India will never attack Pak from Afghanistan'

[$@rJen]

Think through this logically. We in Pakistan know that India will not attack Pakistan from Afghanistan simply because militarily, a ground based invasion is not very feasible. The terrain between Pakistan and Afghanistan is not ideal tank country and this is the very reason why we, the Pakistani detractors of the so-called policy of Strategic depth as understood in the West and India, deny that Pakistan has any intentions to keep influence over Afghanistan just so we can park our tanks and aircraft there just to fight the Indians another day. Hopefully people understand this better now with the Indian example being thrown around to suggest the unlikeliness of such a war.

Secondly, Pakistan's has certain concerns about the support that TTP gets from Afghanistan. Perhaps India is involved, perhaps not, but we know that the capability is there to provide such support and keep Pakistan off balance even if the Indians tell us that such is not their intention, however this goes back to the security posture of any country which is based upon the premise that the threat perception is based on the capability and not the intention. The intention can change any moment and the capability already exists. Bottom line being that Pakistan does worry about the encirclement for the same reasons that India does not like Pakistan cozying up to the BDs and SLs or Burmese for that matter. You suddenly have to take into account all these possible capabilities and fronts into your security calculus.

In the medium term, Pakistan certainly has to work through this issue, but the concerns are not unfounded.


This is certainly a fairytale.

Fairytale? Oh dear i think first you need to learn the history.... Why do you think Gen.Musharraf so sure of attacking India, because he knew the possessing nukes won't allow india to advance into Pakistan territories,, why do you think Nawaz Sharif flew to US? he went there to get a US favor for Pakistan against India, then Clinton said to remove your forces from Indian land or be ready to face the full scale war, then Nawaz Sharif agreed to immediate withdrawal, shedding all earlier pretensions that Pakistan had no control over the attacks. during the Kargil war Pakistan tried to mobilizable Nuke-tipped missiles then India made the decision named "Readiness State 3”—meaning that some nuclear bombs would be ready to be mated with their delivery vehicles at short notice..India ‘activated all its three types of nuclear delivery vehicles..8 were aimed at Islamabad...then Pakistan backed downnnnnnnnn....

Ur ignorance is striking, well u dnt seem good to be brewing ur raging warlord towards ISI, World's No:1 ranked spy agency
wud obviously be aware of India's role in Afghan at play.

I cant predict the result of this tom n jerry u r playing right there, but can certainly see RAW being ninja-wanged at durand line
soon..!! waiting anxiously to see that moment.....

World no 1.. ranked by who? your husband China?...they can't even predict when and where the terrorists are going to strike your own country....Ha ha aha... No 1....you guys are pathetic....Joke of the Day..oh wait let me copy that to my mobile i want to forward to my friends and make them laugh....

 

[Kompromat]

Its impossible sir,we need minerals in A-stan and any anti pak activity by india will depend on your activites on kashmir.

How do you plan to exit those minerals, fly them ? , Iranians won't be too happy doing anything With Afghanistan and even Charbahr port is under our Naval control, we can blockade it in our territory if it ever comes to that - Indian existence in Afghanistan depends on two factors.
1: Is Pakistan ready to throw a bone at the US to turn them around
2: How long we think, we can tolerate India there.

 

[Desert Fox]

That's because indian can't attack Pakistan from Afghanistan.

 

[IndoUS]

How do you plan to exit those minerals, fly them ? - Indian existence in Afghanistan depends on two factors.
1: Is Pakistan ready to throw a bone at the US to turn them around
2: How long we think, we can tolerate India there.

Not really India financed the building of port in Iran for the exact reason. And are building roads and railway in Afghanistan to connect the mines to Iran from where they would be shipped to India.

 

[Desert Fox]

India have been here from more than thousand of years... and many came n many gone..

so u r here to go and we are here to stay..history have been proving itself from one day..

But there is a difference, those people who invaded india in the past didn't have the capability to turn it into a wasteland of deformed inhabitants. Hopefully it never comes down to that and india stays behind its limits.

 

[IndoUS]

But there is a difference, those people who invaded india in the past didn't have the capability to turn it into a wasteland of deformed inhabitants. Hopefully it never comes down to that and india stays behind its limits.

Then I guess you are happy with mutual destruction.

 

[Desert Fox]

First of all, lets keep in mind that once US leaves/decreases its troop presence in Afghanistan it will become difficult for india too to maintain a presence in Afghanistan unless it contributes ground troops to fill in the void of the withdrawing American troops thus taking up the financial and security responsibilities of Afghanistan that the US once held. This will cost india billions every month, straining its resources and burdening its economy, india would be forced to take away from its taxpayers money to build schools, bridges, hospitals, and roads in Afghanistan not to mention maintain the security of this infrastructure and prevent it from falling into the hands of/being destroyed by the Taliban.

