What's new

Modi honors fallen Indo-Pak soldiers

Solomon2

BANNED
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
19,475
Reaction score
-37
Country
United States
Location
United States
621234_thump.jpg

Specifically, the soldiers of the two divisions of the WWI British Indian Army who served and died in Palestine. These divisions included both Hindus and Muslims from areas that later became parts of Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh. Ironically, the pictured memorial is in Haifa's Christian Cemetery.

Story:

Visiting Indian PM honors fallen Indian soldiers at Haifa cemetery
"We are making history together," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says of Indian prime minister's visit, lauds "marriage ... made in heaven" between Israel and India • Israel is "a country of heroism," Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi says.

Shlomo Cesana, Yori Yalon, Danielle Roth-Avneri and News Agencies

Prime Ministers Narendra Modi and Benjamin Netanyahu on a Haifa beach, Thursday

|
Photo credit: GPO​
149933552734565429a_b.jpg

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited the Christian Cemetery in Haifa Thursday morning, laying a wreath in honor of the Indian soldiers who died fighting the 1918 battle to liberate Haifa from the Ottoman Empire in World War I.

Thursday concludes the Indian prime minister's highly successful visit to Israel, which was jam-packed with treaties, ceremonies and official meetings.

Of note, Modi and Netanyahu on Wednesday signed technology and agriculture cooperation agreements, three of which dealt with space and others with the water infrastructure in India.

"What a great day," Netanyahu said in a joint press conference Wednesday with Modi. "We are making history together. ... I have a feeling that today, India and Israel are changing our world. ... Because this is a cooperation, it's a marriage really made in heaven but we're implementing it here on earth."

Netanyahu added that the collaboration between Israeli technologies and the Indian market will not only break new ground in India but also promote India-Israel collaboration in Africa.

"India is present there," he said, "Israel is present and coming in to Africa and we think that by joining forces ... we can help the people of Africa as well." he said.

"Our partnership is real," Modi said. "India has suffered violence and threats of terrorism, like Israel. We have agreed to work together to fight terrorism and to further our strategic interests in order to combat the intensifying radicalization."

On Wednesday evening, Modi visited the Israel Museum, where a ceremony, held in his honor, celebrated the daily life of Jewish communities in India. Modi and his host Netanyahu then attended an event at the Tel Aviv Convention Center honoring the Indian-Jewish community. Thousands of Jews of Indian descent were present.

Due to organization failures and the sheer amount of people trying to enter the convention center to see Modi, several people fainted at the gate and security checks were not performed, as is customary at such events.

After a two-hour artistic program, the prime ministers arrived, went on stage and waved to the crowd.

"Namaste!" Netanyahu said. "The prime minister of India and I decided to bring the relationship between the countries to new heights," Netanyahu continued, "but there is a bridge that connects us and it is a human bridge, and so we honor you."

Modi told the crowd, "Shalom aleichem" (Peace be upon you), and continued in Hindi: "Netanyahu gave me great honor during the visit, and therefore honored millions of Indians. He gave me love of the sort no one can ever forget.

"Israel sacrificed many of its people to arrive at the place where it is, and it is a country of heroism," Modi said. "This proves that it doesn't matter the size of the country, but rather the power it has. In the field of innovation, Israel deserves a Nobel Prize. This is a country that lights up the world with its accomplishments."

The two prime ministers also found time on Wednesday to visit Moshe Holtzberg, today 11 years old, whose parents Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg were murdered in a 2008 terrorist attack at the Chabad House in Mumbai.

"Welcome to our country, prime minister of India," Moshe told Modi in Hindi, earning him a warm hug.

Continuing in English, Moshe said, "Welcome to Israel, our holy land [and] the holy city Jerusalem. My name is Moshe Holtzberg, the son of Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg. ... I [am] 11 years old, I was saved by my very special nanny Sandra [Samuel]," he said, referring to the 2008 Mumbai attack.

"I love you Modi and your people in India," Moshe said, revealing that he intends to return to Mumbai and run its Chabad center when he is older.

Netanyahu told Moshe that "Prime Minister Modi invited me to come to India. You will come with me to Mumbai."

"You are most welcome," Modi said to the boy, offering him and his family extended visas.

Moshe met the two prime ministers with his nanny, Samuel, who now lives in Israel and visits Moshe every weekend, as well as his grandparents Rabbi Shimon Rosenberg and his wife Gila, with whom he has lived since the attack. Rosenberg said that he very much appreciates the time Modi set aside for the meeting, and that "it touches us that he, as prime minister of a billion and a half people, saw fit to meet with [Moshe]."

Modi also met Wednesday with President Reuven Rivlin. This is the third meeting between the two since Rivlin began his term in office.
 
