What's new

Cost of construction of Metro Rail in Dhaka is much higher than India.

Even the whole phase I of Hyderabad metro costs just 31 million per km.

Hyd can go up to 90s frequency if needed, only thing needed is more rolling stock which isn't much costly.

No, stations cannot be rebuilt for longer trains/more passengers, upgrading signalling too is costly. These systems are designed to be 'future-proof', so need for spending further on this do not arise.
I think, there a difference of how cost is calculated in Bangladesh and in India.As most of our project is foreign financed and foreign constructed, so our cost estimate shows the total, final cost including all relevant and associated component into one package.One Example is a 1,320 MW thermal power plant in Cox's bazar. Our media tell us that it will cost 4.5 billion dollar.Many Indian and Pakistanis here raised question about how it can be possible to cost so much to build just 1,320 MW thermal power plant? When similar capacity power plant were build in elsewhere by just 1 billion dollar? But this 4.5 billion include many other relevant structure which is not necessarily part of the power plant. Like construction of deep sea port to import coal, road infrastructure to transfer the coal from port to powerplant, transmission line etc. We calculate all these cost under one single package with the heading of 'coal fired power plant cost'. Dhaka metro also contain many cost which is not directly related to metro rail infrastructure, like land acquisition, shifting of utility lines etc. I think this type of calculation is absent in Indian metro or other infrastructure cost calculation. Associated costs are counted separately.
 
.
.
3 billion US dollars to connect the SW of BD, that has as much people as whole of Kerala

And for a single line, non electrified line ? Could have built an HSR.

As most of our project is foreign financed and foreign constructed

Projects in most developing countries are financed by JICA, ADB, AFD etc.

Dhaka metro also contain many cost which is not directly related to metro rail infrastructure, like land acquisition, shifting of utility lines etc. I think this type of calculation is absent in Indian metro or other infrastructure cost calculation.

It is included in the cost estimates in the DPR.

Google 'name of any Indian metro + detailed project report' and you'll get the DPR in PDF format. Look under 'cost estimate' tab and tell me what you see.
 
Last edited:
.
And for a single line, non electrified line ? Could have built an HSR.

No two lines all the way, apart from the single line over Padma Bridge section.
The amount of stations, locomotives and coaches required would be far in excess in your state. Add in say 3m embankments all the way due to flooding, then the cost is reasonable.
 
. .
Bangladeshis on this thread are trying very hard to justify their incompetence and high corruption. They are making excuses of all kind except for arriving at the truth. Fact of the matter there's just no local industry to support with these kind of endeavors. All had to be imported hence the high costs. All banian export money is going back out to the world.
 
.
So your most dense metro come head in head with Dhaka. Per km cost of Hyderabad is $38.1 million and Dhaka is $135 million. But it can be explained by the first world(Japan) construction compared to Indian quality(non aesthetic, rust bucket as I have said earlier). Also all things required to import from Japan.But in a long run, Dhaka metro will give more bang for it's buck. You can consider the Lifespan issue.Do not expect, run down Hyderabad metro which is built by using cheap, shoddy, low quality Indian materials will last same years like Dhaka metro without renovation and added cost.
We have metros in 10 cities and already operational... 5 metros are under construction... Many cities are planning for metro systems... We have nothing to prove more...
 
.
They were trying to compare high capacity Padma Bridge railway with low capacity lines in a minor Indian state.:lol:


You mean something like this????

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...ge-to-begin-in-march/articleshow/57172147.cms
Work on Bidupur-Dargah bridge to begin in March
TNN | Feb 16, 2017, 11:26 IST

PATNA: The actual construction of piers (pillars) on the six-lane Kachchi Dargah-Bidupur bridge over the Ganga is expected to commence from March 10.
The ADB entered into an agreement with the government of India on November 15 last year for extending a loan of USD 500 million (Rs 3,000 crore) for the ambitious bridge project in Bihar.

"Work will soon begin on a new piece of infrastructure that will help fill the urgent need for bridge connections in Bihar. The new Ganga bridge, supported by ADB, will be built 10km downstream and east of the capital Patna and is likely to be India's longest river bridge with a length of almost 10km," said a blog on the ADB website by Saleha Waseem, operations communications specialist of South Asia regional department in the ADB.

CM Nitish Kumar commissioned the construction work of the bridge in presence of RJD chief Lalu Prasad and his sons Tej Pratap Yadav and Tejashwi Prasad Yadav on January 31 last year.

___________________________________________________________________________

Or something like this????

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...ngest-railway-bridge/articleshow/51074696.cms

Katni to have India's longest railway bridge

Bhopal: Katni in Madhya Pradesh will have India's longest railway bridge, 14 km on the up line, almost three and half times longer than Vembanad rail bridge in Kerala that connects Edappally and Vallarpadam in Kochi and is 4.62 km long.

Called Katni grade separator, down line of the bridge would be of 7 km. Its total length would be 21 km up and down side.

Project received clearance from Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) recently along with other railway projects. Design and survey of the bridge has been completed and it will take 5 years for completion.

________________________________________________________________

Or something like this??

https://www.railway-technology.com/projects/chenab-bridge-jammu-kashmir/

Chenab Bridge, Jammu and Kashmir, India

1l-image-35.jpg

Chenab_project_7L.jpg


3l-image-35.jpg


Chenab Bridge is an under-construction rail bridge, located between Bakkal and Kauri in the Reasi district of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K), India. The 1,315m-long bridge is being built at a height of 359m. Once completed, it will be the tallest rail bridge in the world.

The INR5.12bn ($92m) bridge is a part of Jammu-Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla Rail Line(JUSBRL) project being undertaken by the Ministry of Indian Railways. The bridge will include a 14m-wide dual carriageway and a 1.2m-wide central verge.

The project is expected to be finished by March 2016 and will have a lifespan of 120 years. It will contribute to the economic development of the state and help in providing better transportation accessibility within the state and the country.

Chenab Bridge design details
Chenab Bridge forms a massive steel arch, the first of its kind in India. The country has no codes or design guidance for such massive structures. Based on experiences drawn from similar projects worldwide, the design practices for the bridge are being followed.

BS: 5400 is being used as the basic guideline for the design and construction of the bridge. The deep Chenab river valley under the bridge is prone to high wind pressure risking the stability of the bridge.

Norway-based Force Technology Laboratory conducted several wind tunnel tests to understand the effects of wind speed, static force coefficients and gust buffeting. The bridge is designed to resist wind speeds of up to 260kmph. The seismic nature of the project zone was also considered during its design.

The bridge will include 17 spans, as well as the 469m main arch span across the Chenab River, and viaducts on either side. The main span of the bridge will include two 36m-long approach spans. It will be built as a two ribbed arch with steel trusses made of concrete-filled sealed steel boxes. The structure will be supported by two 130m-long, 100m-high pylons on either end through cables.

Steel was chosen to construct the bridge as it will be more economical and able to resist temperatures of -20C and wind speeds of above 200kmph. The Jammu and Kashmir region witnesses frequent terrorist attacks. To enhance safety and security, the bridge will be made of 63mm-thick special blast-proof steel. The concrete pillars of the bridge are designed to withstand explosions.

A ring of aerial security will be provided to safeguard the bridge. An online monitoring and warning system will be installed on the bridge to protect the passengers and train in critical conditions. Footpaths and cycle trails will be provided adjacent to it. The bridge will be painted with a special corrosion-resistant paint, which lasts for 15 years.

Bridge construction and challenges faced
The bridge is being constructed in one of the most complicated and isolated terrains. One of the biggest challenges involved was construction of the bridge without obstructing the flow of the river. Approach roads, five kilometres in length, were constructed to reach the foundations of the bridge.

The deck of the bridge is partly in straight horizon and partly in curves. It is located on a transition curve with changing radius. Construction is therefore being carried out in stages following the gradual change in the alignment. This is the first time a bridge is being constructed incrementally on a transition curve.

Cable cranes and derrick will be used to construct the bridge. The cable cranes used for the project will be the largest in the world.

Construction of the bridge is expected to require 25,000mt of steel, 4,000mt of reinforced steel, 46,000m³ of concrete and eight million m³ of excavation.

Contractors involved in constructing the Indian bridge
Amberg Engineering was appointed to carry out review work of the alignments. Konkan Railway Corporation is executing the project. Design and construction of the bridge was awarded to a joint venture of Afcons Infrastructure, Ultra Construction & Engineering Company of South Korea and VSL India in 2004.

Finland-based WSP Group and Germany-based Leonhardt Andra and Partners are the consultants for the project. VCE Consult ZT-GmbH designed the pylons of the bridge. Jochum Andreas Seiltransporte installed the cables for the pylon. AkzoNobel was awarded the painting services contract for the bridge.
 
Last edited:
. . . .
We are talking about 200 km long track for Padma Bridge railway and not a few tens of kms.

How Bidi construct railway track to connect bridge?????

Around the world they just construct bridges only, no need to connect it with tracks!!!!

Bidi is special.
 
.
We are talking about 200 km long track for Padma Bridge railway and not a few tens of kms.


Of course you are not going to build 200km bridge and the bridge will be built over river bed.
 
. . .
Back
Top Bottom