Pakistan Navy forces out an armed Indian Submarine from Pakistani waters.

[Falcon26]

how could we drown a submarine who showed peace signal by comming to surface.

No one would care whether it showed peace signal or not once it is blown. What was an Indian submarine doing inside enemy waters at a time of heightened tensions?

 

[Hyde]

One maasumaana sawaal (innocent question):

What was India's objective behind sending it's submarine on a snooping mission towards/into Pakistan's territorial waters? Did it achieve that objective?

I think they just wanted to test if Pakistan has the ability to detect it...

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

According to navy it was being tracked for the past 5 days and waited till it entered Pakistani waters and was escorted back to international waters.

Why escorted? have we forgotten our atlantic-1 maritime plane they shot in 99?

 

[HAIDER]

No need to pay much attention to the Media hype.

The sources says that However, Indian Sub was detected well that surfaced turned back and gone, which itself proven is a message to them. As many said why did not attack, then the sub was not in our territorial waters but close to, so was detected in time and shooed and was not attacked at all. Detection of Sub Type thing itself is a message to the adversary/operator that her most lethal weapon is still in view/visible. True that either the Sub had some fault as being detected or it was indeed the intelligence that pinned the location while PN moved and done the needful.

In rules of engagement during peace time , if Sub detect in hostile posture, native country fleet order to come on surface to identify or locked down for fire at will. But, still lots of speculation , until PN or foreign office say something about incident.

 

[HOTSUN]

View attachment 353238 Breaking news:
indian navy nuclear submarine was successfully detected in pakistani sea. the submarine was forced to move out of pakistani water. the submarine mission was to enter pakistani water and remain there undetected and spy on pakistani navy movement. the submarine had the capacity to remain deep in water for atleast 9 months. it proves pakistan anti submarine warfare capabilities.
Pakistan navy
It is considered as an anti gawader operation. trying to help terrorists enter gawader and sabotage cpec. recently retired pakistan navy commodore.

source ARY News

latest news is that india tried to do a surgical strike against gawader.

exclusive picture of indian submarine

GREAT WORK, KEEP IT UP AND WELL DONE
PAK NAVY ZINDA BAD
MAY ALLAH KEEP OUR PAKISTAN IN HIS BLESSINGS
AMEEN

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

A great achevment of Pak Nevy.

What great achievement?. Can you elaborate it.
It is normal and just situational awareness. There is nothing to celebrate it. This is duty of navy.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

No one would care whether it showed peace signal or not once it is blown. What was an Indian submarine doing inside enemy waters at a time of heightened tensions?

just hightening tension for domestic consumption. Pakistan know they want us to do something so that a war type situation is created.
surgical strike was also a drama for similar purpose. they want to give terrorists in afghanistan a chance to make themselves stronger again in western border areas.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

I am no expert but if you locate a spying plane you do all you can to land it in your country (China did that with US, even Iran did it with one of US drones) ............ why this submarine was (if it was in Pakistani water) let go that easily? The crew and sub should have been detained. Who would mind a sub full of Yadevs and Chohans.....

@Indus Falcon @MastanKhan @Khafee ???????

PN saysit was in international waters and was quite close to our territory, i say we could have still gotten them,

if a nuclear submarine can be detected than other are just a joke. it was your most elite.

Nuklear ones are easiest to detect

 

[Peer Haman Shah]

They always play the game of chor and sepahi which is dangerous for them.

 

[The Eagle]

They should have lured this submarine into Pakistani waters and then blown it up into thousand pieces like they lured that Indian naval intelligence officer straight into isi hands. This would not only have called india'a bluff but would have even created a political crisis for Modi at home. As I said, a missed opportunity.

The Sub thing is not just like Kulbhashan which was caught red handed though whatever you exemplified is never seen in Military that too between arch rivals like Pakistan-India. We know, many of times A/Cs are being radar locked to tell that "Stay Away". Rules of Engagement (RoE) must kept in view during operations and we are not some kind of back stabbers like the enemy (there is an example but no need to drag in merely not to diver the topic).

The Surrendered must not be shot at all, only cowards does that. We detected them, they acknowledged and surfaced, turned back (a white flag to say) and the message sent while on other hand PN happy with its such operation as well as the Nation that surely, security is in competent hands. I would rather say, it was more practical and better than such type of engagements during exercises to learn, which proved preparedness of PN in these conditions on real time bases specifically with respect to the Subject alone.

 

[Muhammad Omar]

Just for an idea:

View attachment 353275

Isn't this Pakistani Territory??

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

Why escorted? have we forgotten our atlantic-1 maritime plane they shot in 99?

Bro, right now, we are no match to India. We need to arm our navy to the teeth.
SAMS, and more diesel powered submarine is inevitable for us. Also need few deep strike fighters of naval version.

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

Bro, right now, we are no match to India.

lol if the deterrence doesnt work now than it never will.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

AND INDIAN RESPONSE IS AGAIN:
"blatant lies"
AND INDIANS THINK PAKISTAN DON'T ACCEPT SOLDIERS.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/india...-its-waters/story-3Ha1qnPQC3mpXgxjE0wujL.html

 

[Falcon26]

The Sub thing is not just like Kulbhashan which was caught red handed though whatever you exemplified is never seen in Military that too between arch rivals like Pakistan-India. We know, many of times A/Cs are being radar locked to tell that "Stay Away". Rules of Engagement (RoE) must kept in view during operations and we are not some kind of back stabbers like the enemy (there is an example but no need to drag in merely not to diver the topic).

The Surrendered must not be shot at all, only cowards does that. We detected them, they acknowledged and surfaced, turned back (a white flag to say) and the message sent while on other hand PN happy with its such operation as well as the Nation that surely, security is in competent hands. I would rather say, it was more practical and better than such type of engagements during exercises to learn, which proved preparedness of PN in these conditions on real time bases specifically with respect to the Subject alone.

You are forgetting the Atlantique incident which occurred in similar circumstances and against the Pakistani Navy. Clearly exemplified by the Indians.