. . . . . . . .
What is this doctored title?

The Indian PM honored the fallen United Indian soldiers. No more, no less.
It's the title of my commentary, followed by an article. I am highlighting that the fallen British Indians Modi honored included both Muslims and Hindus.
 
.
Isn't it embarrassing celebrating fighting for British empire. Personally I see that as disgusting.
They were promised freedom...

And most joined for money n honor.

However most muslim regiments revolted when ordered to fight Osmanli...Many switched to Osmanli side... others turned on british.

In Singapore they mutnied and fought5 british (ordered to fight Osmanli).....they were executed.

In Iraq Pak Frontier Force and Lancers deserted to Osmanli side.

Somehowever remained loyal to british... due to "honor" ...

There were cases where one brother was fightingwith british ... the other against...

And both won valor awards.

Like :


A forgotten hero in Pakistan is Jemadar Mir Mast Afridi from the 58th Frontier Force (Vaughan’s Rifles). Mir Mast was an Afridi Pathan from tribal areas of modern Pakistan. In 1914 his unit was shipped to France as part of the Indian Infantry Corps, which played a major role in stopping the German advance in France in 1914 in Ypres Sector . Mir Mast Afridi seems to have been a far more politically aware and resolute man as compared to many Muslims educated at MAO College Lahore, Aligarh or at many prestigious British universities and Legal Inns! Mir Mast decided that he must not fight the Britisher’s war and crossed over to the German lines on a rainy night in March 1915 along with 14 other Afridi Tribal Pathan. Mir Mast was awarded one of the highest German gallantry award Iron Cross by the German Kaiser Willhelm II .



The British awarded Mir Mast’s real brother Mir Dast Afridi (from 55th FF Coke’s Rifles) a Victoria Cross in April 1915.
The Forgotten Regiments

Mir Mast was sent to Turkey by the Germans, to meet with the Mufti, and by late in the war was back in Afghanistan apparently trying to discourage his Muslim countrymen from joining up to fight for the Raj.
A matter of honour - Philip Mason - Google Books



The Turko-German missionmembers succeeded in establishing a centre for the anti-British activities in Bagh (Tirah), in the tribal belt. In June 1916 two Turkish emissaries arrived Tirah; one was Khired Bey, a staff colonel of the Turkish army and the other Mohammad Abid (alias Abidin), an Arab, a former employee of the Turks as a drill' instructor at Kabul. Mir Mast accompanied the Turko-German Mission. He was already busy in propaganda against the British in Tirah, he had already prepared ground for the mission

On their arrival in Tirah, the emissaries were welcomed by Mast. They delivered anti-British speeches and unfurled a flag, a blessed and sent by the Turkish Sultan. By the middle of 1916 a large number of the Pashtoon soldiers, mainly deserters from the British Indian army had swelled the ranks of the Turkish emissaries. They started recruitment of the locals as well.. By July 1916, the total number of the Afridi recruits was reported to have reached about four hundreds.. They were posted in three different places and and drilled every day by Mir Mast Khan under the supervision of Kharid Bay, a Turkish Colonel.
The Turks also wrote letters to the neighbouring tribes, and in the month of August some Turkish emissaries visited the Mohmand areas where Hajji Sahib was busy in waging war against the British.

As a result of the growing popularity of the Sultan's army in Tirah, Sir George Roos-Keppel, then Chief Commissioner NVVFP, found the tribes being virtually divided into two camps: anti-British and pro-British. The former consisted of deserters and discharged soldiers from the Indian army and other pro-Afghan elements, while the latter was composed mainly of Maliks and elders who were in favour of maintaining friendly relations with the British in lieu of their allowances and other emoluments from the British Indian government. Roos Keppel believed that the Turkish agents were responsible for creating the troubles in the tribal belt, but he could not ask the Government to take any stern action against them lest he feared aggravation in the already tense situation.

The tribes who were supporting the Turkish emissaries inflicted losses on those who were accused of supporting the British. In retaliation, other tribes also organised themselves under the leadership of Khan Bahadur Zaman Khan Kuki Khel and attacked and burnt the village in which the two Turkish emissaries and their Afghan followers were living in Tirah. This action of the Afridis made them unpopular among the people. The British rewarded the tribes by sanctioning a bonus of one year’s allowances.


Isn't it embarrassing celebrating fighting for British empire. Personally I see that as disgusting.
They were promised freedom...

And most joined for money n honor.

However most muslim regiments revolted when ordered to fight Osmanli...Many switched to Osmanli side... others turned on british.


mutiny.jpg

Pak muslim soldiers being executed-Singapore mutiny


In Singapore they mutnied and fought british (ordered to fight Osmanli).....they were executed.

