If Indians were racist, why would we live with black people in the South, says BJP’s Tarun Vijay

[nang2]

Freudian slip

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Thank you master for living with us and, of course, plundering our wealth from South India to Hindi states.

True,Five south Indian states (Tamil nadu,Kerala,Karnataka,Telangana,Andhra) collectively contributing 30 percent of revenue budget of India but getting only 20 percent budget money in return.It is a sad state of affairs that south Indian are subsidizing the very people who are abusing them and looking down of them.

 

[patman]

True,Five south Indian states (Tamil nadu,Kerala,Karnataka,Telangana,Andhra) collectively contributing 30 percent of revenue budget of India but getting only 20 percent budget money in return.It is a sad state of affairs that south Indian are subsidizing the very people who are abusing them and looking down of them.

As a south indian, i find your concerns amusing.we are Indians first , besides south indian politicians hold more power in central.

That aside , your logic can be applied to nearly any of the largest countries in the world .

 

[patman]

And dogs are one of the most beautiful creatures on this earth.

Being compared to them is not a bad thing, especially by people whose PM looks like a pig that ate a pig.

I forgot Indians marry dogs.

@waz @The Eagle

 

[DineshS]

I forgot Indians marry dogs.

I have no knowledge of the marriage practices of Sunni Indians - I will take your word for it

 

[ohmrlobalobayeh]

the most hilarious thing is, bordering on bizarre- that the vast majority of Indians themselves, except for the fair north area bordering Pakistan- are dark-skinned.

The dark-skinned looks down on dark-skinned. just change their DNA to those of East asians or Caucasians if they really have such skin colour inferiority complex.

haha

 

[DineshS]

The dark-skinned looks down on dark-skinned. just change their DNA to those of East asians or Caucasians if they really have such skin colour inferiority complex.

You just explained what happens all over the world.

perhaps you should read the genesis of why Bangladesh was formed. It was all about color.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

As a south indian, i find your concerns amusing.we are Indians first , besides south indian politicians hold more power in central.

That aside , your logic can be applied to nearly any of the largest countries in the world .

I dont think so,BJP is overwhelmingly a north Indian political party which is in power.Even Congress is mainly a north Indian party.

In other large democracy,the states which contribute the most,command respect and influence greater than the others.But not in case with India.It is always thr North Indian Punjabi and Hindi speaker that take the elitist position within India.They are imposing their cultural hagemony over rest of India.Although South Indian are more prosperous,educated and civilized.This is a fact no one can deny it.

 

[patman]

the most hilarious thing is, bordering on bizarre- that the vast majority of Indians themselves, except for the fair north area bordering Pakistan- are dark-skinned.

The dark-skinned looks down on dark-skinned. just change their DNA to those of East asians or Caucasians if they really have such skin colour inferiority complex.

haha

I always find it funny how you Pakistanis think you are white , this entire subcontinent is & always has been predominantly brown.

 

[manlion]

True,Five south Indian states (Tamil nadu,Kerala,Karnataka,Telangana,Andhra) collectively contributing 30 percent of revenue budget of India but getting only 20 percent budget money in return.It is a sad state of affairs that south Indian are subsidizing the very people who are abusing them and looking down of them.

After all, 20% of the population contributes a full 30% of India's tax revenues. This is the money that runs the country.

The South also delivers a fourth of India's GDP. It is not only an economic bellwether with low unemployment, a high rate of industrialisation and a per capita GDP that is over double that of the Hindi belt, it is also leaps ahead on human development and social indicators.

Child development indices are double to 7 times higher than the Hindi states, literacy rates tend towards an average of 80% with a 10-point difference against the North, and accessibility to health and hygiene facilities is radically better.

The gulf in human development is so stark that while fertility rates in the South are closer to that of Western Europe, much of the North is still getting their act together on basic issues like birthing babies without losing mothers.

The bottom line is that the development politics of the South has made it economically comparable to Hong Kong, while the atavistic politics of the North has dropped it far down the scales in the last six decades.

Like a Shakespearean drama though, the heroes with higher state GDP per capita, that is, Net State GDP per person, receive a lower devolution from centre to state, of state revenues. The South is effectively slammed for having scaled up its per capita incomes to the top 10 in India and scaled down poverty to half that of the rest of India

A measly fifth of the population sponsors India's tax revenues to the tune of a third of the total, and in return, the five Deccan states get a paltry 18% of funds allocated back from the centre.

Source: Business Standard

http://www.thenewsminute.com/articl...ern-collective-get-us-better-deal-delhi-46501

 

[kvpak]

Source: Business Standard

Will you please post the URL of that web page? Thanks.

 

[patman]

I dont think so,BJP is overwhelmingly a north Indian political party

That's not how politics work , there have been more south indian presidents and prime minister's than the much more populous north indian States.

6 south Indian president from south india .

Even Congress is mainly a north Indian party.

Bjp rules goa & Karnataka was under bjp & now under congress rule. Congress & bjp have strong parties in all Indian states .

In other large democracy,the states which contribute the most,command respect and influence greater than the others.

Dude tamil nadu , Karnataka are one of the most influential states in India , hell the same with andhra before they split telengana .

Why do you think india helped the sri Lankan tamils in their civil war , that's how much power Tamil nadu has. You clearly are clueless on the topic aren't you.

