What's new

Lahoris ARTISTS FORCE TO DEFACE COUPLET PRAISING DELHI IN URDU BY A CROWD shouting Jai Shri Ram

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,316
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
Swachh devotees in Urdu cleansing
- Artists forced to deface couplet praising Delhi
Pheroze L. Vincent
New Delhi, May 23:A French artist and an Indian associate commissioned by the Delhi government were forced by a crowd to deface their own wall-writing in praise of the capital in Urdu and replace it with the words "Swachh Bharat Abhiyan", one of the artists said.

The crowd was shouting slogans like "Jai Shri Ram" and calling the artists "Lahoris", artist Akhlaq Ahmad said. Urdu is one of the four official languages of Delhi while the other three are Hindi, Punjabi and English.

Last Thursday, the French artist and the Delhi-based Ahmad were painting an Urdu couplet on the wall of a Delhi Jal Board pumping station in northeast Delhi.

Their work is part of the #MyDilliStory project commissioned by the state government's art, culture and languages department. Artists collective Delhi I Love You (DILY), which is steering the project, has selected 40 couplets in the four languages to be painted on walls.

24artists1.jpg

The Delhi wall with the Urdu letters painted over and replaced with the words “Swachh Bharat Abhiyan” in Hindi

Written by Delhi University student Zeeshan Amjad, the couplet chosen for the Jal Board wall refers to the city being destroyed and rebuilt seven times. It says: "Dilli tera ujarna, aur phir ujar ke basna. Woh dil hai toone paya, sani nahi hai jiska(Oh Delhi, you were ruined and you overcame your ruin to settle. No city has a heart like yours)."

Ahmad, better known as Shabbu, toldThe Telegraphtoday: "As we painted the first line, a crowd gathered. People asked why we were painting in Urdu. We explained that this is poetry praising Delhi, it's a government project. We showed them the permission letter on our phones. The crowd soon increased to about 150. A dark and hefty man with a slight moustache stepped forward and said he is from the RSS and Urdu would not be tolerated."

"He had a few supporters who yelled abuses about our mothers and sisters and started shouting 'Jai Shri Ram'. I said my name is Shabbu and they assumed I was Shambhu, a Hindu. So they turned their ire towards my French colleague, Swen Simon, asking him to pay me my wages and go back to Lahore. Swen doesn't know Hindi. I pleaded with them to leave him alone, saying he's French not Pakistani," Ahmad added.

Some people picked up the brush and started painting over the Urdu letters, said Ahmad. "They yelled at me, saying paint in 'yellow, orange, blue'. They held my hands and tried to force me to paint. I agreed to paint whatever they wanted to save ourselves. They said paint 'Swachh Bharat Abhiyan' (the Clean India campaign promoted by the Narendra Modi government) and 'Narendra Modi' in Hindi, which I started doing. By the time I painted the first line, police arrived," said Ahmad.

Ahmad, who has a master's in fine arts from Jamia Millia Islamia, added that the artists had tried to photograph the mob but the self-proclaimed RSS men took their phones and deleted the images. These men melted into the crowd as soon as they heard the police siren.

"The police were quite rude and took away my phone. They kept questioning our motives after I told them I live in Batla House (where two alleged terrorists and a police officer were killed in 2008). Thankfully, (Delhi) culture minister Kapil Mishra called the police up when we were in the van, after which the cops were apologetic and offered us soft drinks and food," Ahmad said.

DILY has decided not to work at the site. "We didn't expect this as it has never happened before," said Kush Sethi of DILY.

Minister Mishra said he would not allow intimidation. "These RSS men neither understand culture nor religion, especially Hinduism. Otherwise, they wouldn't have done this to our foreign guest who is doing a service to the city. The option of taking legal action is open to us but we first want to create social awareness and expose their plans to create communal tension," Mishra said.

In response to a question, A.K. Singla, deputy commissioner of police (Northeast Delhi), said: "I do not know about this incident. I will have to check."


http://www.telegraphindia.com/1160524/jsp/frontpage/story_87317.jsp#.V0RSi_l96t_
 
Seems more like a hot job!! This news paper is known for reporting planted stories against BJP.
 
Minister Mishra said he would not allow intimidation. "These RSS men neither understand culture nor religion, especially Hinduism.
Minister Mishra has termed the Delhi's citizens as RSS men :o:

Thank God Modi was in Iran otherwise Mishra Ji would have implicated him as the one instigating the crowd :D


I think Delhi voters made the mistake of feeding 'Ghee' to Dogs, by giving 67 assembly seats to AAP Party :(
 
Seems more like a hot job!! This news paper is known for reporting planted stories against BJP.

How stupid. Nobody needs to plant stories against any part of the Sangh Parivar. Their own antics are good enough.

Minister Mishra has termed the Delhi's citizens as RSS men :o:

Thank God Modi was in Iran otherwise Mishra Ji would have implicated him as the one instigating the crowd :D


I think Delhi voters made the mistake of feeding 'Ghee' to Dogs, by giving 67 assembly seats to AAP Party :(

Not Delhi's citizens; just a few scumbags among them. Nice to know you are on their side.
 
Not Delhi's citizens; just a few scumbags among them. Nice to know you are on their side.
Well those who did that were indeed scumbags. If they also happen to belong to a particular community or organisation then why blame the community or organisation as a whole.

In this particular case blaming the most patriotic national organisation without any proof speaks itself about the trustworthiness of AAP and its supporters
 
Well those who did that were indeed scumbags. If they also happen to belong to a particular community or organisation then why blame the community or organisation as a whole.