In Iraq Pak Frontier Force and Lancers deserted to Osmanli side.

Somehowever remained loyal to british... due to "honor" ...

There were cases where one brother was fightingwith british ... the other against...

And both won valor awards.

Like :


A forgotten hero in Pakistan is Jemadar Mir Mast Afridi from the 58th Frontier Force (Vaughan’s Rifles). Mir Mast was an Afridi Pathan from tribal areas of modern Pakistan. In 1914 his unit was shipped to France as part of the Indian Infantry Corps, which played a major role in stopping the German advance in France in 1914 in Ypres Sector . Mir Mast Afridi seems to have been a far more politically aware and resolute man as compared to many Muslims educated at MAO College Lahore, Aligarh or at many prestigious British universities and Legal Inns! Mir Mast decided that he must not fight the Britisher’s war and crossed over to the German lines on a rainy night in March 1915 along with 14 other Afridi Tribal Pathan. Mir Mast was awarded one of the highest German gallantry award Iron Cross by the German Kaiser Willhelm II .



The British awarded Mir Mast’s real brother Mir Dast Afridi (from 55th FF Coke’s Rifles) a Victoria Cross in April 1915.
The Forgotten Regiments

Mir Mast was sent to Turkey by the Germans, to meet with the Mufti, and by late in the war was back in Afghanistan apparently trying to discourage his Muslim countrymen from joining up to fight for the Raj.
A matter of honour - Philip Mason - Google Books



The Turko-German missionmembers succeeded in establishing a centre for the anti-British activities in Bagh (Tirah), in the tribal belt. In June 1916 two Turkish emissaries arrived Tirah; one was Khired Bey, a staff colonel of the Turkish army and the other Mohammad Abid (alias Abidin), an Arab, a former employee of the Turks as a drill' instructor at Kabul. Mir Mast accompanied the Turko-German Mission. He was already busy in propaganda against the British in Tirah, he had already prepared ground for the mission

On their arrival in Tirah, the emissaries were welcomed by Mast. They delivered anti-British speeches and unfurled a flag, a blessed and sent by the Turkish Sultan. By the middle of 1916 a large number of the Pashtoon soldiers, mainly deserters from the British Indian army had swelled the ranks of the Turkish emissaries. They started recruitment of the locals as well.. By July 1916, the total number of the Afridi recruits was reported to have reached about four hundreds.. They were posted in three different places and and drilled every day by Mir Mast Khan under the supervision of Kharid Bay, a Turkish Colonel.
The Turks also wrote letters to the neighbouring tribes, and in the month of August some Turkish emissaries visited the Mohmand areas where Hajji Sahib was busy in waging war against the British.

As a result of the growing popularity of the Sultan's army in Tirah, Sir George Roos-Keppel, then Chief Commissioner NVVFP, found the tribes being virtually divided into two camps: anti-British and pro-British. The former consisted of deserters and discharged soldiers from the Indian army and other pro-Afghan elements, while the latter was composed mainly of Maliks and elders who were in favour of maintaining friendly relations with the British in lieu of their allowances and other emoluments from the British Indian government. Roos Keppel believed that the Turkish agents were responsible for creating the troubles in the tribal belt, but he could not ask the Government to take any stern action against them lest he feared aggravation in the already tense situation.

The tribes who were supporting the Turkish emissaries inflicted losses on those who were accused of supporting the British. In retaliation, other tribes also organised themselves under the leadership of Khan Bahadur Zaman Khan Kuki Khel and attacked and burnt the village in which the two Turkish emissaries and their Afghan followers were living in Tirah. This action of the Afridis made them unpopular among the people. The British rewarded the tribes by sanctioning a bonus of one year’s allowances.

p0278dk7.jpg



Mir Mast and other Pak soldiers in Osmali army ...


9289950181_3aefc1849e_b.jpg

Mir Dast who fought for brits
 
. .
3 Regiments were to be sent by British- Jodhpur,Madras and Hyderabad,but they decided not to send Hyderabad as they though Muslims would join Germany+Ottomans and rebel against British.
 
.
Isn't it embarrassing celebrating fighting for British empire. Personally I see that as disgusting.
Its embarrassing and disgusting. However what is satisfying is that many revolted against the brits since many considered it sin to fight against the caliph.
 
. .
Hypocrisy on full display here. Certainly imperialism is to be rejected. But a turk and pakistanis calling serving imperialist forces in a professional capacity disgusting is hilarious.

These same people can not stop gushing about some or all of the following

Turkish imperialism
Arabic imperialism
Persian imperialism
Afghan imperialism etc etc

For them only British imperialism is bad (because they defeated their favorite imperialists lol)
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom