Houses of Afghan nationals bulldozed in Torkham

[saiyan0321]

We really need to end this rubbish now. Its been over 40 years now and according to afghab posters the Taliban are basically dead and Afghanistan is peaceful so these Afghans cab go back. We cannot endure their burden on our economy any longer... We need to continue the repatriation process and make sure they don't come back from their heavenly Afghanistan.

 

[Zibago]

Do not support bulldozing of home for people who have valid registration cards or valid ID issue by Pakistan

Other folks should be respectfully asked to return to Afghanistan

I always feel Afghanistan is better suited to be territory of Pakistan
Problem are hardliners , not general public

Not appropriate to force folks any where

Loy Afghanistan cancel Loy Pakistan

Where will these people stay after their homes are bulldozed. Believe it or not these war ravaged afghans do have flesh and blood just like pakistanis. May be they lack piece of paper called citizenship but they also have feelings similar to pakistanis. Is this how secular liberal Pakistan treats refugees?

Those who are registered can stay those who are not can go back we have 200 million others to take care of we have more refugees than Germany

Where will these people stay after their homes are bulldozed. Believe it or not these war ravaged afghans do have flesh and blood just like pakistanis. May be they lack piece of paper called citizenship but they also have feelings similar to pakistanis. Is this how secular liberal Pakistan treats refugees?

If i make home on govt land my home will be demolished its the law you cant occupy someone else,s property though i would want this law to be implemented on the big fishes and not only to the common man

 

[shah1398]

A lighter hand should be used, all this will do is create resentment, and cause these Afghans to support the TTP when they go back to Afghanistan.

Sir lighter hand for 25 whole years resulted in what we are seeing and experiencing now. Its the illegal ones who are asked to leave and the same bunch are causing most of troubles. Those who have legal cover are dealt with as per law.

 

[Dalit]

Most of Afghani like to live with India according to ( Afghan defence forrum in PDF).Now it is the responsibility of Afghan defence forum to sent these Afghani to India.The Indian govt should to accommodate them in their country near Pakistan border and use them against Pakistan. ( My suggestion to Afghan defence forum.)

That is a lying Afghan for you. They say one thing, but the numbers don't lie. These Afghans love to illegally enter Pakistani territory. Millions are still in Pakistan and don't want to leave. We are forced to use such measures to expell illegal Afghans from our soil.

Build a great wall and send back illegal Afghans. Those who are legally here need to be monitored closely. Make Afghanistan pay for the great wall.

North alliance is only responsible for the unrest in our country not Pashtuns

Only Persian people dislike Pakistan who are in the government

LOL I know how Iran treats these Afghan "Persians". Iran beats up Afghans and sends them back to Afghanistan in the thousands on a monthly basis.

 

[Super Falcon]

Pakistan repeating mistakes over mistakes

We don't accept those Bangladeshi Pakistanis who still don't recognize Bangladesh for love of Pak we forgotten them but we feeding traitors

Agreed we should have sent them to Afghanistan it's not right way to create someone's heart a bad thing for Pak

 

[باپ]

Bad move, in my view Pushtoon on both side of Duradline are Pakistanis

No they are not. There is a country called Pakistan now and it has it's citizens.
Just being pushtoon doesn't mean Afghani are also Pakistani.
Pretty racist mentality

 

[That Guy]

Sir lighter hand for 25 whole years resulted in what we are seeing and experiencing now. Its the illegal ones who are asked to leave and the same bunch are causing most of troubles. Those who have legal cover are dealt with as per law.

Actually, no hand was given for the last many decades, due to international obligations.

They are not in Canada, far away from Afghanistan receiving western education. Remember Pakistan border area is not much difference from Afghanistan. illiteracy, crime, drug poverty. They still got the same mindset. For them KPK is part of Afghanistan and Pakistan is illegally occupying it. I went to Afghanistan and I was told, everything till Jehlum is Afghan land and durand line is just British creation.

Lack of education within the border areas of Pakistan is Pakistan's own fault. It should have been investing in educations far more, and the lack of funding that the education sector gets is absolutely abhorrent.

The tribal laws in the area should have been abolished, and the area should have been brought within the fold of Pakistan as well, a long time ago.

You cannot blame the Afghanis for your own government's incompetence.

They had more than a decade to prove it , They failed!

They were never given a chance.

Every single argument I've heard is based upon emotion, not facts and realistic expectations.

