India, Iran cradles of great civilizations: Iranian envoy

[arcane]

you're the only one trolling here.

u can say that dude, bramhagupta was born after aryabhatta death.....although aryabhatta never wrote any rules for the use of zero, his work implied the use of zero at many places, this is a commonly known fact.....u can come up with all the counter claims u want to, it won't change the fact.....

btw this thread is about iran and india relations, hope that india succeeds in finding a diplomatic solution to the nuclear problem, we won't like a military action against iran.......

 

[Kadamba]

the number zero was invented in Pakistan. It's the shunya, my guess is Pingala's treatizes, or if it has to be placed to someone probably it would be Brahmagupta.

Thanks for enlightening true version of history, sir.

But Before discussing it on pdf; please try to include this correct version of history, into the books of your schools, so that people over here show some seriousness to your views.

 

[LaBong]

Omg, not ancient pakistan yet again!

Khwārizmī must be ancient iraqi!

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Recetly the worlds oldest writing system was found in Iran, in a place called jiroft.But as usuall the west called it fake, this shows their respect for the Iranian people.
anyway Iranian Elamite is the lnguage which is much older than sanskrt, and apprantly it has some thing in common with the Indian dravinian languages, old persian is old too but no where near as old as elamite.

Iran has been shown many times to be older than mesepotamia in almost every aspect,
for example susa in Iran is centuries older than neigbouring mesepotmaia, even wester sites like wilkipedia say it.

So tell me why mesepotmia is considered the cradle of civilization.

Old similarities with dravidian languages??
Well another mystery is in india ....
About whether tamil or sanskrit is ancient nu.....
Scholars are equally divided in this...
IVC points out to dravidian toungue but sanskrit scholars are not avvepting this....
Perhaps india's archeological dept should check out this discovery made in iran...

 

[roadrunner]

about al khwarizmi, he might have been born in uzbekistan. I'm open for debate on what his ethnicity was. It's not clear.

---------- Post added at 01:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:26 PM ----------

u can say that dude, bramhagupta was born after aryabhatta death.....although aryabhatta never wrote any rules for the use of zero, his work implied the use of zero at many places, this is a commonly known fact.....u can come up with all the counter claims u want to, it won't change the fact.....

btw this thread is about iran and india relations, hope that india succeeds in finding a diplomatic solution to the nuclear problem, we won't like a military action against iran.......

so what? pingala's work implied use of the number zero also. but it's not attributed to him.

 

[arcane]

about al khwarizmi, he might have been born in uzbekistan. I'm open for debate on what his ethnicity was. It's not clear.

---------- Post added at 01:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:26 PM ----------




so what? pingala's work implied use of the number zero also. but it's not attributed to him.

no comments dude.........

 

[Roybot]

Can someone explain me why Aryabhatta is a Pakistani?

 

[roadrunner]

he's not. the rules for the use of zero werent laid down by him either.

 

[Roybot]

Who was it laid down by then? And how is that person a Pakistani. Thanks in advance.

 

[roadrunner]

it seems that the place of Kusumpura where arybhatta was born isn't known. Might not have been India in fact.

 

[Drawn_Sword_of_God]

you should become friends with someone for who they are and NOT what they were

 

[justanobserver]

Here we go again..."ancient Pakistan" , and how "India" was actually the region currently known as Pakistan

 

[foxbat]

Here we go again..."ancient Pakistan" , and how "India" was actually the region currently known as Pakistan

Identity crisis is the term you are looking for

 

[PERSIAN GOD KING]

Old similarities with dravidian languages??
Well another mystery is in india ....
About whether tamil or sanskrit is ancient nu.....
Scholars are equally divided in this...
IVC points out to dravidian toungue but sanskrit scholars are not avvepting this....
Perhaps india's archeological dept should check out this discovery made in iran...

That is not saying much, its obvious that your languages would had been influnced by Elamite, since it was part of a great kingdom.

 

[Roybot]

it seems that the place of Kusumpura where arybhatta was born isn't known. Might not have been India in fact.

So anyone whose birthplace is not known becomes a Pakistani? And didn't you just say he wasn't responsible for the rules of zero?