838 Vietnam Map:

Đại Nam entire map drawn in 1838 by Emperor Minh Mạng, it show Paracels and Spratly belong to Vietnam (that time Vietnamese still used Chinese characters)

Those islands don't even looks like Paracels and Spratly at all if you compare this map to the modern map.

 

[Grand Historian]

Show me so-called chinese "historical territory" bullshit in SCS on the chinese map 1904?

No wonder you Vietnamese love to fabricate history you can't even read Hanzi!

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

Those islands don't even looks like Paracels and Spratly at all if you compare this map to the modern map.

You should not ask for a map of Vietnam in 1838 which can be drawn exactly like a modern map today.
You can read the captions on the two islands (by chinese characters), it means Paracels and Spratlys. Clearly, the map shows the two islands belong to Vietnam.

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

1838 Vietnam Map:

Đại Nam entire map drawn in 1838 by Emperor Minh Mạng, it show Paracels and Spratly belong to Vietnam (that time Vietnamese still used Chinese characters)

When Hainan was part of Vietnam?

Make a more realistic one next time.

 

[Snomannen]

You should not ask for a map of Vietnam in 1838 which can be drawn exactly like a modern map today.
You can read the captions on the two islands (by chinese characters), it means Paracels and Spratlys. Clearly, the map shows the two islands belong to Vietnam.

Of course they can't be as same as the modern one, but at least you have to make them "similiar".
I can't really find any resemblance here. None of the distance and the distribution of the islands march each other.
Are you really sure that 黃沙 and 萬里長沙 are Paracels and Spratlys, isn't there a possibility that you mistaked your 黃沙 and 萬里長沙 to other people's Paracels and Spratlys?

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

No wonder you Vietnamese love to fabricate history you can't even read Hanzi!

Ok, evidences will be tested carefully, independently, if your country is ready to go with Vietnam to an international court to settle disputes. We have experts on Han Zi which used in the history of vietnam.

Những "bằng chứng thép" khơi niềm tự hào Trường Sa, Hoàng Sa | Các vấn đề xã hội | An toàn vệ sinh thực phẩm |

 

[Grand Historian]

Ok, evidences will be tested carefully, independently, if your country is ready to go with Vietnam to an international court to settle disputes. We have experts on Han Zi which used in the history of vietnam.

Những "bằng chứng thép" khơi niềm tự hào Trường Sa, Hoàng Sa | Các vấn đề xã hội | An toàn vệ sinh thực phẩm |

Your own experts can't even read the title of the 1904 map correctly

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

Besides many maps, Vietnam has many evidences in writing, showing the two islands belong to Vietnam.
This is one of them:

 

[Snomannen]

Germany and France seems to consider that Paracels and Spratlys are Chinese territory:

Where in the World is the Philippines?: Debating Its National Territory - Rodolfo Severino - Google 圖書

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

A rough translation, Complete map of provinces under direct Imperial Administration(ie Qing)

Your own experts can't even read the title of the 1904 map correctly

It means "Complete map of provinces under direct Imperial administration" as you said, so Which province the two islands belong to?

 

[Rechoice]

Geneva 1954, bro.

he he sorry for typing mistake, Geneva 1954.

 

[EastSea]

When Hainan was part of Vietnam?

Make a more realistic one next time.

we lost Hainan to China over 2,000 year when han dynasty expanded to south, kid.

 

[Peter]

I don't have time to walk you though Chinese texts read 論衡.說苑,白虎通,風俗通義 etc to see that Yuechang's location was unknown.

Which part of the Chinese Han Zi that you Grand Historian could not read?

《 尚书大传 》：
交趾 之南，有 越裳国 ，周公居摄六年，制礼作乐，天下和，越裳氏以三象重译，而献白雉
交阯 ，字亦作 交趾 ， 交趾郡 （ 交阯郡 ），西汉郡治，今越南 河内市

I have cited the source 《 尚书大传 》, so that you now would have broaden your knowledge about "Yuechang" ...

Need to learn Chinese or Chinese History ... do come to my class Chinese History 101 ... Grand Historian