Open Debate | How to conduct a 'reasonable debate' between Pakistanis and Indians on PDF?

[Levina]

1. Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim
   Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim - News - Al Jazeera English Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim A former minister of the southern...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:57 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
2. 
   Thread
   Ending the beatings, rapes, murders: where are India's men?
   http://www.trust.org/item/20140211170905-lnyew/?source=hpeditorial Ending the beatings, rapes, murders: where are India's men? NEW DELHI (Thomson...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:56 PM, 9 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
3. 
   Thread
   Rape scourge a blow to India’s status
   Rape scourge a blow to India’s status | GulfNews.com Rape scourge a blow to India’s status It is counterproductive and foolish to waste millions of...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:56 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
4. 
   Thread
   Charges framed against former Rajasthan minister in rape case
   http://www.newstrackindia.com/newsdetails/2014/02/11/259--Charges-framed-against-former-Rajasthan-minister-in-rape-case-.html Charges framed against...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:54 PM, 5 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
5. 
   Thread
   India's Lost Decade
   India's Lost Decade | KERA News India's Lost Decade A recent visit left commentator Lee Cullum with strong impressions of India, and not all of them...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:54 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
6. 
   Thread
   British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India
   British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India | GlobalPost British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India...
   Thread by: favabeans, Yesterday at 2:53 PM, 32 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
7. 
   Thread
   American media is picking on India again...
   There seems to be a concerted effort underway to discredit, denigrate, and defile India's image.
   Thread by: favabeans, Yesterday at 6:42 AM, 2 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
8. https://defence.pk/styles/dpk/xenforo/avatars/avatar_s.png
   Thread
   U.S. launches new trade action against India | Reuters
   U.S. launches new trade action against India| Reuters U.S. launches new trade action against India | Reuters (Reuters) - The United States on Monday...
   Thread by: favabeans, Yesterday at 6:40 AM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
9. https://defence.pk/styles/dpk/xenforo/avatars/avatar_s.png
   Thread
   Trinamool Congress leader held for twin gang rapes
   Amta Trinamool leader held for twin gang rapes - The Times of India Amta Trinamool leader held for twin gang rapes HOWRAH: A local-level Trinamool...
   Thread by: favabeans, Monday at 4:28 PM, 2 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia

Sir, out of 20,. . .13 threads this guy opened in last 6 days are on rapes.. . .have been reporting him since a long time. . nothing happened so i finally gave up

OMG!!
That guy favabeans is doing some serious research on this topic.

 

[typoerror]

https://defence.pk/forums/general-headquarters.170/

Go here and stop derailing this thread.

I am not derailing the thread. I am trying to contribute and you are in response only ridiculing. Shows you out that you dont give a shit about the topic.

 

[Kompromat]

I am not derailing the thread. I am trying to contribute and you are in response only ridiculing. Shows you out that you dont give a shit about the topic.

Do highlight your 'constructive input', because i haven't noticed it yet.

I am taking down notes for every good point.

 

[typoerror]

The very first post of mine on the thread. Stop banning and threatening members cause they have an opinion. You do that without reason more than anyone else.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Shows you out that you dont give a shit about the topic.

The very first post of mine on the thread. Stop banning and threatening members cause they have an opinion. You do that without reason more than anyone else.

The fact that you're still here after contributing nothing but trolling, shows just how lenient the moderators really are.

As for the topic, banning of trolls is the best way to insure a forum without constant flaming. But that reduces forum traffic, so the Admins need to decide which one they want more.

 

[Spring Onion]

1. Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim
   Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim - News - Al Jazeera English Ex-minister in suicide bid over rape claim A former minister of the southern...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:57 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
2. 
   Thread
   Ending the beatings, rapes, murders: where are India's men?
   http://www.trust.org/item/20140211170905-lnyew/?source=hpeditorial Ending the beatings, rapes, murders: where are India's men? NEW DELHI (Thomson...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:56 PM, 9 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
3. 
   Thread
   Rape scourge a blow to India’s status
   Rape scourge a blow to India’s status | GulfNews.com Rape scourge a blow to India’s status It is counterproductive and foolish to waste millions of...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:56 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
4. 
   Thread
   Charges framed against former Rajasthan minister in rape case
   http://www.newstrackindia.com/newsdetails/2014/02/11/259--Charges-framed-against-former-Rajasthan-minister-in-rape-case-.html Charges framed against...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:54 PM, 5 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
5. 
   Thread
   India's Lost Decade
   India's Lost Decade | KERA News India's Lost Decade A recent visit left commentator Lee Cullum with strong impressions of India, and not all of them...
   Thread by: favabeans, Today at 3:54 PM, 0 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
6. 
   Thread
   British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India
   British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India | GlobalPost British mother of killed teenager writes anguished letter to India...
   Thread by: favabeans, Yesterday at 2:53 PM, 32 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
7. 
   Thread
   American media is picking on India again...
   There seems to be a concerted effort underway to discredit, denigrate, and defile India's image.
   Thread by: favabeans, Yesterday at 6:42 AM, 2 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia
8. https://defence.pk/styles/dpk/xenforo/avatars/avatar_s.png[/URL]
   Thread
   [SIZE=4][B][URL='https://defence.pk/threads/u-s-launches-new-trade-action-against-india-reuters.299544/']U.S. launches new trade action against India | Reuters[/URL][/B][/SIZE]
   [URL='https://defence.pk/threads/u-s-launches-new-trade-action-against-india-reuters.299544/']U.S. launches new trade action against India| Reuters U.S. launches new trade action against India | Reuters (Reuters) - The United States on Monday...[/URL]
   Thread by: [URL='https://defence.pk/members/favabeans.19635/']favabeans[/URL], Yesterday at 6:40 AM, 0 replies, in forum: [URL='https://defence.pk/forums/central-south-asia.160/']Central & South Asia[/URL]
   [*][URL='https://defence.pk/members/favabeans.19635/'][IMG]https://defence.pk/styles/dpk/xenforo/avatars/avatar_s.png
   Thread
   Trinamool Congress leader held for twin gang rapes
   Amta Trinamool leader held for twin gang rapes - The Times of India Amta Trinamool leader held for twin gang rapes HOWRAH: A local-level Trinamool...
   Thread by: favabeans, Monday at 4:28 PM, 2 replies, in forum: Central & South Asia

Sir, out of 20,. . .13 threads this guy opened in last 6 days are on rapes.. . .have been reporting him since a long time. . nothing happened so i finally gave up

Very good. This highlights the crime

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

Very good. This highlights the crime

Yeah sure. . . but rape threads on Pakistan are removed immediately. . . i've personally seen it happening over here. . . why ?

those are not considered as crimes ?

And one more thing. . . what is the purpose of highlighting these things ? what is positive side ? what discussions can be done on rape ?

we can feel sorry for the victing at the max. . . thats it.. . . or you have something more legitimate . . . . then please share it with us. didi ji.

 

[Spring Onion]

Yeah sure. . . but a rape threads on Pakistan are removed immediately. . . i've personally seen it happening over here. . . why ?

those are not considered as crimes ?

oh yeh and we are superhuman that we still manage to debate it if its removed immediately how can we do that

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

Not possible.

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

oh yeh and we are superhuman that we still manage to debate it if its removed immediately how can we do that

what debate you can do on a rape thread.. . .?? a sorry feeling ? expression of anger ? what else. . . please please. . . tell me what else can you debate on a rape thread. .

 

[Skies]

fighting is fun here..everyone is not equal, so expecting sensibility is not possible from everyone. ..ever visited India vs Pk Yahoo chat room ever? this place is n times better..people appreciate this forum for sensibility than other places......


if we wish to see more responsible debate:

1. there is a Senior Member club already........there discussion is very sensible..senors represent therir countries in senior club sensibility which you cannot expect from general members.

2. may be some more strict moderation can help.......that would be devoid of more fun and interest........



3. Open more threads in senior club, there should be another rating system based on "capacity to talk to the point to points" not based on quality of post only.

4. Delete the first unrelated off topic post which leads to more troll and offtopic in real-time with more and more moderators.

5. ask for reference for every claim. otherwise negative rating

6. or Make a "Representative Club", there general members from Pak and India would select or vote for sensible representatives {not TTs selected by admin} for their countries for sensible discussion

7. give a power to the members on immediate lower rank members in the hierarchy, so that if a senior member can rate a junior remember and encourage them.

 

[vicky sen]

oh yeh and we are superhuman that we still manage to debate it if its removed immediately how can we do that

If they cannot be banned, they should be moved to seniors cafe where trolls like @favabeans can be kept out.
In any case I doubt whether there can be any constructive discussions on rapes at all.

 

[favabeans]

really???then how members like favabeans are posting them regularly???

News update: rape topic is no longer banned.

 

[Levina]

News update: rape topic is no longer banned.

So you thought you could post a bunch of rape threads on the site???

 

[Chronos]

So you thought you could post a bunch of rape threads on the site???

Your Avatar

From Avatar

OMG!!
That guy favabeans is doing some serious research on this topic.

Well it does say something about a guy who spends his waking moments researching 'rape' and not even meaningful discussions on it either.