India rejects Pakistan's help in SAARC satellite project

[Mr.Nair]

If it is a SAARC project, India should have made it a collective effort. There is no need to deny support from other members. This defeat the whole purpose of it being SAARC project. Gift in this context seem a bit condescending. Though this is my personal feeling.

'This is like a 2nd standard student telling the teacher that i will teach 8th standard class' ! So if they don't know to develop a satellite neither fund, how they are going to help us ! Period

 

[ito]

"(Pakistan) said their internal consultation process was still on,”

Where is the rejection? Was there a time frame on finishing consultations?

When all members have come to a conclusion and one member is still in 'internal consultation process' is polite way of saying 'i don't agree with all you guys'

 

[Hellfire]

I bet 20 transponders on this new sat will be dedicated to yoga!

Yeah that shall be so ... but not up to the attention grabbing export of terror ... International Yoga Day is 21st June only (one day) ... you guys have marketed terrorism as state policy so perfectly that it is dominating the news and thoughts day in and day out .. you got us mate .. you have marketed brilliantly and we can never hope to catch up ....

 

[vinay]

I bet 20 transponders on this new sat will be dedicated to yoga!

Isn't that nice. Now you will be able to watch and do yoga in your home.

 

[uparyupari]

So all the previous whining and ranting about 'Pakistan refusing to participate in the satellite project' was just that, whining and nonsensical propaganda to bad mouth Pakistan.

More like, pakistan has now realized its follow and wants to join the party.

 

[Hellfire]

What is India good at?

At kicking your collective behinds whenever you grew too big for your boots ... that is what it is good at ..

1. Diplomacy?
Answer: Hell no.... suppa powaa dreams of NSG and UNSC went up their hineys.

We have been doing just fine without either. UNSC is something that we want to ensure in order to continue credence to an organization which is at best redundant. As for NSG, big difference with the setback. We have bilateral agreements and open cooperation now, so insignificant except for cosmetic purposes. I hate to admit it, our politicians do have the holier-than-thou attitude and it beats me too, why we are so interested in increasingly antiquated organizations.

2. Technology?
Answer: WTF...... apparently they call "technical assistance" as "indigenous" and many other things such as ToT.... from American Sounding Rockets to Canadian Plutonium all apparently was indigenous tech...... ALMOST EVERY TECHNICAL EQUIPMENT in modern day India used from Bhabha to ISRO/DRDO is IMPORTED.... then let's not forget them beautiful brand spanking new GSLV engines from Russia? INDIGENOUS MY ASSSS...... if you can't build an aricraft engine, how the hell can you do anything else.
3. Bullshit?
Answer: Amazing at it....
Rest of the stuff is as good as hot air coming from a Mallu's hiney and they are experts and making themselves sound intelligent and mocking your intelligence.... kings of running their mouths with nonsensical numbers and vague reference to some vedic sciences!
ITS ALL INDIGENOUS.......

Big deal again ... we get what we want .. we have the megabucks .. sounding rockets? The damn ICBM program fructified with sanctions against India from 1974 .. we were just sending sounding rockets in the garb of SLVs till then .... Canadian Plutonium ??? We didn't have any post 1974.... GSLV? We had to develop it on our own in the end after the technical support and consultations were stopped towards the end as a reeling Russian economy of late 90s was pressurized by US not to give the same to us ... we cant build an aircraft engine as we love our corruption and money making ... how does it really affect you?

At no point have I found any point where you have been able to do anything other than bad mouth or sound like a dunce in an attempt at derailing a thread .. something which is expected of the majority and not someone who is being labelled as analyst ... and you are labelled "ANALYST" with a propensity to label everything as bullshit .. seems you are obsessed with the caudal regions and their derivatives and have just ended up posting just the products in your 'analysis'...

Yeah ......... Challenge us and we will overcome it in no time!

like LCA's Engine?

 

[IND151]

What was the reason for Pakistan wanting to join the project after rejecting it initially.

Der aye durust aye?

 

[New World]

why dont you say no to SAARC satellite...or else be a good boy

wah ji wah.. kya apne theka uthaya hua hai dosri SAARC members ka..

 

[Srinivas]

And ending up getting labelled a troll in the process ... !!! Any advantage of that?

who says I am a troll ? ...... oh .... ok .... fine ..... this is a small world of about 100 active members..... main thing is what I think about myself and what my well wishers think about me.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

When all members have come to a conclusion and one member is still in 'internal consultation process' is polite way of saying 'i don't agree with all you guys'

No it does not, especially when the discussions are on a highly technical project with national security ramifications and the country proposing the project is hostile.

No rational analyst would expect that Pakistani consultations on the project would not be significantly more extensive than those of other SAARC countries.

And again, was a timeline on consultations made clear? If not then this is just another one of those media distortions by Modi didi to malign Pakistan. Every State has their own process and unique concerns that need to be evaluated, and therefore it is not guaranteed that every State will finish their internal evaluation/consultations in the same time-frame.

More like, pakistan has now realized its follow and wants to join the party.

Pakistan never rejected the project or refused to participate in it, so there is no 'folly' to recognize.

The intellectual dishonesty on the part of the Indian Establishment and the Indian media, and the lack of intellectual ability (on the part of many Indians commenting on the web) to spot blatant distortions of facts in the Indian media, is just astounding.

 

[QARAMATIANS]

Unfortunate decision we should have taken the help of superco,their sounding rockets could lift 2000 kg payload.

 

[MilSpec]

What is India good at?

1. Diplomacy?
Answer: Hell no.... suppa powaa dreams of NSG and UNSC went up their hineys.

Think again, Foreign policy built and run from New Delhi, not Washington DC - can you say the same about yourself? Balanced military relation with russia, ukraine, Israel, US, Britain, France. Bilateral relations with UAE, Saudi, Iran, and Israel on the same footing. ON the NSG waiver Nuclear reactors from France Russia already signed, nuclear material from russia, canada , Australia, and US under negotiations.

2. Technology?
Answer: WTF...... apparently they call "technical assistance" as "indigenous" and many other things such as ToT.... from American Sounding Rockets to Canadian Plutonium all apparently was indigenous tech...... ALMOST EVERY TECHNICAL EQUIPMENT in modern day India used from Bhabha to ISRO/DRDO is IMPORTED.... then let's not forget them beautiful brand spanking new GSLV engines from Russia? INDIGENOUS MY ASSSS...... if you can't build an aricraft engine, how the hell can you do anything else.

American sounding rockets as a starting point reached ICMB's and SLBM's. Canadian reactors as a starting point reacher PWR's for Nuclear Subs. As far as ISRO is concerned, a good comparison would be in your backyard. Your space program if I am not mistaken started before us, and where you stand now. Now as far as Aero Engine jibe you threw, even technological power house like China, couldn't make on it's own and recently has had some success with Russian derivatives of Al31's. On the same bench mark you guys are still struggling to build a decent IC Engine.

3. Bullshit?
Answer: Amazing at it....

Well, that's holy now.

Rest of the stuff is as good as hot air coming from a Mallu's hiney and they are experts and making themselves sound intelligent and mocking your intelligence.... kings of running their mouths with nonsensical numbers and vague reference to some vedic sciences!

ITS ALL INDIGENOUS.......

Please, keep away from vedic science lines, give credit where is due. Purely on terms of technology, India is miles ahead in space program, and thus I don't see a need for any co-operation from Pakistan in this project , so I doubt the project had any scope for technological co-operation. But hopefully in the future when relations between the two normalizes, this is one field where there could be some joint programs.

 

[SrNair]

If it is a SAARC project, India should have made it a collective effort. There is no need to deny support from other members. This defeat the whole purpose of it being SAARC project. Gift in this context seem a bit condescending. Though this is my personal feeling.

Friend .You have to think about it more deeply .
According to out PM this is a gift of India to SAARC.You cant ask money from your friends for a gift that you bought for them even if they offered .
And Pakistan is just one SAARC nation perhaps they can give some monetery support,but what about our Bhutan,Nepal etc.At any case they cant give a same level of support like that of Pakistan.
So it is not just fair.So it would be our own gift .
And this is a right decision.

 

[uparyupari]

Pakistan never rejected the project or refused to participate in it, so there is no 'folly' to recognize.

The intellectual dishonesty on the part of the Indian Establishment and the Indian media, and the lack of intellectual ability (on the part of many Indians commenting on the web) to spot blatant distortions of facts in the Indian media, is just astounding.

Lets cut the BS. pakistan has zero credibility. So yes, I and the rest of the world believe the Indian govt.

 

[ravindra1455]

shayad pakistni ko koi subha ho ki kahin indian setelite me koi jasoosi equipent to nahi he ( they may want to check it out, or want to close look at our setelite programme)