Lets hope india actually falls for the trap that countless powers in the past have fallen in to.

 

[VCheng]

How do you plan to exit those minerals, fly them ? , Iranians won't be too happy doing anything With Afghanistan and even Charbahr port is under our Naval control, we can blockade it in our territory if it ever comes to that - Indian existence in Afghanistan depends on two factors.
1: Is Pakistan ready to throw a bone at the US to turn them around
2: How long we think, we can tolerate India there.

The operation of bulk transport of minerals from Chahbahar would be difficult to interrupt in the peacetime, when the majority of economic benefits would accrue. A blockade in case of hostilities would, by definition, be short-lived.

Further, turning around US policy will not be as easy as Pakistan "throwing them a bone". Tolerating India in Afghanistan would be likely for the long term, please rest assured.

 

[tarrar]

All I will say is horse crap. India is already attacking Pakistan by arming terrorists with the help of their new pimp lord US. They are arming BLA, TTP & other small terrorists group in Pakistan who are all made US & India.

Everybody in Pakistan know what India is trying to do with Pakistan, so you all can STFU & you jabronis stop spreading false news.

 

[newdelhinsa]

India will never attack Pakistan from India either.

Conditions applied*

 

[Pride]

What kind of BS analysis is there? India may have few Agents there in AF and even small troops but for attacking any sovereign nation, one need proper militia, supply and strategy. Most important thing is defense ties with AF which does not exist as of now.

 

[Major Sam]

Prove as all indians explaining and asking about Indian involvement in afghanistan. just see how many comments by indians here?

 

[nair]

Ur ignorance is striking, well u dnt seem good to be brewing ur raging warlord towards ISI, World's No:1 ranked spy agency
wud obviously be aware of India's role in Afghan at play.

I cant predict the result of this tom n jerry u r playing right there, but can certainly see RAW being ninja-wanged at durand line
soon..!! waiting anxiously to see that moment.....

Well I guess you are absolutely right on this assessment ( Now our parameters on deciding the best agency may differ)... I cant agree with you more..... Infact i can add one more point to it.. The state of your country has to be the proof of your assessment

@topic : India will not attack from anywhere unless provoked.....

 

[A.Rafay]

india Cant Attack Pakistan From Afghanistan, What do you think Pakistan Is a Piece of Cake That it will Attack LOL And the afghanis are really the Servants of india? LOL Rubbish Thread

 

[Paan Singh]

How do you plan to exit those minerals, fly them ? , Iranians won't be too happy doing anything With Afghanistan and even Charbahr port is under our Naval control, we can blockade it in our territory if it ever comes to that - Indian existence in Afghanistan depends on two factors.
1: Is Pakistan ready to throw a bone at the US to turn them around
2: How long we think, we can tolerate India there.

So you think you will close iran's business and bucks and they will keep listening pakistan .India is preparing huge navy for some purpose.Iran dont want to loose market who purchases 12% of its oil and helping them under sanctions.Iran is anti taliban n pro Northern alliance.This will all happen with U.S agreed.so paksitan is no where.This is done to bypass pakistan otherwise we could ask pakistan but we dint.

But there is a difference, those people who invaded india in the past didn't have the capability to turn it into a wasteland of deformed inhabitants. Hopefully it never comes down to that and india stays behind its limits.

You can push india behind few years by nuking but you wont see paksitan on earth.This is reality.I was talking about history to show that we are here to exist in any condition.

First of all, lets keep in mind that once US leaves/decreases its troop presence in Afghanistan it will become difficult for india too to maintain a presence in Afghanistan unless it contributes ground troops to fill in the void of the withdrawing American troops thus taking up the financial and security responsibilities of Afghanistan that the US once held. This will cost india billions every month, straining its resources and burdening its economy, india would be forced to take away from its taxpayers money to build schools, bridges, hospitals, and roads in Afghanistan not to mention maintain the security of this infrastructure and prevent it from falling into the hands of/being destroyed by the Taliban.

Lets hope india actually falls for the trap that countless powers in the past have fallen in to.

No sir,U.S is preparing that Afghan army for some purpose.Its known that they are rag tag army and even killing U.S troops but after 2014,ground troops will be reduced and drone campaign will start and even if some attack to be done on pakistan borders,more soldiers will be of afganistan under U.S generals.

+ Many nato countries are not going to leave...you will see that even. .U.S can