Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

[Spring Onion]

You are naming radical Hindu's just because they want to sing " Vandematharam" ?????? You know what???? this institution is owned by a muslims, and most of the education institutions run In Kerala are run by either a muslim based or a christian based....

But you are missing a point here, No one is forcing anyone to sing.... and no one can force one, not to sing too......

In simple words....... I respect your view, you respect mine.....

Note : Check few threads based on Kerala, you will know how radicals Hindu's are in Kerala.

Sometimes back . School children from the 'Jehovahs Witnesses faith' were expelled for refusing to sing.
Anyway my question remains why Hindu Indians even people like you insist on singing it in schools when you know very well that other non-Hindu groups other than Muslims also object to it?


Seems the followers of Godse still want to keep the reason alive for which they killed Gandhi.

WHY NOT only Indian National Anthem

 

[Echo_419]

yeah,they need to be put in place..
but the mainstream parties of Kerala(both ruling and opposing) are not taking it seriously yet...fearing backlash and also their vast political/economical influence...

This will surely pave the way for BJP in the state

 

[pursuit of happiness]

In an incident that reeks of growing Taliban-like radicalism, a school in Kerala had to edit out the Vande Mataram song from its Independence Day programme on Friday, following threats from a political party that it is against the religious beliefs of a community.

The school management also reportedly asked students to not do the 'namaste', a common gesture of respect in India, in fear of threats from the Social Democratic Party of India (SDPI).

According to Hindustan Times, the TKM Centenary School in Kollam was to have a dance planned on Vande Mataram, which is a popular song played as a patriotic symbol on days such as the Independence Day. However, the school management allegedly replaced the song with an orchestra to avert any incident, though the principal claims that the song was removed so as not to "stress" the students.

However, the SDPI claimed that they had asked the school to not play the song.

"We approached the school management after a number of parents complained that some words in Vande Matraam and the gesture 'namaste' were against their religious belief. We only requested the school to respect their sentiment," SDPI leader AK Salahuddin told HT.

SDPI was formed in 2009 as a political wing of the Popular Front of India, and has had a controversial run in Kerala, with the state police often raiding their offices on suspicion of arms and weapons stockpiling by the members. PFI and SDPI were also chargesheeted by the National Investigation Agency, indicating their role in conducting arms training camps, according to an India Todayreport.



There was controversy over Vande Mataram in 2009 as well, when Muslim outfit Jamait-e-Ulema Hind had issued a fatwa against the song and had banned Muslims from singing it, citing that some of the verses go against the tenets of Islam, as reported by The Times of India.

Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

Secularism at work

--
let me send to GOI..
let them

 

[utraash]

sane people? what sane people nair?

Why Hindu radicals wants to force Muslim students to sing Hindu religious belief in form of vande mataram?

now donttell me its not because we had been discussions for ages on this and you Indians failed to prove besides India had been seeing ruckus over this even before partition so its not a new issue.

The fact is Hindu radicals are not ready to drop it and want Muslims to chant it

Again on wrong side .... We have been singing the same before 1947 .....

 

[Spring Onion]

Again on wrong side .... We have been singing the same before 1947 .....

You had been having same objection to this forced singing of hindu song even before 1947.

and oh btw you are on wrong side i saw you crying rivers on Pakistani text books thread and here you are showing your double face.

 

[Nova2]

Taking steps against the leader wont be a nice idea, and that will give fuel to these radicals, and might create a communal issue..... But there are other ways to deal with it

Other ways like?.......we can take action if they are found to be involved in the wrong doings which can be done legally...stock pilling arms ,training ppl are serious crimes indeed...if they are sentenced for such crimes then the larger section of the society would not mind ,though their supports or partymen would jump onto the streets. I know taking action against'em in the short run 'may' cause communal voilence but i m sure it would help in the long run.

 

[utraash]

Sometimes back . School children from the 'Jehovahs Witnesses faith' were expelled for refusing to sing.
Anyway my question remains why Hindu Indians even people like you insist on singing it in schools when you know very well that other non-Hindu groups other than Muslims also object to it?


Seems the followers of Godse still want to keep the reason alive for which they killed Gandhi.

WHY NOT only Indian National Anthem

Why you want exception just for Muslims...... None other than Muslim oppose to sing because of their religious beliefs ..... They have been demanding such exception all over the world without introspecting n reforms their own beliefs..... Though i don't believe in imposition.....

 

[Spring Onion]

Why you want exception just for Muslims...... None other than Muslim oppose to sing because of their religious beliefs ..... They have been demanding such exception all over the world without introspecting n reforms their own beliefs..... Though i don't believe in imposition.....

You are ignorant. You need to read other groups also objected to this controversial hindu religious song .

And why you want an exception for Hidnus here? Jana Gana Mana' is your national song/anthem so why impose vande mataram just for the sake of Hindus?

 

[Indrani]

You are ignorant. You need to read other groups also objected to this controversial hindu religious song .

And why you want an exception for Hidnus here? Jana Gana Mana' is your national song/anthem so why impose vande mataram just for the sake of Hindus?

Hey, our country our rules. Those who do not like it can move.

 

[Iggy]

sane people? what sane people nair?

Why Hindu radicals wants to force Muslim students to sing Hindu religious belief in form of vande mataram?

now donttell me its not because we had been discussions for ages on this and you Indians failed to prove besides India had been seeing ruckus over this even before partition so its not a new issue.

The fact is Hindu radicals are not ready to drop it and want Muslims to chant it

Hindu radicals?? The school is run by Muslim management... Thangal Kunju Musaliar is a prominant muslim person here in Kollam and he had started many schools and colleges here.. Dont talk something which you have no idea of.. Before knowing anything you started your usual rant about Hindu radicals...

 

[amygdaloideum]

kerala and its issues *sigh*

 

[Spring Onion]

Hindu radicals?? The school is run by Muslim management... Thangal Kunju Musaliar is a prominant muslim person here in Kollam and he had started many schools and colleges here.. Dont talk something which you have no idea of.. Before knowing anything you started your usual rant about Hindu radicals...

what you think they would have angered the Hindu radicals and ruin their business? just look at the response from your Hindu countrymen just because one school stopped its singing.

Anyway coming to the core issue which is vande mataram, why should it be sung for the same of Hindus? when you have Jana Gana Mana'?

 

[nair]

Hindu radicals?? The school is run by Muslim management... Thangal Kunju Musaliar is a prominant muslim person here in Kollam and he had started many schools and colleges here.. Dont talk something which you have no idea of.. Before knowing anything you started your usual rant about Hindu radicals...

Some time people think that India is all about Hindu's.... and Everything done is by Hindu Radicals......

 

[Spring Onion]

Hey, our country our rules. Those who do not like it can move.

)))))))))))))))))))))))))) you mean Indian Muslims should move out?

Some time people think that India is all about Hindu's.... and Everything done is by Hindu Radicals......

If NOT Then why vande mataram a controversial Hindu song which had been an issue even before partition?

why dont you accept that you are also biased

 

[utraash]

You had been having same objection to this forced singing of hindu song even before 1947.

and oh btw you are on wrong side i saw you crying rivers on Pakistani text books thread and here you are showing your double face.

None forced to sing that ....
Why should i need to cry for pakistani text book material i merely mentioned i m not surprised how n why radicalism spreaded into pakistani society at large .......