Pakistan Navy forces out an armed Indian Submarine from Pakistani waters.

[Windjammer]

Sub was already surfaced.

There is no way, to make submarine surface without attacking it.

The deployment of a sonar in close proximity of the vehicle usually sends the message home that the game is up.

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

Isn't this Pakistani Territory??

Pakistani territory is till 12 NM from the coast.
Outside of that it is the EEZ of Pakistan, but not territory and any one can transit through those waters.

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

It should've been shot down or boarded.

 

[ravi gupta]

it entered pakistani waters and as soon as it did that. humiliation was waiting for them.

It enter pakistani water you should have caught and arrested the crew then it was utter humilation,man it came back unhurt and collected the data whatever they want so mission accomplished.Now you can write and celebrate.

 

[Qamar shah1]

Atlantic ka bdla le lina Chaiy tha aj

 

[danger007]

As per some members it is a Nuke Sub yet many suggesting to blow up near pakistani waters... seriously guys?

 

[Tamilnadu]

no. hanuman submarines went back undetected.

Bro,keep religion out of it some of my countrymen worship hanuman like you worship allah.if in reasponce i use allah you wont like it.

If our submarines where detected before, when and where ?

 

[danger007]

Earlier Indian French Scorpenes were compromised thanks to Germany. Now it seems like even Indian Russian subs have also been compromised due to emerging Russian-Pakistan nexus...

Indo-Russian relations are being sacrificed at the alter of emerging Russo-Pakistan relations....

Nice analysis.

 

[Muhammad Omar]

Pakistani territory is till 12 NM from the coast.
Outside of that it is the EEZ of Pakistan, but not territory and any one can transit through those waters.

Thanks sir g

 

[Bilal Khan 777]

The deployment of a sonar in close proximity of the vehicle usually sends the message home that the game is up.

Active Sonar.

 

[Shot-Caller]

we cannot see any evidence ? can you share video evidence? please whole wold like to see....

Especially we would like to know which Sub? Kilo Class or German ONe?

U dont know which sub it was? because if u find sub u can tell which type it is ....lol , Sonar signature .. one more fake story busted....

This thread is full of the video. It was a german submarine 209. We humiliate your forces with proof. We don't make up stories like surgical strikes out of thin air.

 

[Divergent]

Stay in your lane.

 

[Osiris]

The deployment of a sonar in close proximity of the vehicle usually sends the message home that the game is up.

And you think, that would make a submarine surface ?

Firstly, using Active Sonar, gives the position of surface vessel and a firing solution faster than you can say the words "Torpedo , Torpedo, Torpedo", makes it sitting duck.

Secondly a submarine only surfaces, when

1) Either its ballast tanks are damaged.

2) Its hull is breached, and in order to survive, it will rather surface thank, sink.

3) It need carry out repairs or charge its batteries, while running on Diesel engines,

Or Most importantly

4) if it wants too, like Chinese submarine surfacing in middle of a NATO exercise, a few years back.
Or Swedish subs surfacing within torpedo firing range of American carrier.

All the above situations are intentional decision taken by the submarine commander.

P.S. : you should stick to aircrafts , naval discussions are not your niche.

 

[CHD]

Humiliation? shame? why would india be humiliated. Its sub came back scratch free after giving a stern warning.

Idiot, at came back with Gun at its head. How is that a win?

 

[Mrc]

And you think, that would make a submarine surface ?

Firstly, using Active Sonar, gives the position of surface vessel and a firing solution faster than you can say the words "Torpedo , Torpedo, Torpedo", makes it sitting duck.

Secondly a submarine only surfaces, when

1) Either its ballast tanks are damaged.

2) Its hull is breached, and in order to survive, it will rather surface thank, sink.

3) It need carry out repairs or charge its batteries, while running on Diesel engines,

Or Most importantly

4) if it wants too, like Chinese submarine surfacing in middle of a NATO exercise, a few years back.
Or Swedish subs surfacing within torpedo firing range of American carrier.

All the above situations are intentional decision taken by the submarine commander.

P.S. : you should stick to aircrafts , naval discussions are not your niche.

Sub can also surface when its gets a message that if it does not it will face an attack....actually that is a standard operating procedure in peace times