But not in case with India.It is always thr North Indian Punjabi and Hindi speaker that take the elitist position within India.

North india from Maharashtra to bihar to Up makes up 60% of the Indian population , obviously they will have more representation. A Real democracy splits power , they don't gobble it under a hand full of states.

They are imposing their cultural hagemony over rest of India.Although South Indian

Lol , they are trying to integrate India under hindi , which most states are opposed to , punjab used to teach tamil & telgu as a secondry language insted of Hindi.

Its the same identity crises faced by all large nations , like Russia and China .

The solution we came up with is simple , to introduce a neutral language as a bridge , aka English. Which is why all multilingual Indian states are so fluent in English.

.

 

[kvpak]

we are Indians first

Not me. I am a Tamil-that's it. Not Indian.

besides south indian politicians hold more power in central.

Nooooo. All power rests with Hindi politicians an subservient non-Hindi-ans like Modi. When Deve Gowda from Karnataka was PM, he read his independence day speech in Hindi (written in Kannada script because he did not know Hindi but just read whatever Hindi-ans wrote for him)

there have been more south indian presidents and prime minister's than the much more populous north indian States

Numbers does not matter. These subservient south Indian politicians serve the Hindi politicians. They do what Hindia.ns want.

Why do you think india helped the sri Lankan tamils in their civil war

You are clueless about the Sri Lankan Tamil vs Sinhala/Hindi-an war, are n't you? Indian did not help Tamils, it funded trained instructed Sinhala army to massacre Tamils. Indian army specialists were in war zone to help Sinhala army. How else was a Indian radar specialists killed by Tamil Air strike?

 

[manlion]

Will you please post the URL of that web page? Thanks.

http://www.thenewsminute.com/articl...ern-collective-get-us-better-deal-delhi-46501

The state allocations speak to the quantum of skew. While Tamil Nadu gets about 40 paise for every rupee it generates for the centre, Uttar Pradesh fattens itself on Rs 1.8 per rupee it generates. It should be remembered that Uttar Pradesh had a distinct economic and social advantage over the southern states coming out of British rule, which it has simply squandered away through mis-governance and profligacy. The South, in turn, for prioritising education, health, economy and social reform, as governments should, receives the proverbial slap

Going beyond states and in keeping with the gross disproportion, the Urban Development Ministry allocated Rs 20,000 crores in 2016 for the development of Delhi alone. That, is more than the cumulative allocations for Hyderabad, Bengaluru, Chennai and Kochi. This, when the cities of the South are the top job creators for India with massive immigration for both the formal and informal sectors, levying a heavy strain on infrastructure and urban development.

In putting India ahead of narrow regional interests and generating extraordinary tax revenues to fund Delhi, UP, Bihar, MP and the overpopulated, under-educated, under-delivering, and over-pandered Hindi belt, the south carries a heavy cross year after year. For this achievement, the south gets a fiscal allocation downside, as vote-bank electioneering of the north overrides federalist policies.

Moral? The lower the per capita income and higher the population, the greater the reward. In other words, a Dakshin Bharat Cess.

Below is the Fourteenth Finance Commission's own admission of percent of states' GDP transferred by centre, with a 2-5x tilt towards UP or Bihar or MP.

Adding salt to the economic injury, the South gets a step-motherly treatment culturally as well. Funds for the preservation and nurturing of its unique identity and autonomy are negligible to non-existent. The propagation of Hindi, for example, just one of the official languages of India, gets thirty times the amount allocated for all other languages combined!

What is taken from the South and what is returned for its development reeks of bias. What then is the solution when democratically rendered justifications, pleas, complaints, negotiations and bargains have failed to strike a chord for decades?

 

[patman]

Not me. I am a Tamil-that's it. Not Indian.

Lol right, as a guy who knows 6 languages and with family in TN , I'll like to see you talk .


Tamil :
dai nii Tamilia poda poramboku , nav vare naadu illa ,namaku orea naadu ave da India.
Kannada:
Ayo nin, le ganchali bedu , nan desha nin deasha andere India inda odhu kalistini
Telugu:
Ni yankama e dasham ni yabb som kadu , e dasham lo undaki estam lekapotai muskoni anglamki nadu ki po


If you are even remotely south indian , you will be able to understand any of these languages. We already proved the other "Tamil-wannabe" troll in this thread is a fake.

Nooooo. All power rests with Hindi politicians an subservient non-Hindi-ans like Modi.

Obviously northern belt will have more power , they make up 60% of the population. That doesn't mean south indian states don't have power , i still can't believe they accepted karunanidis biased arguments , the dude & his daughter should have been hung for all their corruption .

When Deve Gowda from Karnataka was PM, he read his independence day speech in Hindi

Deve gowda doesn't know hindi , he's not from dakshina Karnataka .the guy is like 80 he won't lean even if he wants to. Only 43% of India even speaks hindi.

(written in Kannada script because he did not know Hindi but just read whatever Hindi-ans wrote for him)

Ya and same with manmohan singh , the dude wrote it in punjabi .he could have said it in English , no one would still have given a fuk.

All large nations go through this identity crises, how do you think muslim regions in former Soviet states speak Russian. Why do you think tibet is fluent in mandarin instead of Tibetan.

Numbers does not matter. These subservient south Indian politicians serve the Hindi politicians. They do what Hindia.ns want.

Number are everything. Saying south indian states don't have power is ridiculously laughable.