What's new

Ousted Prime Minister Imran Khan Arrested: News and Discussion

Is Martial Law/Emergency a real possibility after IK arrest?

  • Yes

    Votes: 145 63.6%
  • No

    Votes: 83 36.4%

  • Total voters
    228
  • Poll closed .
. . .
BTW, there's no specific mention of PAA being applied to civilians, rioters etc. from any official channel. Even the ISPR release did not mention this specifically even though the title of the thread/quoted article does:

Sir...:

The Forum expressed firm resolve that those involved in these heinous crimes against the military installations and personal/ equipment will be brought to justice through trials under relevant laws of Pakistan including Pakistan Army Act and Official Secret Act.

BTW, DJ ISPR is getting shabby. It should be personnel, not personal.

Kuch zyada hi pontra gaye hain.
 
.
Screenshot_20230517_092238_YouTube.jpg

Pertinent Q
 
.
RAWALPINDI: The military's top leadership has vowed to take strict action against protesters and their abettors under local laws — including the Pakistan Army Act and the Official Secrets Act — following Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) workers' violent protests in which military installations were attacked.

The decision came during a Special Corps Commanders Conference (CCC) held at the General Headquarters with Chief of Army Staff (COAS) General Asim Munir in the chair, according to a statement from the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR).

The violent protests were triggered after PTI Chairman Imran Khan was sent to jail in the Al-Qadir Trust case, but after walking free on bail, the party chief said his workers did not instigate violence and distanced the PTI from them.

Following the arrest of Khan, who has criticised the military since his ouster in April last year, the PTI workers raised the stakes and attacked an entrance gate of the GHQ among other installations of the armed forces.


😳
Army act doesn't apply to civilians. Read 21-D of the act. Further constitution point 10 also forbids.
 
.
So while I understand the rationale being used, had this been PTI's rule and PDM had resorted to riots, I believe IK's government would have gone after the arsonists/rioters as well.

And if the same sort of heavy handed tactics and blatant violation of the law was undertaken, I would have said that the response by PDM would have been completely justified.

Akhir kab tak aap kisi ko aaj kay daur main is tarah daba kar rakh saktay ho?

Secondly, I think we all can agree that right now, it is not the PDM government that is in charge, it is the estab. No ASI or SP has enough balls to openly defy court orders and arrest or kidnap civilians and employ such tactics.
 
.
PTI people are the awam, they are not separate entity.

Awam, the people, the Pakistani citizens are the PTI.

Why it's so difficult to understand, accept and acknowledge.

Just as Fauj, army composition are the people of Pakistan, they again shouldn't consider themselves a separate entity, another class of people.

This Army and Awam division, difference is the root cause of all.

In all developed countries, Army is part of the civilian government mandated by the people, they work with them and not against them.
 
. .
PTI people are the awam, they are not a separate entity.

Awam, the people, the Pakistani citizens are the PTI.

Why it's so difficult to understand, accept and acknowledge.

Just as Fauj, army composition are the people of Pakistan, they again shouldn't consider themselves a separate entity, another class of people.

This Army and Awam division, difference is the root cause of all.

In all developed countries, Army is part of the civilian government mandated by the people, they work with them and not against them.
 
.
Pakistani nation must learn from everything that has happened.

We need to get rid of this bloated 700000 sized standing army. Bring a mandatory national service every man of 18 serves 3 years. The permanent military should only including officers, specialist, special forces and a smaller standing force. This would cut these megalomaniacs to their true aukat. Right now they are raping the entire country because they know they have 700000 soldiers who will dance to their tunes.


ISI must goes to Civilians or the very least should be rotated between Airforce and Navy. Ground forces officers must be banned from holding any significant position within ISI. This way we will have an independent organization not subservient to the whishes of army commanders.

Remove all decronion colonial Era Laws. Like section 144, army act and official secret act.

Had their been no Officials secrets act we would have never been in this position. They hide all their ill gotton wealth and crimes behind this act.

Full constitutional protection for the right to bear arms and self defence of life property and family against unlawful invasion of privacy even by enforcement with out any legal warrant.
Totally agree. The US military is professional force + conscription recruit during large wars like WWII. There is no question of civilian supremacy as many Presidents, Senators, Congress members have served in the military. Furthermore the Chief of Army Staff has no operational control of the army and serves as an advisor. The President is the Commander in Chief.

See the US Army structure https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Organization_of_U.S._Space_Force.svg

The Israeli military has mandatory service, so the whole country has served with exception of Rabbis.

ISI needs to be removed from the military. Not only because of misuse, but also because military recruits running the agency lack the intellectual capacity to compete with western agencies which are run by the brightest minds from the best universities like MIT, Stanford, Ivy League schools. Do you think a matric pass running the agency has any business sitting across the table from a PhD from Princeton with global satellite & electronic surveillance at his disposal?
 
Last edited:
. .
Reports of AK Dhedi, army generals visiting Zaman Park for a dialogue, a deal of sorts with Imran Khan.

After putting pressure on him through the Army act on 9th May disturbance, arson, mass arrests, looking for IK to budge and accept their tor's.

This is the army SOP, first apply pressure and then look for a deal.
 
. . .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom