What's new

India: Democracy Soaked In Blood of Her Own People

Nassr

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 7, 2011
Messages
835
Reaction score
0
By Khan A. Sufyan

We arrived in Darzo (Mizoram, India) about ten in the morning. My orders were to get the villagers to collect whatever moveable property they could, and set their own village on fire at seven in the evening.

Night fell, I lit a torch myself and set fire to one of the houses. I knew I was carrying out orders, and would hate to do such a thing if I had my way. My soldiers also started torching other buildings, and the whole place was soon ablaze. Women were wailing and shouting and cursing. Children were frightened and cried. But the grown men were silent; not a whimper or a whisper from them. When it was time for the world to sleep, we marched out of Darzo .

We walked fifteen miles and the morning saw us in Hnahthial. I hated myself that night. I had done the job of an executioner. I called the Darzo Village Council President and his village elders and ordered them to sign a document saying that they had voluntarily asked to be resettled under the protection of the Security Forces as they were being harassed by the insurgents and that no force or coercion was used by the Security Forces.
They refused to sign. So I called them in one man at a time. On my table was a loaded revolver, and in the corner stood two NCOs with loaded sten-guns. This frightened them, and one by one they signed the documents.

(Lalkhama 2006. A Mizo Civil Servant’s Random Reflections.
Ghazaibad: Express Print House, pp.177-180)

In September 2011, state assembly of Indian Occupied Kashmir (IOK) debated a report which uncovered presence of more than 2,000 unmarked mass graves not far from the Line of Control that divides Pakistan from IOK. The report, by Indian government appointed State Human Rights Commission, also issued its first official acknowledgment of the presence of these mass graves.

Such incidents have not only been reported from IOK but many other parts of India. The atrocities committed to counter many ongoing insurgencies in the name of democratic Union of India are wide-spread, horrendous and shameful, yet only a handful of the perpetrators has ever been brought to justice.

India has been able to bring some of these insurgencies under a measure of control. Yet the wanton atrocities committed by Indian security forces and the coercive manipulation of democratic process probably has been some of the major causes why India houses one of the largest number of freedom movements and secessionist groups, insurgencies and extremist groups and in any one country in the world. Currently, there are around 140 such known groups operating in 28 Indian States and 7 Union Territories.

There are parts of India where diverse set of freedom movement groups run their own independent governments, collect taxes, maintain functional bureaucratic institutions, judiciary and maintain well organized regular and trained armies. On 30 June 2012, the Army of Government of People’s Republic of Nagaland held an openly announced passing out parade of a batch of officers at their military base Khehoi, merely 40 kilometers from Rangapahar, Dimapur. Rangapahar is the Headquarters of Indian Army 3 Corps and is a big cantonment also housing large Para-military force nearby. Yet the Indian Army and other security apparatus did not have the courage to establish the writ of Indian government.

Over 120 Indian Army battalions and over 250 para-military battalions are deployed in Occupied Kashmir. Close to 70 Indian Army battalions and over 220 para-military battalions are deployed in North East of India. Over 80 para-military battalions are also deployed in the rest of India to combat insurgencies. These forces have committed massive human rights violations. They are protected under the law, particularly the Armed Forces Special Power Act (AFSPA) for protection of Indian Army, giving it blanket cover for killing or torturing anyone.

Does anybody in the so-called civilized world know that a lady known by the name of Irom Sharmila Chanu, also known as the Iron Lady of Manipur, has been on hunger strike for the past 12 years and is being force-fed. She went on a hunger strike on 4 November 2000 in an effort to have the Government of India withdraw AFSPA from Manipur and other parts of India.

India has always blamed her neighbors, mainly Pakistan for presence of such a large number of secessionist groups. However, according to Indian media sources only 32 such groups operate in IOK, presence of which is conveniently blamed on Pakistan. Large majority of the IOK populace however blame oppression of Indian Security Forces in the killings of over 100,000 Kashmiri people. Bulk of the remaining groups around 72 in number operate in the North East of India, while the remaining are spread over the rest of Indian territory. Overall, around 30-40 percent of Indian territory has been inflicted by freedom movements and insurgencies due to un-equal treatment meted out to the local populace and atrocities committed by Indian Security Forces, who are protected by law through manipulation of democratic institutions.

In addition to this, Naxalite movement alone has spread to over 40 percent of India and is fast getting out of hand. These are poor people who have risen up in arms against a manipulative democratic dispensation in which the rich are getting richer and the poor getting poorer without any future. Even with oppressive application of large number of security forces, India is clearly losing her writ on almost 50 percent of its territory.

The neo-colonial attitude followed by Indian political elite has further exacerbated the dichotomies present in the democratic and political dispensation meted out to the population at large. Their indifferent internal economic policies sustained through oppressive application of security strategies kept hidden from the world at large through adroit media handling in order to achieve some unattainable foreign policy precepts may lead to undesirable consequences. The blind followers of Indianized Kingdom or Indianization through attempted assimilation of neo-colonial cultural fail to understand that US achieved the objectives of its state-hood as a result of a civil war in 1860s.

India apparently is fast approaching this red line, where these freedom movements and insurgencies may result in internecine civil wars in different parts of India. In their ambition to undo the 1947 partition of India, the Indian neo-colonial dispensators may further fuel the disintegration of India through a democracy soaked in blood of her own people.

India: Democracy Soaked In Blood Of Her Own People - OpEd Eurasia Review
 
. .
Do whatever is right to preserve the sovereignty of the state.I as a citizen of India have no problem what so ever in how the security forces treats anti national elements.

It has always remained like this through the entire history of human civilisation and will always be...Pakistanis are greedy people who want Kashmir valley and use different methods to show their right on the land forgetting how they themelves treat the Balouchs,secularism and what not which is laughable.