In this particular case blaming the most patriotic national organisation without any proof speaks itself about the trustworthiness of AAP and its supporters

Nowhere has anyone blamed the community. But the organisation has to take the blame, unless they also take steps to control the behaviour of those who claim their membership.

And who told you that the RSS is the most patriotic national organisation? In what way have they been patriotic? By sitting out the entire freedom struggle? Or by massacring Muslims in Jammu and the Punjab and in UP during partition?
 
Can someone who knows tell me how many Muslim league leaders went to prison fighting for Independence from the British?

Surely there would have been many.

Just curious.

None.
They're all traitors.
Should have fought with the Nazis like great Netaji.
 
Nowhere has anyone blamed the community. But the organisation has to take the blame, unless they also take steps to control the behaviour of those who claim their membership.

And who told you that the RSS is the most patriotic national organisation? In what way have they been patriotic? By sitting out the entire freedom struggle? Or by massacring Muslims in Jammu and the Punjab and in UP during partition?
Therefore its okay for a community not to take steps to control the behaviour of its misguided members, but you got a different set of rules when it comes to RSS. Great !!!!

And who told you that we got Independence through freedom struggle. It was Subash Chander Bose's plans to massacre Englishmen which made them leave India and hand over power to their stooges. Don't insult your intelligence by claiming that English were threatened by the types of Gandhi and Nehru. Learn History not reading but by analysing the facts.
 
Therefore its okay for a community not to take steps to control the behaviour of its misguided members, but you got a different set of rules when it comes to RSS. Great !!!!

And who told you that we got Independence through freedom struggle. It was Subash Chander Bose's plans to massacre Englishmen which made them leave India and hand over power to their stooges. Don't insult your intelligence by claiming that English were threatened by the types of Gandhi and Nehru. Learn History not reading but by analysing the facts.

A community is not organised; an organisation is - what? So you should learn to argue not by letting your prejudices loose on the rest of us unsuspecting victims, but by analysing the facts.

Subhash Bose and his plans were very grand, but they did not survive. Only children and the feeble-minded fear ghosts, so don't insult your intelligence by imagining that it was the sole influence. I have actually learnt history; have you?
 
Therefore its okay for a community not to take steps to control the behaviour of its misguided members, but you got a different set of rules when it comes to RSS. Great !!!!

And who told you that we got Independence through freedom struggle. It was Subash Chander Bose's plans to massacre Englishmen which made them leave India and hand over power to their stooges. Don't insult your intelligence by claiming that English were threatened by the types of Gandhi and Nehru. Learn History not reading but by analysing the facts.
The reason why the British left India was simply because their entire military power as well as economy was destroyed after World War II. It was unfeasible to maintain a large faraway colony such as India after the war.
London after WWII
View_from_St_Paul's_Cathedral_after_the_Blitz.jpg
 
Can someone who knows tell me how many Muslim league leaders went to prison fighting for Independence from the British?

Surely there would have been many.

Just curious.

Edit: this is not meant to be offensive to anyone. I really would like to know. If anyone finds it rude , please let me know I am happy to delete.

The Muslim League felt threatened by the prospect of the precipitate departure of the British, leaving them to the mercy of a majority. Please remember that by this time the people of Indian had been practising democracy for more than twenty years. The Muslim leadership knew that they would lose the leadership of the Muslim community to mainstream politicians, whether meritorious or not, and did not want to see that happen. They opposed the British, but more than that, they refused to back what was seen as an exclusively Congress movement.

Your short answer (after the Moplah Rebellion) - none.
 
The Muslim League felt threatened by the prospect of the precipitate departure of the British, leaving them to the mercy of a majority. Please remember that by this time the people of Indian had been practising democracy for more than twenty years. The Muslim leadership knew that they would lose the leadership of the Muslim community to mainstream politicians, whether meritorious or not, and did not want to see that happen. They opposed the British, but more than that, they refused to back what was seen as an exclusively Congress movement.

Your short answer (after the Moplah Rebellion) - none.
Thanks Joe. I will read up on this more as I have been curious on this for a while.

Meanwhile to anyone who felt insulted. It was inadvertent. I will do my own research in future

I wish such sensitive matters could be discussed better on PDF. Sadly it is not to be.
 
A community is not organised; an organisation is - what? So you should learn to argue not by letting your prejudices loose on the rest of us unsuspecting victims, but by analysing the facts.

Subhash Bose and his plans were very grand, but they did not survive. Only children and the feeble-minded fear ghosts, so don't insult your intelligence by imagining that it was the sole influence. I have actually learnt history; have you?
When you are voicing your opinion then aren't your opinions are coloured with your prejudices. for that matter do you know anybody anywhere who is not prejudiced OR anyone who knows that he is wrong. A mind so filled with pre conceived notions and huge acquired knowledge generally doesn't has any space left for simple logic,
Thanks and regards
 
The reason why the British left India was simply because their entire military power as well as economy was destroyed after World War II. It was unfeasible to maintain a large faraway colony such as India after the war.
London after WWII
View_from_St_Paul's_Cathedral_after_the_Blitz.jpg


One of the reasons, not the only one. It was a complex, compound situation; I am amazed at the decision once again
When you are voicing your opinion then aren't your opinions are coloured with your prejudices. for that matter do you know anybody anywhere who is not prejudiced OR anyone who knows that he is wrong. A mind so filled with pre conceived notions and huge acquired knowledge generally doesn't has any space left for simple logic,
Thanks and regards

My opinions when voiced are open to examination by the public. Doesn't that put the onus on the listener to discriminate between prejudice and reality? Your formula is merely a facade for protecting the most blatant and most untrue statements with the excuse that your prejudice is as entitled as the prejudice of someone else. It is merely a crutch.
 
Another reason why we are living in our own state
 
Back
Top Bottom