Is Punjabi a mere dialect of Hindi?

[Shamain]

Punjabi is unique, only surviving tonal language among indo-europeans. Punjabi is mother of indo-aryan languages in subcontinent.

Urdu isnt indo european as well?

 

[scionoftheindus]

Punjabi is unique, only surviving tonal language among indo-europeans. Punjabi is mother of indo-aryan languages in subcontinent.

Man don't make foolish claims...if so provide some proofs...if you talk like this without proofs soon you will not be taken seriously.our words should have some value

 

[Shamain]

Hahaha..it sounded troll but a person who is interested in linguistics could learn something from that..sad that mods deleted it..I gave phonological reasons behind you people to have difficulty in pronouncing some words.

Ur post further proves u are a sick troll and must be infracted etc for trolling on the forum and shamelessly bragging abt it

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Hahaha..it sounded troll but a person who is interested in linguistics could learn something from that..sad that mods deleted it..I gave phonological reasons behind you people to have difficulty in pronouncing some words.

Ever heard a Indian say "Zindagi"? or Shalwar? They sound to me "Jindagee" and either "Jalwar" or Salwar" and was your dad Pakistani? I ask because your handle is alluding to you being "son of the Indus"?

 

[Kabira]

Man don't make foolish claims...if so provide some proofs...if you talk like this without proofs soon you will not be taken seriously.our words should have some value

Not claims but hard facts, indo-aryan languages spread from Punjab. Do you deny this mallu bhai? And punjabi is only surviving tonal language among indo-europeans.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Hahahhaha ya true abt accents true, well yet he was making fun of us.

And avatar lolzzzz, oh magar abhi tau change kiya tha......iwant 2 keep it for sometime.

Shamain, Shamain your going to expose my weakness. You should by now know my Urdu is well "derelict" to put it mildly so your making me feel ignorent .....

@save_ghenda Everything, civilization, language, even Rig Vedic religion spread from our Indus land ( Pakistan ) east into their Ganges land ( India ).

Yet they talk as if they gave us everything ......

 

[scionoftheindus]

Not claims but hard facts, indo-aryan languages spread from Punjab. Do you deny this mallu bhai? And punjabi is only surviving tonal language among indo-europeans.

Info Aryan languages spread from iran-afganistan to Punjab and from there to India..but the language was Sanskrit not punjabi

 

[scionoftheindus]

Ever heard a Indian say "Zindagi"? or Shalwar? They sound to me "Jindagee" and either "Jalwar" or Salwar" and was your dad Pakistani? I ask because your handle is alluding to you being "son of the Indus"?

My great grand dad of some 120 generations ago was from present day Pakistan(assuming each generation is 30 years)..actually I should have called it Sindhu saraswati civilisation but the Id becomes too long so I chose this smaller one

 

[Kabira]

Info Aryan languages spread from iran-afganistan to Punjab and from there to India..but the language was Sanskrit not punjabi

Indo-aryan is not spoken in Afghanistan, they speak languages belonging to indo-iranian family but not indo-aryan. Sanskrit was never spoken anywhere unlike ancient punjabi like language for common people.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

My great grand dad of some 120 generations ago was from present day Pakistan(assuming each generation is 30 years)..actually I should have called it Sindhu saraswati civilisation but the Id becomes too long so I chose this smaller one

What? 120 generations? 3,600 years ago? So your family have kept a record for 120 generations? Wow. You been smoking some potent stuff .......
Loopy loop.

 

[Kabira]

My great grand dad of some 120 generations ago was from present day Pakistan(assuming each generation is 30 years)..actually I should have called it Sindhu saraswati civilisation but the Id becomes too long so I chose this smaller one

Lol no, don't make up bs along the way. Your grandfather landed in south india along coastal way, and your kin migrated to australia also. IVC people were not pushed back by aryans, we have proof that they were absorbed by indo-aryans.

 

[Shamain]

Shamain, Shamain your going to expose my weakness. You should by now know my Urdu is well "derelict" to put it mildly so your making me feel ignorent .....

@save_ghenda Everything, civilization, language, even Rig Vedic religion spread from our Indus land ( Pakistan ) east into their Ganges land ( India ).

Yet they talk as if they gave us everything ......

LOLZZZ. You dont know urduuu. Omgg!!!!!!! Ihad thought u can speak and understand quite good urdu. Oh my bad!!!

Ok i was saying that my avatar , i had recently changed it and i want to keep it for sometime ,i hope u wont mind

 

[scionoftheindus]

Indo-aryan is not spoken in Afghanistan, they speak languages belonging to indo-iranian family but not indo-aryan. Sanskrit was never spoken anywhere unlike ancient punjabi like language for common people.

Sorry I should have said indo European..old Sanskrit is closer to old Persian..in that sense old Sanskrit is also indo Iranian..sorry to say the present day Punjabi has same status as rajastani,lambadi,marvadi or kachh languages of India(cheap versions of a standard language)..don't you people call putra as puttar?isn't that paindu?(Pakistani term)...I am sure you have twisted many such Sanskrit words..

 

[scionoftheindus]

What? 120 generations? 3,600 years ago? So your family have kept a record for 120 generations? Wow. You been smoking some potent stuff .......
Loopy loop.

Your dalit Christians are the remnants of our ancestors.

 

[scionoftheindus]

Lol no, don't make up bs along the way. Your grandfather landed in south india along coastal way, and your kin migrated to australia also. IVC people were not pushed back by aryans, we have proof that they were absorbed by indo-aryans.

Who are those dark Christians in pak?