First sort out your own house then point a finger at us.
 
.
Propaganda news as usual writter by a Lahore based Pakistani writer. Anyway sorry but OP reminds me of an old member 'Ticker'.

The facts speak for themselves and the atrocities committed by Indian security forces can never be propaganda.

Some one else also accused me of impersonation. I do not know why this is being done. If it is to discourage me from posting the truth, you will not be successful.

India and her security forces have committed untold atrocities against her own minorities and these are recorded facts. The Indian minorities have been meted out collective community punishment time and time again since 1947. At times it has been handed down in the shape of destruction of minority's places of worship and on other occasions through mass murders. These facts can not be denied just because your nationalistic feelings force you into a defensive and denial mode.
 
.
Do whatever is right to preserve the sovereignty of the state.I as a citizen of India have no problem what so ever in how the security forces treats anti national elements.

It has always remained like this through the entire history of human civilisation and will always be...Pakistanis are greedy people who want Kashmir valley and use different methods to show their right on the land forgetting how they themelves treat the Balouchs,secularism and what not which is laughable.

First sort out your own house then point a finger at us.

I did not know that Indians from majority community consider Indian minorities as anti-national elements. I wonder what would you do with your minorities who probably well exceed 200 million. The Germans could only gas 6 million. Innovative as you Indians are, I am sure you'll find a way to eliminate 200 million of your own - another Mahabharata May be .......
 
.
The facts speak for themselves and the atrocities committed by Indian security forces can never be propaganda.

Some one else also accused me of impersonation. I do not know why this is being done. If it is to discourage me from posting the truth, you will not be successful.

India and her security forces have committed untold atrocities against her own minorities and these are recorded facts. The Indian minorities have been meted out collective community punishment time and time again since 1947. At times it has been handed down in the shape of destruction of minority's places of worship and on other occasions through mass murders. These facts can not be denied just because your nationalistic feelings force you into a defensive and denial mode.
Not when a country like Pakistan ranked 4th in the world for 'extreme risks' of 'human right violations' and instead it's writers are obsessed with much better India. Point fingers when your own house is in order or you'll look stupid!!
 
Last edited:
.
And 50,000 soldiers and civilians killed in Pakistan so far! Some by the TTP some by the Establishment. Human rights organizations have found hundreds of disappearances and thousands of unmarked graves in Balochistan!

Scores of people being killed in Karachi daily. Shia-Sunni conflicts resulting in spilling blood on the streets.....

Instead the headline of this thread should read:
Pakistan: Democracy Soaked In Blood of Her Own People
 
. .
In India congress is using democracy to suck blood and money from Indians.
 
. .
Kashmir obsession.....but nobody cares about thousands of dead n displaced kashmiri pandits

maoists......can be swept out in hours ......but vote bank politics wont allow it
 
.
And 50,000 soldiers and civilians killed in Pakistan so far! Some by the TTP some by the Establishment. Human rights organizations have found hundreds of disappearances and thousands of unmarked graves in Balochistan!

Scores of people being killed in Karachi daily. Shia-Sunni conflicts resulting in spilling blood on the streets.....

Instead the headline of this thread should read:
Pakistan: Democracy Soaked In Blood of Her Own People

50,000 Pakistani soldiers are killed in fighting against TERRORISTS, in War on Terror. Not fighting against insurgents. :)


So your comparison here is dead wrong.


On the other hand Mizo or even if you talk about North East Indian trouble it has always been civilian fight for resources and your own govt never declared them terrorists.

I dint read whats there in the opening post just after glancing at the first para, since i keenly study the insurgencies hence i avoided commenting on that. Therefore replied to your wrong comparison.

Wont talk about Indian democracy and its link to NE but i can say that these insurgencies in India are result of attitude of Indian govts since long who have always ignored to address the core issues of these people.

From start these were NOT separatist movements but Indian govt's attitude added fuel to fire.
 
.
look at you pakistanis and then raise finger to anyone else...... go have some land reform ....kick ttp and same minded pu$$ey and the lecture others......
 
.
The first section about Mizoram is old history. The incidents described happened in 1966 to 1968. Incidentally, Mizoram is the only place within Indian borders where the Indian Air Force had to be called into action against Indian citizens in 1966. Since then, especially after signing a peace accord with the Mizo National Front, Mizoram is now possibly the most peaceful state in India. It is certainly the most literate and the most civil state in India. Its elections are a marvel. There are no processions, no ugly posters or hoardings, no sloganeering during elections. Public election meetings are organised by the civil society and the church, and candidates are called to state their case. All candidates are given time to have their say and then the crowd disperses peacefully only to come on election day and to vote. This year the voter turnout was about 73%, which is low by Mizoram standards. There is no violence, no exchange of money or liquor. It it a remarkable place.

Re the unmarked graves in Kashmir, I would only say that a lot of them belong to infiltrators from across the border. Why, there are 9 unloved and unmarked in a jail in Mumbai plus another unloved but not unknown.
 
.
The facts speak for themselves and the atrocities committed by Indian security forces can never be propaganda.
Some one else also accused me of impersonation. I do not know why this is being done. If it is to discourage me from posting the truth, you will not be successful.
India and her security forces have committed untold atrocities against her own minorities and these are recorded facts. The Indian minorities have been meted out collective community punishment time and time again since 1947. At times it has been handed down in the shape of destruction of minority's places of worship and on other occasions through mass murders. These facts can not be denied just because your nationalistic feelings force you into a defensive and denial mode.
If you are so inclined to post the truth, I ask you to post the truth about minorities killing in Pakistan and war crimes by Pakistan forces (war crimes happen in any long time struggle).

Mention me on that thread. Lets see if you do that.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom