This is thread of 2010, my views are still same on this matter. Though i would like to add the history and origin of pathan and Sardar jokes which are rooted in Punjab and U.P/Delhi region.
The Hate and dislike for Pathans , that are expressed through jokes, comes from military expeditions of Abdali in Punjab and areas around Delhi, to consolidate his rule. They were not locals so needed some plundering to feed their large army (who has not done plundering?). Note that in panipat they didnt need to plunder as most of the musalmans in panipat area were of Afghan descent who were cooperating with their kinsmen Rohillas and Durranis. Punjab was ruled by mughals for two centuries and was not subjected to foreign invasions for these two centuries, mughals were excellent administrators and they were loved by punjabi muslims. Nadir Shah was the first invader after such long period and he destroyed the punjab region and delhi, his troops army had large Afghan contingent , somehow nadir shah himself was perceived as Afghan by punjabis and delhwis (they remember him as nadir shah durrani rather than afshar). Read urdu poetry of that time, it is deeply affected by nadir shah sacking of delhi and massacring its inhabitants. Its no coincidence that muslim Punjabis and urduspeakers of U.P/delhi have hateful jokes for sikhs as well as pashtuns. The dislike for both dates back to chaotic 18th century. Sikh misals also looted delhi and U.P. In addition to Sikhs, people of delhi and awadh also experienced fearsome Rohilla Pashtuns of Doab, one of whom in 1788 humiliated mughal emperor and his family.
Ahamd Shah abdali not only ended much respected mughal rule (among muslims) in punjab but they also had not forgotten that he was part of nadir shah's military expedition. The most acute problem for punjabi muslims at that time were sikh misals who were terror for them, Abdali led several military expeditions against sikh misals, who were terrorizing muslim populations, but the enemies used to retreat to hills instead of offering war. Punajbi musalmans blame Ahmad shah for sikh problem, the argument was that mughals were much efficient in dealing with sikhs. Terror of Sikh misals got imprinted in meek muslamans of Punajb and Delhi and U.P, who expressed their anger and hate through either poetry or through jokes.
@
Pakistanisage
@
Nuri Natt