 

[salarsikander]

Where will these people stay after their homes are bulldozed. Believe it or not these war ravaged afghans do have flesh and blood just like pakistanis. May be they lack piece of paper called citizenship but they also have feelings similar to pakistanis. Is this how secular liberal Pakistan treats refugees?

Hi,

This is just one move. Why dont you also focus towards how many Bengali, Burmese, and Afghani we have as refugees n our country ?

 

[Genghis khan1]

Actually, no hand was given for the last many decades, due to international obligations.


Lack of education within the border areas of Pakistan is Pakistan's own fault. It should have been investing in educations far more, and the lack of funding that the education sector gets is absolutely abhorrent.

The tribal laws in the area should have been abolished, and the area should have been brought within the fold of Pakistan as well, a long time ago.

You cannot blame the Afghanis for your own government's incompetence.


They were never given a chance.

Every single argument I've heard is based upon emotion, not facts and realistic expectations.

Your approach is way too civilized and not practical considering the realities on ground. There is a long list of thing that Pakistan and Pakistanis should have done. Nothing works in Pakistan, no one make sense there. Tribal, Taliban, MQM, govt, people. Everybody is looking for a shortcut to make quick 2 bucks for themselves and would not mind fucking fellow Pakistani or nation integrity over for it.

 

[Tps43]

These afghans dont spare any thing for criticizing pakistan be it at home or any place in the world

 

[Samandri]

While there is justification for this action....what was the justification for demolishing the houses of IDPs from Mohmand agency in Islamabad and treating them very badly?. Tomorrow there might be military in settled area of KPK , its people will become "Mohajir" and neither Sindh, nor Punjab and Balochistan will welcome them and will demolish their shelters on some pretext, ... ..i used to scold those Pashtun brothers of mine who used to laugh at the misery and refugee status of the Afghans, i stiil do, now for ooking down on IDPs from FATA. May Allah prevent us from becoming "zaleel o khwar" mohajir or idp

 

[Luffy 500]

Hi,

This is just one move. Why dont you also focus towards how many Bengali, Burmese, and Afghani we have as refugees n our country ?

So ? What abt them? Aren't they human first before bengali , burmese or afghani?

 

[B+ Dracula]

While there is justification for this action....what was the justification for demolishing the houses of IDPs from Mohmand agency in Islamabad and treating them very badly?. Tomorrow there might be military in settled area of KPK , its people will become "Mohajir" and neither Sindh, nor Punjab and Balochistan will welcome them and will demolish their shelters on some pretext, ... ..i used to scold those Pashtun brothers of mine who used to laugh at the misery and refugee status of the Afghans, i stiil do, now for ooking down on IDPs from FATA. May Allah prevent us from becoming "zaleel o khwar" mohajir or idp

Iam thinking about the small little Kids...what they will do right after seeing their sweet shelter demolished....??
.
wait a minute.... Why I've to worry about them....my home ladies have no restlessness nights, we enjoy spare time on Laptop trumpeting lectures on nationalism then before going to bed we enjoy 8 o clock Political show ...?
.
day end's
.
Afghans Idps are doing meager jobs to have their both hands meet, they're not burden to our pocket then on what moral ground 'me' implying to them as "Haram khor" or other ego-full words....??

 

[salarsikander]

So ? What abt them? Aren't they human first before bengali , burmese or afghani?

Hi,

Coming extremely rich from a country whose SECULAR prime minister on record disregarded the Humanity when she clearly states it is not our problem to deal with Burmese. Please ! Officially speaking we have hosted far large number of refugees than you guys can ever imagine. So how about setting your house in order first.

 

[Dalit]

No ifs and buts. We all know how illegal Afghans are tied up and chased down with machetes in other lands. You know how they treat people who chase down illegal Afghans in certain European capitals? Like heroes! Pakistanis have destroyed their nation by turning a blind eye towards this enormous problem. Trying to reason and act sentimental won't resolve the problem. Illegal Afghans are an immense problem. They resort to terror activities, criminality and act innocent. It is time to protect our borders from infiltration. If other provinces apart from KPK and AJK feel that Afghans should stay in Pakistan they should take in the Afghans. KPK and AJK are overwhelmed by illegal Afghans and we cannot bear the burden anymore. We don't need any lecturing from other provinces on this matter. Other provinces should take in Afghans instead of cheap talking. Otherwise let KPK and AJK perform its duty by protecting its land and people from illegal Afghan invaders. Enough is enough.